4 ms·

I think there is a similar situation with guitar tuning where the G string can either be tuned to a 4th above the D string, or a Maj3 below B string, which are

by meggar 12y ago

I think there is a similar situation with guitar tuning where the G string can either be tuned to a 4th above the D string, or a Maj3 below B string, which are not exactly equal, so guitar chords are usually a tiny bit out of tune.

neonscribe 12y ago
No, the Maj3 interval between the 2nd and 3rd strings on the guitar is unrelated to this issue. It's just the fret spacing on the guitar that causes it to have equal temperament and therefore makes chords slightly "out of tune".
- elihu 12y ago
  Incidentally, a just (non-tempered) guitar fingerboard might look something like this: http://jsnow.bootlegether.net/cbg/fingerboard_at_a.svg http://jsnow.bootlegether.net/cbg/fingerboard_at_a.svg I swapped fingerboards on an old Harmony Archtone with one based on the above design. Admittedly, 20 notes per octave may have been a bit much; it's kind of awkward to play. The next one I do will be simpler. Sounds nice, though.
  - gnaritas 12y ago
    Just remove the frets, problem solved.
    - elihu 12y ago
      Fretless is difficult to play accurately, especially for chords. Also, you get a louder sound from frets because your fingers aren't muting the strings quite so much.
      - gnaritas 11y ago
        Of course, but it does solve all such intonation problems.