6 ms·
> No one uses bike helmets in Berlin, because Berlin is safe for bicycles That's not why people don't wear helmets there, and that's not a reason to not wear o
by stronglikedan 12y ago
> No one uses bike helmets in Berlin, because Berlin is safe for bicycles
That's not why people don't wear helmets there, and that's not a reason to not wear one.
I would have been in a world of hurt if I didn't have a helmet on when I fell. No cars, people, or other moving object were anywhere near me. My tire hit a slippery patch as I was turning, and I went over sideways. I broke my shoulder and my hand, and my head hit the ground so hard that my glasses flattened out on the pavement. I considered myself lucky that I didn't have a head injury, aside from my bell being rung - hard.
Wear a helmet. They not only save you from dangerous environmental situations, but they save you from yourself.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> Wear a helmet. They not only save you from dangerous environmental situations, but they save you from yourself. http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/do-bike-helmet-laws-really-save-people/2013/06/03/6a6532b4-c6df-11e2-9245-773c0123c027_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/do-bik... http://www.californiahealthline.org/insight/2015/bicycle-helmet-bill-changed-from-mandate-to-call-for-study http://www.californiahealthline.org/insight/2015/bicycle-hel... http://greatergreaterwashington.org/post/19036/feds-will-stop-hyping-effectiveness-of-bike-helmets/ http://greatergreaterwashington.org/post/19036/feds-will-sto...
- kevinnk 12y agoThere isn't much question that helmets reduce injury. The larger question of "should they be mandatory" is still open (with a strong lean towards "no.") From the first article. "Even most opponents of mandatory helmet laws advocate helmet use, but they say that the negative consequences of helmet laws outweigh the benefits." From the third. "If you consider the entire body of research rather than just one study, and look at both head and neck injuries, helmets only reduce the risk of injury by about 15% to 45% ."
- panglott 12y agoWearing a helmet would also improve the safety of people driving or walking around. But strangely we don't hear all the nagging lectures for people to wear a helmet when they are driving or walking to a corner store, whether or not it's on a quiet street in fine weather.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNegligible for walking. Its different to be hurtling along at 20mph on a contraption of pipes, gears and chains and hit a storm drain, launching headfirst into the back of a parked car, than to trip and skin your knee. One requires a helmet to survive. And driving - there's airbags and the steel cage and belts and padding. Another storey altogether.
- panglott 12y agoWalking is pretty dangerous: you could be walking and spontaneously stumble, or slip on wet leaves, and clip your temple on a fire hydrant. That's it for you! Walking is quite dangerous, and is in fact has the highest rate of injuries and fatalities per mile traveled. That's mostly because pedestrians get hit by cars, but that's surely an even better reason to get pedestrians to wear helmets. What if you get hit by a car while walking? As for motorists: http://www.copenhagenize.com/2009/10/australian-helmet-science-for-motorists.html http://www.copenhagenize.com/2009/10/australian-helmet-scien...
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI suggest all walking accidents are possible on a bike as well. While bicycles have even more potential accidents.
- panglott 12y agoMaybe, but pedestrians have a higher rate of actual accidents. ;)
- u801e 12y ago> Wear a helmet. They not only save you from dangerous environmental situations, but they save you from yourself. Given the CPSC test procedure for bicycle helmets, I seriously doubt it: http://www.helmets.org/cpscstd.htm http://www.helmets.org/cpscstd.htm >> 1203.15 Positional stability test Test that the helmet doesn't roll off when a 8.8 lb weight in a guided free fall from a distance of 2 feet strikes the helmet. >> 1203.16 Dynamic strength of retention system test Uses the same weight and guided free fall distance. >> 1203.17 Impact attenuation test >> (b)(3) A guided free fall of the helmet on a weighted headform from a minimum height of 6.56 ft onto a flat anvil and a guided free fall of the helmet on a weighted headform from a minumum height of 3.94 ft onto a hemispherical and curbstone anvils Regarding the last test procedure, that would be like testing the helmet on an adult male of average height, where, while standing, suddenly suffered a stroke and fell over. It certainly wouldn't protect you in a crash at speed or with a motor vehicle. If you want real head protection while riding a bicycle, then you need to wear a motorcycle helmet (preferably one that meets the Snell standard).
- hkmurakami 12y ago>Regarding the last test procedure, that would be like testing the helmet on an adult male of average height, where, while standing, suddenly suffered a stroke and fell over With all due respect, do you ride a bike extensively? Because these exact sort of accidents happen all the time. I've fallen sideways from a stationary position several times over the last 5 years as an avid cyclist when I've had lapses in judgment or focus when declipping from my pedals. Further, I was struck by a car from behind 2 years ago and lost consciousness, propelled forward several meters, broke several ribs, suffered large abrasions on my back. My helmet suffered dents and scratches, but my head and face were 100% fine. If not for the helmet, I would have 100% suffered from cuts and abrasions to my face (given that my back has permanent scars, this could have easily happened to my face), even without taking into consideration impact protection. The fact that bicycle helmets don't protect you from every type of accident situation is a ridiculous reason to not wear one.
- u801e 12y ago> With all due respect, do you ride a bike extensively? In the last 10 years, I've ridden about 10,000 miles give or take. > Because these exact sort of accidents happen all the time. I've fallen sideways from a stationary position several times over the last 5 years as an avid cyclist when I've had lapses in judgment or focus when declipping from my pedals. I've never used pedal clips. I do ride in traffic, but I doubt I average more than 15 miles per hour. > Further, I was struck by a car from behind 2 years ago and lost consciousness, propelled forward several meters, broke several ribs, suffered large abrasions on my back. My helmet suffered dents and scratches, but my head and face were 100% fine. If not for the helmet, I would have 100% suffered from cuts and abrasions to my face That last sentence doesn't really make sense. Bicycle helmets do not cover one's face. Also, getting hit from behind by a vehicle is the least common type of crash from what I've read. > The fact that bicycle helmets don't protect you from every type of accident situation is a ridiculous reason to not wear one. If they were designed in a way that would protect me in most crashes, then I certainly would wear one while riding, but given the standard I referenced, I seriously doubt it. If FMVSS 209 stated that seat belts in cars were only tested in frontal collisions at speeds of 20 mph or less, then I wouldn't bother wearing them because I know that they wouldn't protect me while I'm driving at highway speeds. Fortunately, that's not the case and I always wear my seat belt while riding in or driving a car. In the end, the way one rides is far more effective in mitigating the risk of getting involved in a crash (like following the rules of the road, having appropriate equipment, etc.)
- revelation 12y agoI'm sure this epiphany now has you wear a helmet in your car, where risk of life-threatening head-trauma is significantly higher than when riding a bicycle?
- cynicalkane 12y agoUh, the risk of life-threatening head trauma is significantly lower in a car. Cars are the safest form of personal travel.
- gamache 12y agoOnly if you're inside one.
- panglott 12y agoHelmets are still the best way to reduce a lot of head injuries among motorists. Cars travel at a much higher speed than pedestrians/bicycles, so it takes a lot more to dampen the injuries, and auto-related head injuries are simply more common than bicycle-related ones. It's absolutely as reasonable to exhort motorists and pedestrians to wear helmets as it is to exhort cyclists to do so.
- stronglikedan 12y agohttp://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline http://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline
- makeitsuckless 12y agoYeah, that's exactly why I have a bit of a problem with such guidelines. It protects people from the normal consequences of insulting outer people's intelligence. Sometimes it's useful to know when your behaviour pisses other people off.
- stronglikedan 12y agoIf what I said pisses you off, then you have bigger issues to work on.
- knz 12y agoI had a similar experience. Slipped off my bike and broke an arm, leg, and various facial bones. My helmet was split in two and the ER doctor was quite blunt about the state I would have been in without a helmet. Wear a helmet.
- krschultz 12y agoI unfortunately had the counter experience. I was not wearing a helmet on my "short commute" and got hurt pretty bad. A good number of stitches, a permanent scar, but worse than that - concussions are not fun. I blacked out and woke up an hour or two after the accident inside a CAT scan machine at the hospital. My wife found out about the accident when I called her and left an identical voicemail 3 times in a row not realizing I had just done it. Wear a helmet. I used to sell them at a ski shop and wear them religiously on the ski slope, but didn't bother to put one on for the 2 minute bike ride from my dorm to class. Huge mistake.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoOh god, not again. Wearing a helmet when biking is like wearing a bullet proof vest when walking. It may be necessary in some environments, but it's those environments that are the problem. If you don't know how to ride a bike (which includes how to fall), don't project it on other people. Please stop spreading the fud about cycling itself being dangerous. It's no more dangerous than walking. The Netherlands says hi: https://bicycledutch.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/typically_dutch02.jpg https://bicycledutch.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/typically_d...
- krschultz 12y agoThat's such a load of crap. See my other comment below, the reason why I had that accident was my bike wheel had a mechanical failure. I was on a bike lane in the middle of a college campus 500 yards from the nearest car. It was a peaceful afternoon with no one around. The environment didn't mean anything at all. If your sneaker fails, you don't get thrown 20 feet onto concrete.
- makeitsuckless 12y ago20 feet. Seriously. Which would mean you were racing, not just cycling. And on a bike line "in the middle of a college campus" no less. So basically you were just being irresponsible, not just for yourself but also towards others. Oh, of course, there was "no one around", which makes it alright. No wonder cycling has a bad name in the US.
- maxerickson 12y agoWhat is the maximum appropriate cycling speed? Walking is about 6 kph, so that seems like a reasonable floor. (I'm not trying to be antagonistic, if you are going to argue that cycling above some speed is unsafe, I think it is constructive to be specific)
- ptaipale 12y agoGoing like 30 km/h on a clear bike path is not "racing". It's just normal traffic, gonig from place A to B. Still, a helmet can help this casual cyclist. My experience is from a bike path, no one in sight. A ball bounces onto the the path from a bush. That would have been the time to hit brakes immediately, but I just didn't think right. Next comes the 4-year-old kid who runs from behind a bush. Now I hit the brakes, go over the bar, head first. No damage to the head, despite a bump. Broke a radix bone, though. I definitely recommend using a helmet, however casually you ride.