6 ms·
Hi! Cis-het white dude here. That you come in arguing is likely part of the problem. That you have constructed your point of view as the intellectually honest o
by wpietri 12y ago
Hi! Cis-het white dude here. That you come in arguing is likely part of the problem. That you have constructed your point of view as the intellectually honest one, making your conversational partners the un-intellectual, dishonest ones, is surely another part.
What your approach doesn't acknowledge is the historical inequality, and the system by which that inequality is maintained. Just by virtue of being a comfortable white dude, I already get listened to way more than somebody less historically favored. And if I want, I can use that power to harm discussion of the systemic problems that give me that power.
Anybody in a disfavored group has experience that misuse of power about a zillion times. It's such a popular activity that there are mocking how-to guides for the powerful, like Derailing for Dummies.
So when people pop in to a discussion saying, "Hold on there, ladies; you seem hysterical. Let's calm down and listen to the white men for once," it's infuriating, because a) they are pretty familiar with the dominant perspective, and b) it is an exhibition of the unearned power that they are directly working against.
As a white dude, I get that this sucks. I am used to being heard, so not being heard feels unfair. But because I want real equality, I put on my big boy pants, shut my opinion-hole, and listen to people who are different than me. And in doing that, I've come to a much better understanding of what real equality means and how much hard work it will take us all to get there.
- Moshe_Silnorin 12y agoYou type so much and say nothing at all.
- wpietri 12y agoI'm open to constructive criticism, but I'm not seeing much here. Would you care to try again? I think I said some very specific things.
- Karunamon 12y agoConstructive criticism: The content of ideas is infinitely more important than the identity of the person speaking the ideas. To deny this is to deny basic rationality, and is infinitely more harmful on a longer time scale. That you come in arguing is likely part of the problem. There is no such thing as an idea that is above criticism. The problem here, the one highlighted by the article, is that the radicals being complained about disagree with both of these concepts - things which are the cornerstone of an open dialogue, which is the cornerstone of a healthy society. With that in mind, how can you simultaneously hold the dissonant beliefs that rationality is important, and that one of its primary tenets should be ignored?
- innguest 12y agoFinally someone says what needs to be said. This is all. Either you understand arguments stand for themselves, or you are a relativist that thinks arguments vary in validity depending on whose mouth they're coming from. If I find out someone is a relativist I never discuss anything with them ever again. Those people are sophists without knowing - they just think "if I talk a lot I must be having a debate!". They have much reading in front of them, which they usually don't get to ever do. Those are the people that had rather die than think. I ignore them but I make sure they know it's because they are a relativist. If we all ostracized relativists we would be able to better tell the extremists from those that have something to say.
- atlantic 12y agoExcellent. This is the crux of the question. Ideas have to be evaluated on their content, not according to the identity of the authors, otherwise civilized discourse is shut down.
- wpietri 12y agoAs I've done elsewhere, let me use the example of interracial marriage, an idea whose evaluation has changed over time: http://www.gallup.com/poll/163697/approve-marriage-blacks-whites.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/163697/approve-marriage-blacks-wh... Note that the content of the idea hasn't changed, but the evaluation has. Look in particular at the second graph, where black people came to the now-correct answer long before white people. Black people on average had it right 25 years before white people. So it would seem to me that on topics of race, identity of speaker can be helpful in evaluating views.
- atlantic 12y agoI don't follow your argument. Take something like Newton's theory of motion. It stands or falls on its mathematical and experimental foundations. It doesn't matter if Newton belonged to the gentry, if he treated his servants badly or if he beat his wife. That's not pertinent to the truth of the theory. If the logic sound? Are the experiments reproducible? That's the only part that matters. As for the example you've given - a Gallup poll - there is no right or wrong answer to a poll. Nobody ever "got it right". If people are simply expressing an opinion, there isn't any right or wrong answer. Opinions are what they are, and they change over time.
- Moshe_Silnorin 12y agoYou disagree with the tenets that make "being open to criticism" possible. Arguments do not where the skin of their speakers. They're sexless, skinless things. Your ideology destroys the fungibility of arguments, requiring that we pay strict attention to the provenance of any idea that pertains to your sacred issues, gender and race. Obviously, this poisons the information economy around these issues and much nonsense is taken as fact.
- wpietri 12y agoArguments don't do anything. People use arguments. Those people have histories, and their histories are material when considering what they do with those arguments. I agree that the truth isn't influenced by race or gender. But one's perception of truth is influenced by one's experiences, and those experiences currently have heavy race and gender components. So if getting at the truth is the true goal, then one must be enormously careful to discover and work against one's own biases. If you're looking for a way to get started on that, try Harvard's Project Implicit: https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/index.jsp https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/index.jsp I used to think that I wasn't biased. But instead I just didn't want to be biased. There's a big difference, and seeing that helped me see how wrong I was to think that my experiences didn't influence my opinions.
- wpietri 12y agoOh, and one more point. The "information economy" is only part of how society actually changes. Look at this graph: http://www.gallup.com/poll/149390/record-high-approve-black-white-marriages.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/149390/record-high-approve-black-... Is that a graph of people being convinced by rational argument? No, it's mainly people with old ideas dying off. It would be great if the world worked like you say, but it doesn't. Even science doesn't. Max Planck wrote, "A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."
- classicsnoot 12y agoYou type so little and say so much.
- dang 12y ago> You type so much and say nothing at all. Please don't post drive-by insults to HN.
- evincarofautumn 12y agoI ordinarily do avoid spouting off opinions when I should be listening. Also, most feminists I talk to are considerate and do not bully people in this way. Still, it is important to have an open dialogue, and this article is advocating for that, so I felt the need to express my agreement.
- wpietri 12y agoThanks. I too am in favor of open dialogue, but with a couple exceptions. These exceptions really bug me, because by masquerading as dialogue they reduce the opportunity for real dialoue. One is when open dialogue is used as a cloak for social control. The extreme example here is the Westboro Baptist Church, which pickets with signs that say, "God Hates Fags". A historical example is all the people picketing during school integration in the US. But there are a zillion subtle examples where people today, often unconsciously, say and do things that act to maintain historical imbalances. Another is when discussion participants aren't acting responsibly. I forever see dudes sea-lioning their way into some advanced discussion on feminism, saying ignorant and/or harmful things, and then getting upset when they're called out. Real dialogue requires new participants to approach with humility and respect. Nobody expects it to be ok to for somebody off the street to barge into a graduate physics seminar and start opining. Those people will promptly get bounced, and surely go away complaining. But topics like feminism and race relations also have long histories. People jumping in to serious discussions should know something; they are not entitled to an on-the-spot education that stops the advanced discussion from progressing. I'd also add that as I have come to better understand the experience of other people, I'm a lot more forgiving of possibly misdirected anger from marginalized people. A (white) sysadmin pal has a permanent, visceral dislike of cops because he was once assaulted by a cop who mistook him for somebody who had just shot a brother officer. Intellectually he knows that most cops are fine, but if somebody puts you in the ER, intellect only takes you so far. He just now doesn't trust cops in general; each individual officer has to demonstrate that they are safe before he feels safe. Knowing how much bullshit has been perpetrated by people who look like me, I just accept that some people are going to initially see me as a probable threat. I am just always going to be Schrodinger's rapist [1] to a lot of women. I'm going to be Schrodinger's racist to a lot of black people. So if in a discussion on sensitive topics I am mistaken for an asshole, I try to let that slide. Heck, they could be right. And if not, their reaction to me may be wrong, but I think it's understandably and forgivably wrong. [1] http://kateharding.net/2009/10/08/guest-blogger-starling-schrodinger%E2%80%99s-rapist-or-a-guy%E2%80%99s-guide-to-approaching-strange-women-without-being-maced/ http://kateharding.net/2009/10/08/guest-blogger-starling-sch... P.S. I am up against my noprocrast limit, but I'll try to come back this evening.
- themgt 12y agoThat's a straw-man response to parent that you could have pasted out of any SJW handbook. We need to stop having these privilege olympics, talking in circles, and applying offensive stereotypes to white men ("calm down ladies") any time they ask that their voice be heard and treated with the same respect as anyone else's. The parent didn't call ladies hysterical or misuse his power - you accusing him of such is disingenuous and derailing the conversation.
- wpietri 12y agoI did not in fact accuse him of that. I specifically avoided accusing him of that. But that is exactly the sort of thing that gets said in "open dialogue". And then those people get all butthurt when people don't treat their disrespect with the sort of unearned respect they are used to. It is also not a straw man response, and it is not pasted. Hi! I'm a real person, writing under my real name. These are things I believe. Would care to engage with the actual substance?
- zxcvcxz 12y ago> Just by virtue of being a comfortable white dude I've got news for you: People don't listen because you're a white male, they listen because you're privileged. I've never met a "SJW" that actually knows what it's like to be poor, it's all well-off, college educated, mostly white people. I think most poor people who make their way to the top don't actually get any help, so they end up forming conservative view points, whereas the rich white people just can't understand why poor people don't just stop being poor. It must be because they're black! Congratulations you're a racist.
- wpietri 12y agoYou should meet more people interested in social justice. Plenty of them grew up poor. I did. It's only thanks to a childhood hobby of computers that I'm now doing well. Whiteness is one kind of privilege in US society. So is male-ness. So yes, I'm privileged. And yes, people listen to me better because of that.