5 ms·
I'd argue that this is not an instance of dishonesty. The ideologies of groups like the one you linked to, despite being radical, are quickly becoming mainstrea
by Karunamon 12y ago
I'd argue that this is not an instance of dishonesty. The ideologies of groups like the one you linked to, despite being radical, are quickly becoming mainstream.
You've got an author in a mainstream newspaper who can write that due process shouldn't exist, and this is taken seriously in the current political climate.
You've got an ideology that asserts your identity is more important than the content of your character, and this is taken seriously.
You've got an ideology that states literally any dissent is at least bad, at most hateful, and this is taken seriously.
The example you link to is not dishonest because it is not meant to be an example of "everyday" thoughts by everyday people, it is meant to be an example of radicalism becoming mainstream.
- fweespeech 12y agoRelying on a source that is basically a propaganda organ of the hard right elements of the Republican party without disclosing that is what it is falls under "dishonesty" when attempting to use it as a factual representation of reality. It is IDENTICAL to me going to a SJW and using her as a source without fact checking it. Or the Rolling Stone article. He literally did that. It isn't a fact you can wave away and say "Well, conservative republican views are becoming mainstream so its okay." All he had to do was add a footnote saying "Hey look at these Republican political operatives".
- Joeboy 12y ago> You've got an author in a mainstream newspaper who can write that due process shouldn't exist Maybe you do, somewhere, but the author of the cited article makes it clear she isn't arguing for a change to the legal system: "This is not a legal argument about what standards we should use in the courts; it’s a moral one, about what happens outside the legal system."
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoI'm sorry, but I think everything you've written is utterly backwards. Nobody outside the internet takes seriously the ideas that due process shouldn't exist, or that identity is more important than actions, or that dissent is morally harmful. And "Conservatism" in its hard-right, Koch-and-Paul incarnation is already mainstream. It has been mainstream ever since Ronald Reagan -- not just mainstream but the mainstream, in the sense that it keeps winning elections, no matter what the San Francisco digerati think of it. (And for reference, I'm very hard-left. I don't like that the Republican Party wins elections; I just also don't pretend it doesn't happen and then claim the Tumblr Left is somehow mainstream!)
- classicsnoot 12y agoFallacies abound. >Nobody outside the internet takes seriously the idea that due process shouldn't exist. The Internet is made of people. Do these people (you and I and everyone ITT) not exist in the real world? >...ever since Ronald Reagan. Do you honestly believe a Golden Age actor invented Conservatism? Crazy town banana pants >...the Tumblr left is somehow mainstream. main·stream ˈmānˌstrēm/ noun noun: mainstream 1. the ideas, attitudes, or activities that are regarded as normal or conventional; the dominant trend in opinion, fashion, or the arts. Isn't mainstream more of a reflection of Common Knowledge then ubiquity throughout subgroups? Regardless, the idea that leftishness is somehow an underground thing is CTBP. Full disclosure, I am an intellectual anarchist. THAT is a fringe group. I am not trying to hate, i just disagree with what you said, and i am sorry if you feel offended by anything i wrote, but i am not sorry for anything i have written.
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>The Internet is made of people. Do these people (you and I and everyone ITT) not exist in the real world? The internet is mostly made of a strict subset of people who exist in the real world, and the people who make up The Internet, in the sense of internet-centered subcultures, are a very small subset of all real people. The fact that an idea or ideology is loud, or even possibly dominant, within our subculture is not even evidence of its being dominant within society as a whole. Most of society are nothing like us net-folk. >Do you honestly believe a Golden Age actor invented Conservatism? Crazy town banana pants What I said is that he brought it to mainstream electoral dominance, particularly after the social-democratic Postwar Consensus. > Isn't mainstream more of a reflection of Common Knowledge then ubiquity throughout subgroups? Right, hence why we need to check to make sure that what we think is common to think among our friends and cliques is actually common among the population as a whole -- because our friends and cliques are not representative samples. >Regardless, the idea that leftishness is somehow an underground thing is CTBP. Don't be silly. It's not underground, it's just a comparatively small minority of the total population. In the United States, for instance, if I recall the numbers correctly, I believe that roughly 40% of the population self-report as conservative or conservative-leaning, 10% as independent/undecided, 20% as liberal or leftist, and 30% as moderate/centrist. So in total, there are fewer devoted leftists than devoted rightists, and fewer devoted anything-ists than self-declared non-ideologues. And of the people who self-declare as leftists, only a minority will be Tumblr leftists. So yeah: a tempest in the internet's teacup doesn't mean that a bunch of authoritarian identity-politicking liberals are taking over the world.