5 ms·
I thought the initial concept of wikileaks was to publish documents that would reveal scandals. Instead it is becoming a pirate bay for stolen documents. I am s
by cm2187 12y ago
I thought the initial concept of wikileaks was to publish documents that would reveal scandals. Instead it is becoming a pirate bay for stolen documents. I am sure the leaks of the Sony documents will reveal the nasty side of Hollywood (which are well known, Hollywood made hundreds of movies on that topic!), but how is that a matter of public interest? What scandal will come out of this? Even the diplomatic cables didn't really reveal any major wrong doing. Most documents were, at most, of interest to diplomats and historians. But no major scandal came out of these leaks.
Too often wikileaks is compared to the Snowden leaks, which triggered a rightful outrage.
- hurin 12y agoI tend to agree - the documents relating to actual abuses are worth releasing, - but releasing the entire trove (and granted I haven't looked at all of it) seems arbitrary and without principal.
- tete 12y agoAre you seriously asking how revealing corruption in politics is in the public interest? https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/135225 https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/135225
- eli 12y agoYou needed leaked emails to tell you that companies donate to political candidates they like? https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00282038 https://www.opensecrets.org/pacs/lookup2.php?strID=C00282038
- task_queue 12y agoIf you read a follow up email here: https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/49813 https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/49813 You will be aware of the damning evidence. They intended to donate $50k. They are subject to a $5k donation limitation. They are deliberately skirting the law.
- cm2187 12y agoWhat I don't understand is how is that different from any fund raising effort for a candidate? You look for people who have a reason to support a given candidate (race, religion, profession, etc) and invite them to give them money. How is this a proof of corruption? Yes, the money will come with a message: we like you because you vote xxx on yyy. But I don't see how this is illegal (or even immoral). And I don't see how this is information you couldn't get from public data.
- eli 12y agoAre you saying it's illegal to email coworkers and ask them to donate to a campaign? Or that it should be?
- yellowapple 12y agoThe email implies a specific intent of soliciting individual donations toward a cause (in this case, a politician) which is directly beneficial to the interests of the organization as a whole. It would be one thing if the emails amounted to "hey, you should donate to this guy because he's a cool dude". That's not the case here, though; it's instead a case of "hey, you should donate to this guy because the company you work for wants to donate $50k but can't because of legal restrictions, and this guy's been really good to us", which - legal or not - is (in my opinion at least) morally deplorable and certainly skirting around the intent of the existing law.
- eli 12y agoSorry, I'm not really seeing why asking people to donate for one reason is ok but another is morally deplorable. > The email implies a specific intent of soliciting individual donations toward a cause (in this case, a politician) which is directly beneficial to the interests of the organization as a whole. Sure, agreed. Makes sense to me. Why is this "deplorable"? I founded a startup. Is it wrong to email my employees and ask them to support tax breaks for startups? Or to contribute directly to the politicians who implement those tax breaks?
- joopxiv 12y agoAs these contributions were already made public, nothing has been revealed.
- task_queue 12y agoAnd then connecting it with this email reveals the damning evidence: https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/49813 https://wikileaks.org/sony/emails/emailid/49813 Publicly they were individual donations. This shows the intent of the group to donate a sum of $50k along with detailing how they were going break their donation up to skirt the law. They deliberately structured their donations to sidestep the $5k limitation to campaigns they're subject to.
- RobertKerans 12y agoThat's fine. What about the rest of the documents?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoThis isn't even close to being damning evidence. There's no "structuring" here to "sidestep" anything. There's no breaking up donations. This is someone asking individuals to contribute to a campaign. Contributions which, by the way, are a matter of public record for all to see, no hacking needed.
- mentat 12y agoAsking for contributions to make a corporate goal as a kickback for services received.
- cyphunk 12y agoData has qualities of the inverse of decay and what you see initially when looking at it on your own is only its half-life. This release shows very clearly to anyone but the absolute naysayer that the sony data has political and legal ramifications that deserve public attention. Now the public will have the chance to uncovering other kernels of interest and truth, which wikileaks could not possibly accomplish by sitting on the data. In light of blaring illegal activities I do not see how you could question this. Further, I don't see how one could find bringing the collusion between multinational corporations and governments to the light of day as not being worthwhile. Even if it may not always reveal illegal activity it enlightens the public. This is why regardless of what you see on the surface of a data trove erring in the direction of release is likely wise.
- cm2187 12y agoI don't see any illegal activity yet. Political donations is something perfectly legal and transparent.
- cyphunk 12y agoWhat of the claims that Sony orginised methods to get around the $2000 limit of donations? I'm curious if this would be illegal, and if not I feel it should be. And even if there are reasons for it to be legal, I'm grateful I at least can learn about it when it happens.
- cm2187 12y agoFrom the email I read, that relied on executives making a donation of their own money. I don't see how this different from any other appeal. And in any way political donations are publicly available, you don't need leaked emails to identify them.
- fineman 12y agoMaking six $3k deposits in a row isn't a crime. Doing so to avoid the reporting limits, is. It might turn out that because of some quirk of law that intentionally getting around donation restrictions isn't illegal (which is presumably should be, just like the banking regulations...) but even if so it's still pretty clearly an end-run around the intent of the law and that's a pretty scummy thing to do. Especially because I think it's pretty easy to see the easily coercive nature of this. After all, donations are publicly visible... I wouldn't expect to be fired for not, but I would expect not to be promoted unless I did.
- happyscrappy 12y agoI imagine Snowden contemplated releasing everything to Wikileaks but decided against it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- throwaway9324 12y ago> I thought the initial concept of wikileaks was to publish documents that would reveal scandals" Well. From an early version of wikileaks website: "Wikileaks is developing an uncensorable Wikipedia for untraceable mass document leaking and analysis. Our primary interests are oppressive regimes in Asia, the former Soviet bloc, Sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East, but we also expect to be of assistance to those in the west who wish to reveal unethical behavior in their own governments and corporations." http://web.archive.org/web/20070114162346/http://www.wikileaks.org/index.html http://web.archive.org/web/20070114162346/http://www.wikilea... > Most documents were, at most, of interest to diplomats and historians. But no major scandal came out of these leaks. What people don't seem to get is that the cables wasn't about the US. But about what every other government where doing with or saying to the US behind their own peoples back. E.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contents_of_the_United_States_diplomatic_cables_leak_(Europe)#United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contents_of_the_United_States_d...
- coldtea 12y ago>I am sure the leaks of the Sony documents will reveal the nasty side of Hollywood (which are well known, Hollywood made hundreds of movies on that topic!), but how is that a matter of public interest? So that Taylor Swift has a new boyfriend is somehow "a matter of public interest" judging from the tons of classic and new media that report such BS, but the "nasty side" of a huge industry that caters to billions of people is not?
- task_queue 12y agoJust because you don't know what you're looking for doesn't mean there isn't anything to find.
- cm2187 12y agoThen you don't mind if I release all your personal emails? I don't know what I am looking for, but that doesn't mean there isn't anything to find.
- task_queue 12y agoThe difference here is that I'm not a powerful organization that employs hundreds of thousands and has influenced international/domestic law and trade policy.
- yellowapple 12y agoAt least that we know of. :)
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 12y agoYa I'm waiting for someone to show me some kind of explosive corruption from this data dump, perhaps I just need to wait. I suppose that is the argument for releasing everything; all the reporters and people around the world might find something that a reporter in NY or DC or London will not understand or fail to connect the dots. I just don't see why they can't send these to the top news organizations and wait for them to review them, and maybe point out a few big news items they found? If that doesn't happen, this seems silly to me. It's basically entertainment gossip and of no real news value. And if anything, I feel like this detracts from the story because there are so many superfluous emails in there. I'm not going to go through them and most people won't, so why don't Wikileaks review them and release the ones that are actually newsworthy?