2 ms·
"Which is why we need government funding, though not government control, of research" Without accountability (which is what you mean by 'government control'),
by dnautics 12y ago
"Which is why we need government funding, though not government control, of research"
Without accountability (which is what you mean by 'government control'), all you will have is crony funding, and a downward-spiraling quality of work as effort goes toward scientific rent-seeking instead of real scientific product. This problem is inextricable. In order to have accountability, you have to have benchmarks, which really means that the only type of science funding the government is consistently good at is translational, with defined goals. A good example is the moonshot.
If your claim is that government will politicize science, well then, the problem is with demanding that government fund science in the first place. It is a ridiculous position of entitlement to demand money, obtained from taxpayers who have little choice to comply, with nothing in exchange.
For an excellent counterexample to your assertion, consider Peter Mitchell. He created an private, nonprofit science research organization very much dedicated to a 'basic science' question and solved a fundamental question in biochemistry: How does the cell generate energy? Although there is no way that industry would have funded this, there was also no way that government would have funded it either. He won a Nobel Prize for his work.
Do not make the mistake of conflating 'private' with 'for-profit'. This is a false dichotomy that overlooks important social efforts, such as the Polio Vaccines.