3 ms·
I've just finished reading Chomsky's "How the World Works". I'll quote a relevant section about the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). The behaviour,
by shoo 12y ago
I've just finished reading Chomsky's "How the World Works".
I'll quote a relevant section about the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA).
The behaviour, in my opinion, seems roughly consistent with what we are seeing now:
In 1974, the Trade Act was passed by Congress. One of its
provisions was that the Labor Advisory Committee -- which
is based in the unions -- had to have input and analysis
on any trade-related issue. Obviously that committee had
to report on NAFTA, which was an executive agreement
signed by the president.
The Labor Advisory Committee was notified in mid-August 1992
that their report was due on September 8, 1992. However, they
weren't given a text of the agreement until about 24 hours
before the report was due. That meant they couldn't even
convene, and they obviously couldn't write a serious report
in time.
Now these are conservative labor leaders, not the kind of
guys who criticize the government much. But they wrote a
very acid report. They said that, to the extent that we can
look at this in the few hours given to us, it looks like it's
going to be a disaster for working people, for the
environment, for Mexicans -- and a great boon for investors.
The committee pointed out that although treaty advocates
said it won't hurt many American workers, maybe just
unskilled workers, their definition of "unskilled worker"
would include 70% of the workforce. The committee also
pointed out that property rights were being protected all
over the place, but workers' rights were scarcely mentioned.
The committee then bitterly condemned the utter contempt for
democracy that was demonstrated by not giving the committee
the complete text ahead of time.
On a related note, if anyone is interested in reading more about
the Investor-State Dispute Settlement provisions of these
"Free Trade" agreements, there's an interesting perspective from
Chief Justice RS French, from the High Court of Australia:
http://www.hcourt.gov.au/assets/publications/speeches/current-justices/frenchcj/frenchcj09jul14.pdf http://www.hcourt.gov.au/assets/publications/speeches/curren...