3 ms·
Those damn neanderthals look scary as hell. I'm telling you, I felt an primeval gut reaction looking at those pictures. Maybe he's on to something.
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Those damn neanderthals look scary as hell. I'm telling you, I felt an primeval gut reaction looking at those pictures.
Maybe he's on to something.
- nfnaaron 17y agoThe reason they're drawn scary is to support the theory of Neanderthal as cannibal. I'm not saying Neanderthal's didn't eat and rape humans, I'm just pointing out that the authors would be unlikely to include pictures of cuddly Neanderthals juxtaposed with paragraphs of rape. Sometimes I look scary. Sometimes I look friendly. My skull shape does not change in either state. I suppose when humans were fighting Neanderthals, their facial expressions were equally fierce and scary.
- jpeterson 17y agoThey're definitely on to something with the eyes. I don't scare easily, but any vaguely hominid-shaped creature with big eyes gives me a visceral feeling of fright. The vertical slit has an affect, too. I think most people have this same reaction. Another example of this which I don't think they cite in the article would be modern alien abduction mythology. Most of the renderings and conceptual drawings of them portray beings with enormous black eyes (also slanted in the same fashion as the rendered neanderthals in parent article). Having said this, there are also many modern animals that, when shown snarling in the same manner as they portray these neanderthals, would be equally terrifying, I think.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agothere are also many modern animals that, when shown snarling in the same manner as they portray these neanderthals, would be equally terrifying, I think. In person, yes. But in a picture? That's unusual for me. I thought the snarl was overdone. Just the big eyes and vaguely human (yet alien) form was enough I intuitively like the idea that another intelligent tool-wielding species put pressure on humans to evolve. I have no idea of the likelihood of the claim, but it would explain the sudden changes in our species in the last 100K years or so.
- Semiapies 17y agoHaving big eyes is a common threat trigger for animals. Putting big eye stickers on an inert object will scare away birds.
- dejb 17y agoAre you serious? A scary picture means "Maybe he's on to something"? For the record I didn't find the picture all that scary so what does that mean?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoYes. I am serious. If you're asking me to comment on what I think might or might not have happened a hundred thousand years ago based on a few TV shows and books and classes and such I've had? My answer is going to be something like "That's a nice color. I like brown" There is no right way to respond to these articles -- there is no frame of reference, the topics are imminently debatable, and to some degree we'll never know. So any answer is as good as any other. In fact, the tendency is for internet pundits to run on at length, taking on airs of expertise when in fact they're as lost as the next guy. If you asked me (you didn't) 99% of internet comments are people talking way out of their league. In this case, I don't think anybody in the world is able to do anything but idly speculate. I decided not to do that. And it means you do not like brown.
- Gupie 17y agoI am very dubious of the pictures. For example why the jet black skin? Neanderthals were cold adapted creatures.
- etal 17y agoThey lived and hunted in dark forests, so black would have been good camouflage. Cold doesn't have anything to do with it as long as the creature can get enough vitamin D through its diet.
- Semiapies 17y agoTo make the Neanderthal look more simian and threatening. The art looks like very old pictures of gorillas, before people had a decent idea of what they looked like.