5 ms·
World-record electric motor for aircraft
- ghostberry 12y agoOut of interest, I looked up the motor used in the new Formula E racing cars. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spark-Renault_SRT_01E#Electric_Motor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spark-Renault_SRT_01E#Electric... I'm sure there are details other than power and weight which makes a direct comparison unfair.
- gsinkin 12y agoWhat are the benefits of having an electric motor? I imagine that fewer moving parts means less maintenance and lower odds of failure, but what are the other advantages? Quieter perhaps? Are these aircraft going to be loaded up with battery packs? How is that going to work?
- bhayden 12y agoThe quiet aspect probably has a lot of value in military applications. And it'd be useful in the solar powered unmanned planes we see, but maybe the energy requirements for this are too high.
- Crito 12y agoA solar-powered sea-plane would be pretty awesome. Probably not enough range to cross an ocean in one go, but you just land, do some fishing, then take off again the next day.
- euyyn 12y agoEven if the motor is quiet you still have the propeller making a lot of noise. I (honestly) don't know if you can really get it quiet enough for the motor's noise to be important.
- davepage 12y ago> The propeller, even at 500 feet over the maintenance area, made only a light flutter, heard just as it approached. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_YO-3 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_YO-3 The largest source of propeller noise is transonic flow at the tips, so turning the propeller slowly helps significantly. The tradeoff is a larger propeller and more expensive engine installation due to the required gearbox.
- bpowah 12y agothis article does a fair amount of discussion on advantages. Basically it is quiet, has no on-site emissions, and is theoretically more efficient. They also go on to mention that it loosens some design constraints. http://www.technologyreview.com/news/516576/once-a-joke-battery-powered-airplanes-are-nearing-reality/ http://www.technologyreview.com/news/516576/once-a-joke-batt...
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThose would be advantages of an all-electric aircraft, however this article is not about that. This article is about an electric motor that could be used in a series-hybrid aircraft, that is, one with a fixed-speed combustion engine and small battery or capacitor.
- bpowah 12y agoThe original article mentions hybrid but does not say the motors are exclusive to hybrid drives, merely that the motor will be flight tested in a series-hybrid DA36. Besides, the MIT article I linked enumerates the benefits of the hybrid drive. The word 'hybrid' is in the subtitle. I suspect Siemens is focusing on hybrid tech at the moment because battery tech is such a moving target and they want to use an existing airframe. Ultimately, I think all-electric aircraft will find their market in short-flight urban transport applications where noise, pollution, and reliability are huge factors.
- nikolaj 12y agopassenger quadcopters anyone?
- bigiain 12y agoTo be fair, I'd prefer a hex or octo - gimme a little bit of redundancy, at least in the first few versions...
- bhayden 12y agoRedundancy for what? Normal helicopters only have a single rotor and are perfectly safe.
- tjohns 12y agoNormal helicopters can autorotate to perform a controlled emergency landing if the engine fails. Quadcopters don't have that option.
- bigiain 12y agoNormal helicopters can autorotate[1] to a landing if the motor stops. A quad is unflyable with one motor out[2]. An octo can self correct for a single motor failure, and is still controllable with two motors out if you get lucky about which of the motors fail second. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autorotation [2] it's probably theoretically possible that a quad with reversible motors (or reverse pitchable blades) could be built to survive a single motor failure, but so far as I can tell nobody, at least in the hobby size quadcopter world, has done so (thoughI'd be surprised if the KMel Robotics and Pennsylvania University research teams don't know exactly how to do it).
- sjtrny 12y ago> but so far as I can tell nobody, at least in the hobby size quadcopter world, has done so It's not the motors that are the problem. They can spin freely any direction. It's programming the ESCs to be reversible. Anyway it's already been done a hundred times over: - Fixed pitch props but reversible ESCs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UoReJULASkw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UoReJULASkw - Variable pitch prop styles exist such as HobbyKings Reaper https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAFxkHAiimY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mAFxkHAiimY and Curtis Youngblood's StingRay http://curtisyoungblood.com/V2/products/quadcopters/stingray-500 http://curtisyoungblood.com/V2/products/quadcopters/stingray.... Autorotation on quadcopters is possible with the variable pitch configuration.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- staunch 12y agoElon Musk has joked that one day he will merge the work of Tesla and SpaceX into an electric jet. I'm hoping we'll end up with electric-powered Star Trek shuttlpods with Falcon-derrived takeoff-landing thrusters.
- pchristensen 12y agoThat's what he said in his cameo in Iron Man 2 - "I've got an idea for an electric jet" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuG2AVFB-g0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EuG2AVFB-g0
- staunch 12y agoHe has also discussed it on stage at least a few times.
- paulsutter 12y agoWhile weight is very important in electric aircraft, I was hoping to see an efficiency advantage as well (batteries weigh more than motors). The top advantage of electric motors for aircraft is that they can fly at much higher altitude, therefore much lower air resistance, reducing energy requirements. Fuel-burning jet engines require a certain oxygen density to operate[1]. Electric motors don't need oxygen, and propellers/fans can operate even with very low air pressure. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_engine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_engine: "The limit on maximum altitude for engines is set by flammability- at very high altitudes the air becomes too thin to burn, or after compression, too hot. For turbojet engines altitudes of about 40 km appear to be possible, whereas for ramjet engines 55 km may be achievable. Scramjets may theoretically manage 75 km."
- baddox 12y ago> and propellers can operate even with very low air pressure How does that work exactly? Of course, my intuition is that lower air pressure means less to "push off of" but also less drag. And you've got certain constant overhead, like internal friction. Is there some sweet spot of air pressure where you'll get the best efficiency?
- krschultz 12y agoYou change the pitch on the propellor. The steeper the pitch, the more air is grabbed on each revolution.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThere is far more benefit to be had by reducing the weight of the motor than increasing the conversion efficiency, given that modern motors are already generally over 95% efficient, so there is just not that much left to gain there.
- thedrbrian 12y agoUnfortunately one of the pilots disadvantages is that they don't work at high altitudes. Turbo prop and turbo jet planes get around this with PACKs and bleed air. To make a high altitude electric small plane you're going to have to make a mini Dreamliner PACK or carry tanks of liquid/gaseous oxygen.
- avdempsey 12y agoIf you're interested in this you should check out the Electric Aircraft Symposium (taking place an hour North of San Francisco) on May 1-2 [1]. A quieter, more efficient aircraft with full auto-pilot could make general aviation attainable for far more people. [1] http://eas2015.cafefoundation.org http://eas2015.cafefoundation.org
- beloch 12y agoLet's do a quick comparison. A candidate plane for this engine would be the Cesna Turbo Stationair. -It is a six passenger plane with a base operating weight of about a ton. -It's engine delivers 231 kW, which is slightly less than Siemens electric engine. It's mass is approx. 200 kg, so the Siemens engine frees up 150 kg of weight. -It's fuel capacity is 237 kg of 100LL avgas. With an energy density of 44.0 MJ/kg, this gives the plane a stored energy of 10.4 GJ. The plane's max range is 1300 km. -Tesla's best battery (the Smart) has an energy density of 132 WH/kg, which is 475.2 kJ/kg. That means you'd need 21.9 thousand kilograms of battery to store the same energy that's in the Cesna's tank when full. -If we assume the plane's range is linearly related to it's stored fuel (an approximation not really accounting for take-offs), 237 kg plus the 150 kg saved in engine weight gives 0.051 GJ of stored energy, which would reduce the plane's range to 5% of normal, or about 63 km. Based on this, don't expect an EV passenger plane anytime soon. Battery technology just isn't good enough yet. A hybrid with a gas-turbine generator is much more likely in the near future. This engine may also have applications where range is not important, such as training, stunt and racing planes.
- nether 12y ago> If we assume the plane's range is linearly related to it's stored fuel it's not btw: http://web.mit.edu/16.unified/www/FALL/thermodynamics/notes/node98.html http://web.mit.edu/16.unified/www/FALL/thermodynamics/notes/...
- mikeash 12y agoAh, but it is if you're running on batteries! Unlike fuel tanks, batteries don't get lighter (at least, not measurably; e=mc^2 tells us that there will be a little change) as you drain them.
- tlb 12y agoPiston engines are only about 30% efficient in converting gasoline to mechanical energy. While battery/electric can be around 90%. So you may be off by a factor of 3.
- 12y ago
- DigitalSea 12y agoWhatever reduces our reliance on fossil fuels and leads to reduced emissions I am down with. I see some people getting confused, this is not about a solely electric plane. The applications here would be for a hybrid plane that utilises both existing jet engine technology and electric tech. Like a hybrid vehicle, which hopefully leads to reduce fuel costs, greater distances possible to travel in a plane. Imagine if for take off and landing the pilot can fire up the existing jet engines, then whilst cruising fire up the electric engines and wind back the output from the jet engines (leading to a slower burn rate). You would still be using both, but you would have some additional boost from the electric engines. Put some lightweight solar panels on the roof of the plane, charging up the batteries while the plane sits on the tarmac and readies for taxi. Take the output of the existing engines and use it to charge the batteries in flight (like an alternator in a vehicle, but on steroids). Of course, weight is the limiting factor of all of this. I am more thinking out aloud here, when it comes to reducing our reliance on fossil fuels, I think anything (even a marginally small improvement) is a great step forward. The future is looking great.
- glabifrons 12y agoI don't see how hybrid-aircraft make any sense. The whole point of hybrid cars are the fact that you're only on the throttle periodically. You start, stop, speed up, slow down all the time (especially in S. Florida!). Normally when you're slowing down, you're burning off the energy as heat (friction from the brakes), etc. Adding an electric motor/generator to this allows you to recapture energy that is normally wasted slowing back down, so it can be reused to re-accelerate back up to speed. This is why hybrids (unlike non-hybrid cars) get better fuel mileage in town than on the freeway. Aircraft, on the other hand, are at full-throttle on takeoff, and close to 3/4 throttle during the vast majority of the flight. There is no slowdown to recoup the energy until coming in for a landing. @beloch has already done the math showing the electric range would be downright miniscule, so there's very, very little to be gained here. Until we have some utterly astounding advances in battery (or more likely, supercapacitor) tech (probably via graphene), this won't really be a cost-effective solution. However, this would be an absolutely incredible motor for electric car conversions. Imagine a pair of these (each powering an axle)... it would be considerably more powerful than even the Tesla Model S P85D.
- nether 12y agoElectric aircraft can recharge in flight from the sun. This will mostly be long endurance, high altitude utility aircraft, like Facebook/Titan Aerospace's wifi UAV or surveillance drones that can stay airborne indefinitely. These aircraft can be pseudo satellites without requiring a rocket launch. They must be extremely low in drag and weight efficient, with powerplant weight being a major issue because previously large electric motors have not had application in aerospace and have not been weight optimized as gas turbines have. Siemens has seen the growing market (QinetiQ Zephyr for another example) and is responding to it. We definitely won't be seeing any passenger aircraft electrically propelled anytime soon.
- glabifrons 12y agoThe article specifically mentions using this motor for hybrid passenger aircraft (which is what my post addressed). I mentioned nothing about UAVs or solar power (which is only possible with an enormous wing/fuselage ratio). FTA: "This innovation will make it possible to build series hybrid-electric aircraft with four or more seats," said Frank Anton, Head of eAircraft at Siemens Corporate Technology
- mapt 12y agoCould be useful for airships, and for long-endurance solar drones, where the weight is costly. I really expected this to be about high-temperature superconductor motors. Whatever happened to those?
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThey tend to stay on the ground, beside the tank of liquid nitrogen.
- WatchDog 12y agoWould driving one of these engines concurrently with the power generated by a turbine engine make sense? Does the thrust generated by a turbine engine hit some point of diminishing returns that converting the engine energy to electricity and powering this engine be more efficient? I know Boeing have made advancements in the efficiency of drawing electric power from a turbine engine with the 787, the generators are now directly connected to the transmission of the engine.