3 ms·
Not every slope is slippery. There is nothing wrong with getting rid of obvious trolls and doing so is not an indication of future censorship of genuine debate
by slg 12y ago
Not every slope is slippery. There is nothing wrong with getting rid of obvious trolls and doing so is not an indication of future censorship of genuine debate.
- parennoob 12y agoActually, on second thought -- I'm not at all convinced that it was trolling (and have changed my "trollfest" description to "heavy-handed parody"). I said "troll" because everyone else did, and I suspect the same is true of you. At what point does making comments to your own repo constitute "trolling"?
- slg 12y ago"Heavy-handed parody" and "trollfest" aren't mutually exclusive. Parody is the overarching category that can include both trolling and satire. The difference between the two is motive. A troll's only goal is to get a response, usually through anger and outrage. While a satirist is using parody to actually change opinions. Trolling is an aggressive action. Satire is a political action. I am perfectly fine protecting the later while punishing the former.
- angersock 12y agoYour trolling is their art. Censoring art is still censorship, even if we care for neither the art, the artist, or the message.
- slg 12y agoThere is a line there. I can't set fire to your home and call it art to avoid punishment. Why should I be allowed to figuratively set fire to your corner of the internet in the name of art?
- angersock 12y agoYou realize that Github pretty much did exactly that with the repo, right? It was a silly, somewhat mean-spirited project, but it lived in its own dumb little bubble and didn't hurt anyone who didn't choose to go there and be outraged.
- slg 12y agoGithub is Github's corner of the internet. This repo was a fire that was stomped out by Github.
- parennoob 12y agoGiven that Github is now big enough that Google is hosting their code there, I think that view needs to be a bit more nuanced. Yours is a very slick reply that could easily be a boilerplate one for, say, privacy concerns with Google -- "Hey, it's their service, they can do whatever they want". That's fine, but if they subsequently publish a Transparency Report that isn't very transparent about some things, it's probably a good thing to call them out on it. Would you agree?
- maxerickson 12y agoThey did not set fire to anything. They repudiated their relationship with something. Compare them to a bookstore. Say the bookstore sends some books back to the publisher (without saying why, but maybe the owner didn't like the paper or something). The bookstore might not be a very good bookstore, but it hasn't burned any books. Anybody hosting the only copy of anything on Github is making a mistake, so it isn't fair to use an analogy implying that they destroyed something.
- malvosenior 12y agoIt's not really about debate though. It's about policy. Repos should be sacred. It doesn't matter what they contain (as long as it's legal). Github shouldn't have an ideology. Would you trust Google if they started filtering pro or anti feminist results from their search? Github should never remove a repo unless they're forced to by law.