4 ms·
Yep, that's really strange. Have you reported the doctor? Their name should be on the scripts. That said, I don't see how your father's health is entirely the
by Balgair 12y ago
Yep, that's really strange. Have you reported the doctor? Their name should be on the scripts.
That said, I don't see how your father's health is entirely the responsibility of the doctor. He has the majority of the responsibility for his own body. Yes, when you are sick and scared, a doctor has enormous discretion over you. They take these oaths for a reason and the legal system is very tough on them when they fail (as things should be). However, your father has much more responsibility for his health, especially for something as simple as a common cold. I mean, the excuses that you 'don't know' are gone these days. Google is literally in your pocket for most people.
That said, we have issues with filter bubbles and getting good information. There is a lot of chaff for the seed online.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> He has the majority of the responsibility for his own body. The doctor has the responsibility to not inflict antibiotic resistance on the population at large just because he can't stand up to pushy patients. > Google is literally in your pocket for most people. Far more likely to result in "I hear this causes autism!" than "I hear I shouldn't take antibiotics for a cold".
- Balgair 12y agoNo, the doctor has no such responsibility, they only have responsibility to their patients. They are bound to operate based on the standard of care in the profession and location (this varies widely between states, cities, and countries). The doctor, likely, can easily stand up to pushy patients and, likely, has been doing so for years. The alternative of censure is much more harming than some patient that knows exactly the opioid and dosage they want. if they are not doing so, then it is the responsibility of the patients and other staff to report the doctor to the appropriate medical boards such that the doctor continue to practice safely.(http://www.ehow.com/how_5106471_report-bad-doctors.html http://www.ehow.com/how_5106471_report-bad-doctors.html). Also, yes, the issue with Google is that your filter bubble gets in the way and you make bad choices about what to listen to. Honestly, it's really bad. You point out the autism-vaccine controversy (...good God, what the hell has happened to us...Jesus...) and I'm sure there are a million other nutters out there with even more dangerous ideas. I.... I'm at a loss here. I can only say that you just have to research more, but I know that is beyond the reach of most people to do so. The excuses are gone, but not the stupid. We have all this information, but it's like a library with pages just thrown everywhere and there are no curators. I can't expect people to know what to do. My own father would say 'Well, life sucks, and it sucks a lot more if you're stupid'. Man alive, is that a cop-out. It's true, but saying that life just sucks for stupid people is heartless and against all of medicine as an ethos. Still, the question remains, how do you get people to be responsible for their own damn asses? Any ideas?
- tormeh 12y agoYeah, tell them to ask a doctor while shutting up and listening. Telling stupid people to Google stuff is how we ended up in this mess to begin with. Maybe we could tell them to consult a medicine textbook, at which point they'll be begging for option 1.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> No, the doctor has no such responsibility, they only have responsibility to their patients. Their patients, who soon will not be able to use antibiotics for a genuine bacterial infection because of resistance.
- e40 12y agoMy father is 80 and 3,000 miles away. So, no, I haven't reported the doctor and it's pretty silly to think I would. My father doesn't know any better. The doctor does. That makes it clear where the responsibility lies.