6 ms·
From the article: >They didn’t give it much thought. Periodic strep tests on Isak had always come back negative. And his symptoms seemed too dramatic to be the
by epistasis 12y ago
From the article:
>They didn’t give it much thought. Periodic strep tests on Isak had always come back negative. And his symptoms seemed too dramatic to be the result of a simple, common childhood infection.
I don't think there's any institutional stranglehold stopping research in this direction, just standard human reasoning. As a scientist, there are enticing hypotheses to follow that pop up every single day, and it's hard to judge what should get the investment of time and money.
>Their first priority is pushing pills, not our well-being.
These were doctors prescribing these, not the pharmaceutical industry, and I believe that the doctors were trying, something, anything, that they believed might work. What's more risky, using a drug that's been proven to help adults (barely better than placebo or not), or going after an as-yet-untested hypothesis about streptococci, that doesn't fit our current understanding of the problems? There are certainly issues where pharmaceutical interests are not aligned with our health and well being, but I don't really see this child's unfortunate trajectory as part of that. The failure rests more on the science just not being there, and us not having a great understanding of the mind.
- jedrek 12y agoIt really bugs me when people talk about Big Pharma pushing pills, cause really, 8-9 times out of 10, it's patients begging for pills. Are pharmaceutical companies angels? Fuck no, neither are doctors, but if nobody was buying, they wouldn't be selling. There's a great post on reddit from a doctor who wrote about a typical patient-doctor interaction (which I'm too lazy to find right now): Patient comes in with elevated blood pressure, about 30 lb overweight, sedentary lifestyle. Doctors talks about blood pressure, possible future issues with it, recommends patient start getting some exercise, portion control, lose some weight, maybe a dietary consult. Patient comes in a month or three later for a follow up visit. No weight loss, no drop in blood pressure. Doctor writes a script. Hell, when I was checking out doctor review sites for a podiatrist, one of the negative opinions he had said, "He didn't even prescribe me anything!
- e40 12y agoIt really bugs me when people talk about Big Pharma pushing pills, cause really, 8-9 times out of 10, it's patients begging for pills. Are pharmaceutical companies angels? Fuck no, neither are doctors, but if nobody was buying, they wouldn't be selling. In this trio, I blame the doctors far more than anyone. Patients have no clue, they just want to be cured. It's the responsibility of the doctors to only prescribe what is necessary. Every time I hear my father say he got antibiotics for his cold I cringe, and wonder WTF the Dr. he saw was thinking. I think the count is up to a dozen times he's received them in the last 10 years.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mreiland 12y agoI agree with you in that it's the doctor's irresponsibility. But you know they're human too, and the path of least resistance is still the path of least resistance. That and they're a product of their education.
- Balgair 12y agoYep, that's really strange. Have you reported the doctor? Their name should be on the scripts. That said, I don't see how your father's health is entirely the responsibility of the doctor. He has the majority of the responsibility for his own body. Yes, when you are sick and scared, a doctor has enormous discretion over you. They take these oaths for a reason and the legal system is very tough on them when they fail (as things should be). However, your father has much more responsibility for his health, especially for something as simple as a common cold. I mean, the excuses that you 'don't know' are gone these days. Google is literally in your pocket for most people. That said, we have issues with filter bubbles and getting good information. There is a lot of chaff for the seed online.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> He has the majority of the responsibility for his own body. The doctor has the responsibility to not inflict antibiotic resistance on the population at large just because he can't stand up to pushy patients. > Google is literally in your pocket for most people. Far more likely to result in "I hear this causes autism!" than "I hear I shouldn't take antibiotics for a cold".
- ryandrake 12y agoBetween the constant TV ads shouting "BUG YOUR DOCTOR FOR PILLS!" and the vacations, free samples, and outright cash bribes lavished on doctors, I can't see how you can characterize what's going on as anything but pill-pushing by Big Pharma.
- mv 12y agoThere may have been things lavished on doctors in the past, but as of a few years ago docs effectively can't get anything free unless it is under $10 an instance and less than $100/year. See: http://www.rxvantage.com/sunshine-act http://www.rxvantage.com/sunshine-act
- kijin 12y ago$10/instance and $100/year are only the threshold for reporting, not the threshold for banning. Plenty of doctors are still getting lots of perks from the pharmaceutical industry. In some circles, most notably in academia, doctors even consider it a mark of prestige to get expensive perks from multiple pharmaceutical companies. "Pfizer just asked me to speak at their conference in the Bahamas. Too bad I already agreed to attend Novartis's event in France!" The Sunshine Act does nothing to curb their corruption and only fuels their pride.
- glaugh 12y agoThat particular story seems like reasonable behavior on the doctor's part. But my personal experience has been that no doctor has ever brought up anything but pills to treat any condition I've had or my wife has had (and we've each had a condition that we later mitigated with a relatively small amount of experimentation, once we sort of realized it was up to us). So to me the answer is "The doctor needs to start with non-pill solutions (if they make sense), then if the patient gets pushy or is uncooperative resort to pills, with fair warning that for the most part she's treating symptoms instead of the root cause." Does that sound like a reasonable compromise that we should all be able to agree on?
- cromulent 12y agoNo, I can't agree. The doctor should do what their training and experience leads them to believe will lead to the best outcome for the patient. Pills are not evil. Optimise for good outcomes.
- kaitai 12y agoDoctors are trained to use pills to treat conditions, so that's what their experience is in. Few have training in other treatment modalities; you can't get reimbursed for many other treatment modalities; you can't carry out an effective CBT session or really work on behavioral change in 12-15 minutes. Doctors are very well-trained in a very narrow area, which emphasizes pharmaceutical approaches. That's why many good docs refer you (to a physical therapist or dietician or psychologist) if they are aware of other effective non-pharmaceutical treatments for your condition.
- frenchy 12y agoI'm assuming this is specific to the United States? My anecdotal experience in Canada has been that it is not unusual for doctors to misdiagnose, but pill pushing isn't particularly a problem.
- tim333 12y agoYeah, not much of a problem in the UK either. The US system is a bit unusual. I daresay they'll still prescribe the pills if you ask - there are an awful lot of people on antidepressants.
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago>It really bugs me when people talk about Big Pharma pushing pills, cause really, 8-9 times out of 10, it's patients begging for pills. Are pharmaceutical companies angels? Fuck no, neither are doctors, but if nobody was buying, they wouldn't be selling. In the case of children it is the parents begging, but the real question is why do they beg. If you met large populations who begged for something dangerous or bad to be done to them that would benefit another, would you think they truly wanted it of their free will having made fully informed decisions, or would you suspect that for many, there had been some manipulation/misinformation/etc.?
- DanBC 12y ago> It really bugs me when people talk about Big Pharma pushing pills, cause really, 8-9 times out of 10, it's patients begging for pills. Are pharmaceutical companies angels? Fuck no, neither are doctors, but if nobody was buying, they wouldn't be selling. Pharmaceutical companies don't help their image when they behave as poorly as Roche has in the UK with avastin and lucentis. Avastin and Lucentis are very similar compounds. A astin is older and much cheaper than Lucentis. Lucentis is licenced for use in macular degeneration - the leading cause of blindess outside poor countries. Avastin is not licenced for macular degeneration. Despite numerous safety and efficiency trials Roche are refusing to allow Aventis to be licenced for macular degeneration, and they intend to use the law to its full extent to prevent aventis being used for macular degeneration. (Off label rules are stricter in England). This is a scumbag move. Roche have chosen to let people go blind because they want the profit from lucentis. Here's the US version: http://www.allaboutvision.com/conditions/lucentis-vs-avastin.htm http://www.allaboutvision.com/conditions/lucentis-vs-avastin... Here's the UK version: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-30138097 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-30138097
- jobu 12y ago> These were doctors prescribing these, not the pharmaceutical industry, and I believe that the doctors were trying, something, anything, that they believed might work. It wasn't until I was a parent that I realized a big part of what doctors do is guesswork. Not all of the time, and they are making educated guesses, but it's still guesswork. Lots of people don't understand this - unfortunately even some doctors.
- chockablock 12y ago'educated guessing' is exactly what I go to the doctor for.