2 ms·
Why has the name Lisp been coöpted to mean Common Lisp?
by TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago
Why has the name Lisp been coöpted to mean Common Lisp?
- copsarebastards 12y agoBecause people are lazy and say the shorter thing. It's not particularly a bad thing. It's only a problem in this argument because people have no understanding of context and don't understand the meaning of the word "Lisp" in context. It's like arguing about whether English is a Dutch, while claiming that Pennsylvania Dutch is the real Dutch, when in fact both languages have something to do with Dutch (they're all Germanic Languages) but neither one is Dutch. (In this metaphor, Scheme = English, Common Lisp = Pennsylvania Dutch, Dutch = Academic Variations on McCarthy's Lisp, Ancient German = McCarthy's Lisp).
- divs1210 12y ago..with a brilliant example.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoI don't think it's that. The thing is that Common Lispers believe Common Lisp to be, well, Common. The Lisp to end all lisps, the one true lisp, the one lisp to unite the community. And some believe there should be no other lisps as they are just fracturing the community. So calling CL Lisp comes down to arrogance.
- copsarebastards 12y agoThat may be so. It's a weird stance to take, though. CL has as little in common with McCarthy's Lisp as any of the other variations that descend from McCarthy's Lisp. So at this point it's just a name, and I'm not sure what's to be gained even if CL somehow got everyone to agree they had sole ownership of the name.
- lispm 12y ago> CL has as little in common with McCarthy's Lisp as any of the other variations that descend from McCarthy's Lisp. That's not true. http://www.informatimago.com/develop/lisp/com/informatimago/small-cl-pgms/wang.html http://www.informatimago.com/develop/lisp/com/informatimago/... McCarthy's implementation of Wang's algorithm from 1960. Run's unchanged in Common Lisp, with only very little support code. > CL somehow got everyone to agree they had sole ownership of the name. CL does not have the ownership of the name Lisp. But for many Lisp is like "German", a family of dialects which share literature, speech and an audience. Common Lisp is the main "German" dialect. Others are Emacs Lisp, ISLisp, Eulisp, XLisp, Franz Lisp, ... all those are closely related. Then Lisp is not "Germanic", which for example included English and German. English and German are Germanic languages, but they don't share literature, speech and the audience. Languages like Logo, Clojure, Newlisp and several others are 'lispy'. But they are not in any way compatible to Lisp. Porting a program means a full rewrite and re-architecture.
- copsarebastards 12y ago> McCarthy's implementation of Wang's algorithm from 1960. > Run's unchanged in Common Lisp, with only very little support code. Riiiiight, okay, so how difficult would it really be to change `defun trace (functions)` to `define (trace functions)` and a few other minor syntactic so it runs in Scheme? What you're saying is basically tantamount to a claim that CL has stayed truer to the syntax of McCarthy's Lisp, but it would be easy to argue that Scheme is truer to the mathematical principles of McCarthy's Lisp. Looking at syntax is a very shallow way to look at it. >> CL somehow got everyone to agree they had sole ownership of the name. > CL does not have the ownership of the name Lisp. I said "So at this point it's just a name, and I'm not sure what's to be gained even if CL somehow got everyone to agree they had sole ownership of the name." Please don't quote me out of context. The rest of your post is incoherent because you've used the isolated word "Lisp" despite the fact that this conversation is about the very fact that the meaning of "Lisp" is unclear. > Languages like Logo, Clojure, Newlisp and several others are 'lispy'. But they are not in any way compatible to Lisp. Porting a program means a full rewrite and re-architecture. Porting almost any CL program from CL to McCarthy's Lisp would require dropping most features. Hopefully this highlights the problem with this whole debate.
- aidenn0 12y agoIf you read that discussion, it actually hasn't. KMP, for example seems content to consider ISlisp and elisp as being lisps (not to mention the several pre-common lisp lisps such as maclisp and interlisp.