3 ms·
Ten bucks says gravity payments will be for sale within a year. This is an obvious PR ploy and I'm surprised HN is vulnerable to it.
by chatmasta 12y ago
Ten bucks says gravity payments will be for sale within a year. This is an obvious PR ploy and I'm surprised HN is vulnerable to it.
- nearmiss 12y agoGreat! Here's hoping the PR pays off. Imagine if other companies noticed it was a net gain to do this sort of thing and the practice picked up steam (unlikely/impossible I know). The horror of it all!
- totalrobe 12y agoAnd then those overpaid employees will be laid off...
- deong 12y agoIf you're buying the company for its "goodwill", why would you then very publicly torch that very same goodwill by laying off all the employees?
- chatmasta 12y agoBecause revenue needs to be greater than cost for a business to survive.
- deong 12y agoOf course, but my point is that you know this going in. The assumption was that you'd buy the company not because it was so insanely profitable, but because you reaped a PR benefit. So you buy the company for the sole reason that you look good for paying everyone well, and then take away all the money to increase profits. This makes no sense -- you look far worse PR-wise for revoking the raises than any benefit you originally got from buying them in the first place, and PR was your reason for the deal. This is like buying Santa's workshop so kids will like you and then executing all the elves. You should have just bought a profitable company in the first place.
- chatmasta 12y agoThe problem is it's unsustainable. The employees aren't providing $70k of market value. The CEO is changing his pay to attract attention and build customers. Companies are not going to adopt paying 2x market salary as a standard business practice. If people will work for $40k then that's where the costs will "gravitate" (hah) to.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The problem is it's unsustainable. The employees aren't providing $70k of market value. How do you know this? Sure, if you make the assumption that the before this one change, the world worked perfectly in line with the kind of simplifying assumptions that you might see in an Econ 101 class, then that would be true, but then, if the world worked that way, this raise wouldn't have happened.
- chatmasta 12y agoBecause they were willing to work for $40k.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Because they were willing to work for $40k. That doesn't mean that they weren't providing $70k of market value, unless you assume that (at a minimum): (1) they were maximimizing their pay in choice of job, and (2) they had perfect knowledge of all the alternatives jobs that they could otherwise have obtained. These are the kind of assumptions that are typical in Econ 101, but to which real humans do not actually conform, particularly the second.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIf someone volunteers for a non-profit for no pay, does that mean they're providing $0 in value? After all, they were willing to work for $0.
- emodendroket 12y agoHow long would they be willing to stay at that rate? Raises aren't entirely altruistic.
- leetrout 12y agoI'll take that bet.
- scott_s 12y agoYou can arrange it here: http://longbets.org/ http://longbets.org/
- vidarh 12y agoIt would be a silly PR ploy for the purposes of preparing the company for sale to announce how he's going to be drastically cutting into profits for the foreseeable future.
- gotrecruit 12y agofrequently, a business' goodwill is worth substantially more than their profits. if this successfully gains persisting goodwill for gravity payments, it might be worth the acquisition.
- wnevets 12y agowas it a PR ploy when henry ford did it?
- gopher2 12y agoYou're jumping to negative conclusions and making cynical generalizations. I think this is actually pretty cool.