12 ms·
Yes, You Can Catch Insanity
- niche 12y agoSounds like this kid was a super evolved humanoid whose special powers were tamed by pharmaceuticals
- fennecfoxen 12y ago> "He would smash his head into windows and glass whenever the word ‘dead’ came into his head." Yep, that totally makes me think super-evolved humanoid with special powers. 100%.
- goldenkey 12y agoYou say tomato. I say "hulksmash!"
- jdpage 12y ago(Warning: long screed tangent to the article.) To be fair, Superman locks himself in a closet because his powers are too scary, but yeah, this is totally a different case. There's this trope that people with mental illnesses—like John Nash, or Rain Man, or Sheldon Cooper, or all of these people who can paint perfect landscapes because they're on the autism spectrum or have brain trauma—are more advanced than people who aren't. And yeah, these people can do things that the rest of us would have a much harder time doing. But it also comes with the fact that the world is going to be a much harder place for them. For people who do have brain quirks that they can take advantage of, it can be a really empowering narrative. It can also be harmful for people whose brain quirks don't fit well into a role that's valued by society. There's a difficult line to find there; what kind of neuroatypical behaviour should or shouldn't be treated? Most people can agree that depression needs to be treated, because it's harmful to the sufferer with no benefit. Or if someone is hearing messages from aliens and running away from home and wandering about alone in altered mental states, it's fairly uncontroversial to put them on antipsychotics, even with the negative side-effects. But on the other hand, the idea of medicating ADHD kids is massively controversial, because the argument can be made that for many people diagnosed with it are either misdiagnosed, or are just bored or learn differently. But I also know ADHD people who legitimately cannot function if they don't take their medicine. What should be medicated or what shouldn't? Or here's an even more borderline case: what if someone is convinced that they're hearing messages from the beyond, and decides to spend the next ten years writing a book about how to live at peace with the world? What if the book doesn't make sense? Should they be medicated, because they've clearly broken with reality? Or should they be let alone, because there's a remote outside chance that maybe we're all wrong and they're on to something? Should they see a psychiatrist or a counsellor, who they can talk to and can keep track of how well they're doing? If so, should that person take an authority role, or should they be someone to be worked with to reach a mutually agreeable course of medication (which may be none at all)? Hence movements centred around neuroatypical people, and this narrative that they're potentially a next stage in human evolution. Certainly, there are plenty of neuroatypical people who have desirable traits because of it that could very well become the norm, but there are also plenty of people whose traits are simply going to be selected against. It's an incredibly attractive narrative for those people, though, because society doesn't tend to value them as people as much as 'neurotypical' people, which is absolutely terrible. I personally think that there are three big takeaways for this: 1. People are people, and should be valued as such. 2. Not everyone has a special talent that is valued by society, and that's okay. See #1. 3. Medication isn't fire-and-forget. It's something that needs to be constantly re-evaluated and carefully managed.
- niche 12y agoWell said. Let meditation be the medication.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoThe following is from personal experience. I think the most useful, helpful thing for mainstream society to do is not to treat "neuroatypicality" as a unified category. And I say this as a very neuroatypical person. But the thing is, when you get to the tails of the normal distributions for various cognitive and neurological functions, most of the individuals you find are cognitively and neurologically uneven. We may be significantly higher-functioning in one aspect, while being average in most other aspects, and sometimes lower-functioning in one or another aspect. The biggest mistake mainstream society makes is treating cognitive functioning as a uniform, one-dimensional spectrum from low-functioning (autistic people, low-IQ people, the "mentally ill", etc.) to very high functioning (so-called "geniuses" and "very well-balanced" people). I'll use myself as an example. The educational system simply never knew what the bloody hell to do with a small child who obviously suffered from nasty emotional disturbances, which were at least partially due to parental violence, and who obviously had difficulty interacting with others, and yet who simultaneously tested at the 98th percentile of intelligence and obviously wanted to make friends. "Gifted and talented" classes were designed for kids who were just as gifted in their self-organization as in their ability to read, write, and do maths, and who also cooperated easily with adults and wanted to work within the system. "Special education" was designed for the intellectually weak, the especially violent, and those utterly unable to direct themselves. I didn't fit into any category the system had. So I only started getting a really decent education when I entered university, where I was, pretty much for the first time, allowed to take mostly smart-kid classes and allowed to socialize without being branded as the dangerous idiot first thing. It worked great: I learned how to make friends and graduated with a solid circle of them, and I managed honors in computer science. Admittedly: I now wish I'd been able to weedle out the opportunities and privileges those Good Little Children got, since in adulthood I'm seeing just how much they were able to accomplish while I was having to push to be treated as a non-moron, but oh well. Weirdly enough, other than a post-undergrad bout of depression that apparently happens to everyone (but which nobody is ever told about...), the post-school world of work and research has been a pretty great experience! And here's the freakish thing: among the very... anything - the very intelligent, the very creative, the very emotional - none of this story has turned out all that unusual! I attend lesswrong.com meet-ups sometimes and find that pretty much everyone else there has stories just like mine. TL;DR: Society thinks that cognitive functioning ranges from "really great" to "really bad", with each particular aspect of mental functioning co-varying along a single dimension. This is approximately correct for middling cases - a person who's average all-around will usually be roughly the same level of average in each particular - but almost entirely wrong for people at the tails.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThere are some people who argue anti-fungal and anti-bacterial activity are actually behind the effectiveness of a variety drugs that are not thought of as such. Statins, for one example, clearly do save people from having a second heart attack, even though the official cholesterol story justifying the drug is problematic. Some say the statins are actually killing off a fungal infection. The article didn't even mention toxoplasmosis infection and links to mental illness and other behaviors. I don't think it's crazy to predict we're going to see more and more health and behavior problems directly linked to infectious agents over time. People bought this simple story that antibiotics saved us from all the infections 60 years ago.
- derefr 12y agoHuh. Similarly, I have managed to "cure" a number of infections in my own body, both fungal and bacterial—and even, apparently, a few cavities—purely with a course of extra-strength expectorants and mucosal-membrane rinses containing biologically-safe surfactants (e.g. baby shampoo.) Basically, we think of diseases as things we have to fight with drugs—but our immune systems are perfectly adequate at fighting blood-borne diseases, most of the time. The only thing the body really struggles with is plaques/biofilms—whether in the heart, in the liver, in the tonsils, in the teeth, in the appendix, etc. And we've invented tons of things that break up plaques/biofilms: surfactants, mucosal thinners, ultrasound, etc. But we only apply them in very specific cases (ultrasound only for free-floating stones, mucosal thinners only for lung problems, scraping for arterial plaque, etc.) instead of thinking that this is a class of problems, that will have a class of solutions that all apply to any instance of the problem. I bring this up because, by your statement, statins sound like yet another item in that "biofilm-reducing" class of treatments that all happen to have some miraculous and mysterious effect on both chronic fungal/bacterial infections and inflammatory disease (Chron's, IBS, etc.)
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoI found permanent relief from a couple long lasting problems with the application of xylitol, tea tree oil, and taking high dose aspirin. Antibiotics had been useless. In my unfortunately personal experience doctors are almost entirely ignorant on the matter of biofilms at the moment and will simply keep blasting you with antibiotics.
- rrss1122 12y agoI believe it's the stranglehold of the pharmaceutical industry on psychology that prevents research like this from going forward. Instances like Isak's ordeal with PANDAS and Susannah Cahalan's battle with anti-NMDA receptor encephalitis show that more research should go into how infections and autoimmune response can cause some forms of mental illness. I was particuarly appalled when I read that doctors gave Isak anti-depressants to treat his mental illness. These are the medicines the pharmaceutical industry have been pushing on us for decades to treat any malady of the mind, and they have been proven to be barely more effective than placebo treatments. Their first priority is pushing pills, not our well-being.
- task_queue 12y ago> These are the medicines the pharmaceutical industry have been pushing on us for decades to treat any malady of the mind, and they have been proven to be barely more effective than placebo treatments. Weird, the studies where they're given to sufferers of severe depression and anxiety say otherwise.
- untothebreach 12y agoSure, for severe cases studies have shown that depression medication helps, but that is not what the parent said: ...to treat any malady of the mind, and they have been proven to be barely more effective than placebo treatments Which is also shown by studies[1][2] 1: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7945737 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7945737 2: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18303940 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18303940
- task_queue 12y agoThat is true, but "any malady of the mind" is a blanket statement encompassing severe depression. It gives the impression that the medications are not significantly better than placebo for any mental illness, when in fact they are significantly effective for certain mental illnesses.
- epistasis 12y ago
- contagiouse 12y agoI thought this was going to be an article about Dr. Donald Ewen Cameron, notoriously associated with Project MKUltra, and his curious hypothesis of contagious mental illnesses and how psychiatric conditions might possibly be transmitted by way of the mere interactions of differing personalities, and institutional social norms: Cameron stated, "Get it understood how dangerous these damaged, sick personalities are to ourselves - and above all, to our children, whose traits are taking form and we shall find ways to put an end to them." [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Ewen_Cameron#Mental_illness_as_a_social_contagion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Ewen_Cameron#Mental_ill...
- mellavora 12y agoPoor kid. Glad the ordeal is over. Mind/body. It's one system. Of course issues with one impact the other. However--Not all mental disease is caused by infection. Schizophrenia, for example, is associated with a number of abnormalities in brain structure.
- wusher 12y agoRecent research is showing a link forming between Schizophrenia and Toxoplasmosis infections. http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/11/03-0143_article http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/11/03-0143_article http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toxoplasmosis
- tim333 12y agoSchizophrenia's a complex one. It seems to be associated with human endogenous retrovirus-W (HERV-W): >Several other studies have since found similar active elements of HERV-W in the blood or brain fluids of people with schizophrenia. One, published by Perron in 2008, found HERV-W in the blood of 49 percent of people with schizophrenia, compared with just 4 percent of healthy people. “The more HERV-W they had,” Perron says, “the more inflammation they had.” The odd thing is HERV-W is a viral sequence which entered the human genome many millions of years ago. It is normally suppressed but can cause problems sometimes triggered by other infections. http://discovermagazine.com/2010/jun/03-the-insanity-virus http://discovermagazine.com/2010/jun/03-the-insanity-virus
- fiatmoney 12y agoInteresting synchronicity with this result that pain killers / anti-inflamatories seem to have psychological effects: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/releases/acetaminophen-may-reduce-both-pain-and-pleasure.html https://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/news/releases...
- pera 12y agoJust two days ago I found this article: Do Bartonella Infections Cause Agitation, Panic Disorder, and Treatment-Resistant Depression? http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2100128/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2100128/
- rasur 12y agoAn aside (and trying not to be snide with it) but you can certainly be indoctrinated into Insanity (or perhaps Brainwashed might be a better term). Just look at Religion and/or Cults. To be sure, not the same cause, but debatably a variant on the theme of 'insanity'
- DanBC 12y agoInsanity is an outdated term that usually refers to psychosis type illnesses. When a person has a conversation with their God figure this happens in (roughly) one of two ways. 1) they say a prayer and spend some introspective time thinking 2) they have an actual conversation with a real voice. Is someone in the room with you? Ask them to say something. An auditory hallucination voice is as real as that voice; it just happens to come from something that isn't there. EDIT {this second one is what we would call"insane" or "ill" or "pathalogical". But the vast majority of religious people do not experience this, ever, no matter how religious they are.} Describing religious behaviour as insanity isn't helpful. It shows a lack of understanding of mental illness. It's not an effective attack on the harms that some forms of religion can do.
- Crito 12y agoWhether you want to call it mental illness or insanity (I am neither a doctor nor a lawyer, do I don't have any preference for either term..), I cannot fathom how the second possibility that you list does not qualify. People who are experiencing auditory hallucinations while fully awake and rested should seek professional help. The first possibility would not be so worrying if people were not attributing their own introspective thoughts to a flawless perfect benevolent supernatural being. Nobody should ever be that confident of their own ideas. I think the attribution of the introspective thought to a supernatural being (not the introspective thought itself) can reasonably be thought of as "crazy". I'm not saying it is in DSM, that there is some sort of recognized illness that it can be attributed to, but it certainly isn't rational thinking.
- DanBC 12y agoYes! Sorry, i hadn't finished. You're quite right, the second one is insanity. But most religious people don't have that experience. I'll edit my comment.
- elf25 12y ago'splains Randy Quaid... kind of.
- MollyR 12y agoIt's fascinating and makes sense. It's just personally horrifying to think, an infection could one day slowly drive me insane. I really hope we start getting everyone their personalized genome, so we can start working on targeted cures based on an individuals genome.
- derefr 12y agoI find it odd that medical treatment insists on being so causal—diagnosing a specific illness, and then treating for that illness, but never, ever treating if you don't have evidence of a particular illness. It makes sense if you're dealing with hypochondriacs or drug-seekers, and it makes epidemiological sense to withhold some treatments from prophylactic use (like antibiotics) to preserve their efficacy. But if you're dealing with an idiopathic illness for over four years, I would think there would come a time where you'd ask the doctor, "can I just try some antibiotics to see what happens? And how about some antiretrovirals, antiparasitics, and antifungals while you're at it?" Just methodically working through the safe, first-line treatments to the major disease classes, taking each for a month or so and seeing what happens, would probably fix 90% of people's chronic illnesses. Even if it didn't, paying attention to people's reactions to being on various medications are some of the best diagnostic tools there are—which second-line treatment regime to pursue would likely become rapidly apparent. But instead, people can go years slowly dying from something that they could fix with a few pills from the corner pharmacy, if a doctor would deign to "tinker" rather than working from theory.
- epistasis 12y agoGiven the side effects, and the huge number of potential treatments, I don't think that the course pursued in this case was in any way unreasonable. They did try something "random" after a while. Doctors are not infallible, but neither are they idiots. Before suggesting a radical departure for how medicine works, it may be worthwhile to learn a lot more about why it is the way it is right now. >Just methodically working through the safe, first-line treatments to the major disease classes, taking each for a month or so and seeing what happens, would probably fix 90% of people's chronic illnesses. 90% huh? I'm in no way confident that we have a diverse enough set of interventions in our medical toolkit to fix that much, or that we could find the proper one in a suitable amount of time.
- derefr 12y agoMy (unsupported) hypothesis is that the causative agents behind chronic idiopathic illnesses obey a power law: that there should be one treatment that will help an extremely large percentage of people (greater than 30%, say) that should be a "first-line idiopathic treatment regime", and then another treatment that covers another 10%, and then a rapid decline into a long tail of interventions that will only help a few percent of people each. I say this because the causes of idiopathic diseases, when revealed, seem to be similar in structure to the causes of idiopathically failing companies, or idiopathically broken computers, or idiopathically recidivist criminals: namely, that there is some obvious-after-the-fact property of the environment, which combines with a person who never learned how to deal with/be hygienic in the case of/avoid that property. Computers choke on dust; criminals have friends/family who are in debt and need money; companies hire workers based on status rather than efficacy. None of the subjects of these forces realize that they need to do something about them (clean the computer; get their family to declare bankruptcy; give objective tests to their workers), so they get worse and worse until someone who actually knows enough about their life, while also not being immersed in the subculture that is missing the hygienic knowledge, comes along and helps them. For the case of criminals (and bad parents), this is the job of social workers. For dentistry, you've got dental hygienists. But who is supposed to teach people how to avoid fungal infections, if it's not part of their implicit cultural package of knowledge? Who's supposed to teach them why they should care about the effects of their diet on their blood pressure, if hey have no family history of hypertension? Etc. And because of that gap in cultural hygiene-knowledge transmission, I have a strong feeling that a few interventions that directly target the knowledge gaps equivalent to "have you tried blowing compressed air into the computer's vent?" Would have an extremely outsized impact in these cases.
- yellowapple 12y agoNo, you can't catch insanity, seeing as "insanity" is strictly a legal term; "insanity" is not a vaild diagnosis per any psychological standard that I'm aware of (most notably the DSM-IV).
- duckdogkitty 12y agoI completely agree with this article, based on my own experiences. My wife acquired Bipolar 2 after a prolonged systemic infection at 30 years old. After years of hospitals, tests, virtual bankruptcy and little to no progress, I decided to do something. I started by looking at human population studies which showed lower incidences of her mental illness, and based on differences in diet, exercise, and medicines I discovered a possible difference in India from WHO publications and . After reviewing several PubMed and other academic papers on the subject, I thought perhaps that dietary difference may account for disease incidence differences. So, comparing the most common Indian food ingredients versus US diets, I came across turmeric. Turmeric has shown strong anti-inflammatory properties, positive effects on astocyte cell regrowth, and may improve neural myelination. It is used in many Indian dishes but relatively few American dishes. It's used throughout the middle east and asia, but mostly for grilling. So I purchased imported Indian turmeric, and started cooking it into all that I could every day, especially soups and other combinations with pepper and oil as it's done in India. Inside two months and she started to sleep less than her typical 16 hours a day. She quit listening to music all her waking hours. Her mood made positive strides. She played with the children. It was a small, however exceptionally positive change. Following five years of improvements, the outcomes have been great. She is again driving, teaching, and just needs her single medication at the most minimal measurement essential. She now has clear thinking, great memory, and no longer experiences the symptoms of side effects. She has not been hospitalized since. Take it as quackery, miracle, or however you like. Perhaps it may help someone, someday. I know studies are in being proposed, and perhaps it may improve the lives of others.
- epmatsw 12y agoI've actually heard good things about turmeric. If you don't mind me asking, why imported Indian turmeric though? Is it different from what you would get in the States (aka what I've got in my pantry)?
- duckdogkitty 12y agoI wanted to emulate the dietary environment as closely as possible. I don't know if US turmeric is the same, so it was easier to just get imported from an Asian grocery. Many ingredients we get in the USA are not the same as elsewhere. For instance, cinnamon and vanilla extract can vary.
- Falkon1313 12y agoI find it interesting because strep is very easy to test for and very easy to cure (for the most part - although the test failed in this case), but I've seen such a wide variety of responses to it. When I was young, the doctors would always test and almost always prescribe antibiotics. Initially they gave shots, which of course I hated as a kid, but they were effective and very fast - within a few days I'd be better. Then they switched to multiple week courses of pills, which also worked but left you sick a lot longer. (Now I wish they'd go back to shots.) Then something weird happened - they quit testing and started guessing. A quick glance down the throat followed by either "May be strep, here's a prescription." or "Might go away on its own. Come back in a couple weeks if it hasn't gone away." I know people who ended up hospitalized because of this. Even if it might not get worse, why make them suffer extra weeks, miss school/work, and risk it getting worse when it could so easily be tested and treated with a cheap, readily-available cure? I wonder why testing and applying an appropriate response to test results fell out of fashion in general. How much more advanced might psychiatric medicine be if doctors generally did test like scientists (not just for strep, but whatever) instead of guessing like astrologers? There's probably a lot that could have already been discovered.
- MrFree 12y agoThe 1st/top comment on this article by Steve C is very interesting.
- raldu 12y agoHere is a related story about a urinary tract infection causing psychotic symptoms and some additional thoughts on immune system, psychosis, and evolution. Infection and Psychosis in Schizophrenia http://evolutionarypsychiatry.blogspot.com.tr/2013/06/infection-and-psychosis-in-schizophrenia.html http://evolutionarypsychiatry.blogspot.com.tr/2013/06/infect...