3 ms·
It's an impressive achievement, but I've been around a long time and seen lots of those. It's even more impressive given the age of the dev, and I hope he gets
by ColinWright 12y ago
It's an impressive achievement, but I've been around a long time and seen lots of those. It's even more impressive given the age of the dev, and I hope he gets the chance to improve, develop, and contribute to the art and science in general.
His bot just said this, though:
"It's I know a fair bit."
That just screams "Eliza!" to me. I remember implementing Eliza back in 1979, copying the text from a magazine, and then looking to see how I could improve it. I did write a much better version that didn't make so many grammatical howlers, but that's now lost in the mists of time.
It's interesting to see how much, and simultaneously how little, the art/science has progressed, especially given the wealth of tools and data available.
- aristus 12y agoProgress isn't just about the upper bounds of human achievement, but also the average. I think it's a mistake to confuse the two, or to place one too high above the other. Of all people you should appreciate that. :) If the next generation tackles calc or recursion even one year earlier or one percentage point more often than yours did, that's a huge cumulative win.
- ColinWright 12y ago> "Of all people you should appreciate that." I do know that - I know that very well. I'm just interested to see that with all the vast amount of progress that has been made, and all the tools available for language analysis, this system still make mistakes like that. I'd love to see more about how much this is gluing together existing components, and how much is original to the project. Back when I was doing this everything had to be written by hand, from scratch. So much time was spent/wasted in basic, underlying stuff. It's fantastic that people now have so many resources that they don't have to start from so far back, and the inventiveness can shine through. I'd love to see the inventiveness in this and other projects, but it's hard to see what's really new.
- seanlevan 12y agoThat's the interesting thing- I am not, unlike most chatterbot projects, using existing technologies and jumbling it together- a quick glance at the "read more" page on the technologies of ACUMAN will tell you otherwise. Everything is made from scratch. From the ground-up. I could have used AIML (the AI version of XML), or anything I wanted. But instead, to make it unique and customizable to the demand of this project, I created my own markup language entitled ACUMANSCRIPT. Even the sentiment analysis algorithms are made from scratch by using Naive Bayens algorithms. The only APIs in use are those for some aspects of the knowledge base, which is a must in any machine learning or artificial intelligence project, as not leveraging the massive amount of data available on the internet would be a waste. I sincerely doubt that we are anywhere near a flawless piece of artificial intelligence software, but this is not a result of people's lack of diligence in the field, but rather a testimony to it's complexities. Google has made a short documentary explaining why natural language processing and machine learning are some of the hardest fields due to their surprisingly complex nature: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxxRAHVtafI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxxRAHVtafI
- ColinWright 12y agoRight, that's much more interesting, especially making your own markup. Did you read extensively and decide that AIML and friends were not really suitable and hence you had to make your own, or did you make your own because you wanted to get a feel for the problem domain before trying to take advantage of the work others have done? ... doubt that we are anywhere near a flawless piece of artificial intelligence software, but this is not a result of people's lack of diligence in the field, but rather a testimony to its complexities. That is certainly true. ... a quick glance at the "read more" page on the technologies ... That button isn't working on my browser: the latest Firefox on the latest Ubuntu. When I get time I'll look at it using Chrome, but I've got other stuff on at the moment. It would be interesting to know more about ACUMANSCRIPT - are you intending to release it or otherwise make it available? How are you tapping into the "knowledge bases"? If these questions are answered in the (currently no working for me) link on your page then don't answer them again here, but you might want to write a page specifically talking about these things and submit that here.
- seanlevan 12y agoWhile I understand where you are coming from, obviously the bot is not flawless, but it is ridiculous to compare our technology today to Eliza. ACUMAN uses a wealth of knowledge bases and natural language processing to comprehend and accurately give responses. Obviously, the field is invariably complex, but I find it absurd to say that it has increased so little, considering that it was never dreamed of that a bot would be able to answer the exact release date of a specific musical album, for instance. It is still a work in progress, but I don't understand why it would be a huge turnoff that there was a simple grammatical error in the bot where he inadvertently prepended a contraction "it's" before the actual answer.
- ColinWright 12y agoFrom the two responses I've had it would seem that my comment is going to be misunderstood and misinterpreted. Fair enough. I could write essays on this (in fact, I have when I took Philosophy as a minor to accompany my Pure Maths and Computer Science courses) and comments here just aren't going to cut it. As I say, fair enough. The responses I'm getting from it have a consistent feel. They are either reciting facts, or they are totally non-committal. Here: "I don't like picking favorites. Everything that is something regarded with special favor or liking seems good to me." That has all the feeling of a canned response. I know the advances that have been made, I know how impressive this thing actually is, I know how hard it is to do this, and I know the work that must have gone into it. And even knowing all of that, when it makes what are to humans trivial grammatical mistakes, it takes away from all that and reduces it to a machine. My comments are not intended to diminish the accomplishment, but to highlight a place where the illusion gets broken. If you have a large, totally white canvas with one small, off-center black dot, what will people look at? So please understand that this is not a dismissal of the work, or of the achievement, but a highlighting of one specific point that disproportionally detracts from the effectiveness. To continue to provide feedback to try to help, it just rendered like this: http://www.solipsys.co.uk/images/acuman.png http://www.solipsys.co.uk/images/acuman.png Latest Firefox on latest Ubuntu. edit: That's just a grab of part of the screen, I can do the whole window if you'd like to see the context. Edit: It would be nice to have some details about how it is doing what it's doing. They might be there, but I haven't had time to rummage much, as I'm in the middle of other things. Someone mentioned AIML. I will be back to look again later.