I'm not sure either applied, as least from the four or five reviews that I read in great depth. His reviews were opinionated, and touched on themes that he tho

I'm not sure either applied, as least from the four or five reviews that I read in great depth. His reviews were opinionated, and touched on themes that he though were important - but by and large weren't overly detailed or comprehensive. He sought to capture the overall arc of the growth of OS X, rather than regurgitate every new feature.