10 ms·
L.A. school district ditches iPad curriculum
- zaroth 12y agoMore like seeks refund from Pearson? The body of the article directly contradicts the headline. I'm hope that FBI investigation turns up some dirt, Pearson is a name that comes up too often in public education, and seems like universally negative reactions. How do such shit companies manage to gain such a stranglehold, particularly when it comes to government contracts? Across 50 states and the innumerable local governments which enter into these contracts, is it literally graft all the way through? Clever seems like the one breath of fresh air into the system. Maybe they will get into actual curriculum development in the future.
- bruceb 12y agoyep their beef is with Pearson: In its letters, the district said it wants to meet this month to arrange “the dissociation from Pearson and recoup the costs of Pearson licenses that we paid for but have been unable to use.” Board member Monica Ratliff, who chaired a technology committee that raised serious questions about the effort, said the district has been patient with Pearson but that time has ended. “I believe that it is time for Pearson to either deliver on its promises immediately or provide us with a refund so that we can purchase curriculum that actually works for our students,” she said in a statement.
- MCRed 12y agoIn answer to your question, corruption. Buying influence, access and lucrative contracts is a lot more common than I think people seem to think about on a day to day basis.
- chaostheory 12y agoThe misleading title involving Apple is really just to get more eyeballs.
- roel_v 12y agoThe article says clearly that Pearson was a subcontractor to Apple. Seems that Apple was leading the deal. Not sure how the schools would even take this up with Pearson. If Pearson really is a subcontractor, the real party to have a beef with is Apple.
- pyvpx 12y agoI want to know more about the 800MM on "improving" Internet access. that seems absurdly high, even for one of the top three school districts in the nation (by size)
- jv22222 12y agoI work in a k12 ed tech company. In most schools I've seen, by the time the internet gets to the users device, the quality of service is astonishingly bad. Even in schools that purport to have a big pipe coming in. Low bandwidth per user, bad access points, frequency clashing, broken switches, aggressive content filtering and firewalls all add up to making it really hard for a student to stream even one educational video from youtube. 5 students in the same class, forget it!
- dinergy 12y agoWe have none of those issues. We block Youtube because when opened students don't stream "educational" videos. They sit in the library watching sports, anime, and inappropriate content. Aggressive filtering, unfortunately, is a necessary evil because students are kids who, en mass, are irresponsible and make dumb choices.
- smackfu 12y agoIt's not really Internet access, it's wifi. And wifi for a one-to-one deployment in existing schools gets pretty involved and expensive if you are doing it right.
- dinergy 12y agoNot really given size. We're a tiny district < 1K student body, and we've spent perhaps 1/4m on a infrastructure refresh; we deployed a new wireless network, replaced edge and core l2 and l3 switches, etc. Consider LA has 600K+ students across the district, multiple facilities, and tens of thousands of staff I would say that is on the low end of infrastructure costs. Our four site WAN runs > 30K/year, 100Mbps circuit is 24K, we're already at ~60K/y in operating costs. It is easy to see how 800mil on infrastructure is probably not enough.
- hanlec 12y agotl;dr There wouldn't have been enough eyes on this article if it correctly stated the issue is with Pearson and not the iPad or Apple.
- BuckRogers 12y agoThey've just kept Apple on the hit list because they know they had more money than brains to attempt to purchase an iPad for each student. If they want to add more technology to the classroom, hire some programmers to build educational software with a committee of teachers. Make it a webapp so the district can use whatever array of hardware they already own. This was just a school district looking to waste money as far as I can tell. "Deasy had said the technology effort was a civil rights imperative designed to provide low-income students with devices available to their wealthier peers." And what a civil rights effort. Slow clap. If you want to do something to help equalize them with their wealthier peers, buy them all Learn Python the Hard Way. Which would satisfy their need to waste money, because that book is free online.
- FleshGordon 12y agoContrary to popular belief everyone REALLY doesn't need to be a programmer.
- seanp2k2 12y agoNope, but everyone doesn't need to be a mathematician, biologist, geologist, historian, or any of the other primary subjects in school either. I think that in 2015 it's hard to argue that a basic grasp of computers / software won't have at least as big of an effect on your quality of life after graduation as being able to work quadratic equations by hand, without reference.
- borgia 12y agoI've personally been pretty irked by the whole "EVERYONE SHOULD LEARN TO CODE ASAP" narrative being pushed basically everywhere recently, but I agree with you here. Sticking something like python onto the school curriculum would only be a good thing. The vast majority who do it won't become programmers, just as the vast majority who sit math don't become mathematicians, etc. but it would give kids a fun and interesting way to learn logic, create things on the computer for themselves, etc. They have problems unique to them that they may be able to spin up little desktop apps or similar to solve, which could then go on to inspire them to become entrepreneurs, tech product creators, etc. Regardless, there would be absolutely no harm in making it available to them.
- threatofrain 12y agoAside from how Pearson performed, I'm rather surprised that they choose to buy so many iPads. What does the iPad offer to the pedagogical process? Are they teaching kids about programming or computer skills? Probably not. Did they expect Pearson to produce an entire curriculum just for the iPad? Why not a website instead, which is so much more easily accessed and maintained? Did these schools want to be "technological" for the sake of it? And for general student tasks, is the iPad really a good fit? As opposed to a conventional computer running Microsoft Office or a browser with Google Drive? And that computer could do other things too?
- dima55 12y agoYes. Exactly.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> Did they expect Pearson to produce an entire curriculum just for the iPad? More or less, yes: "Under the contract, Pearson was to provide English and math curriculum." > Why not a website instead The article says "Deasy had said the technology effort was a civil rights imperative designed to provide low-income students with devices available to their wealthier peers." It's easy for you and me to assume that every man, woman, and child in America has easy access to the web, but it's not necessarily so. Giving a tablet to every single student does seem like a reasonable way to level the playing field. In theory, it would be more portable, simpler to use and maintain, and less abusable than, say, a laptop. It's unfortunate that things broke down along the way. This could have been a really good idea, if it was implemented properly.
- Nullabillity 12y agoIf you want to level the playing field then giving out devices that are effectively only useful for consuming content is not the way to go.
- eXpl0it3r 12y agoI can't stand when writers artificially lengthen the article and only after the first half get actually to the point: > “Only two schools of 69 in the Instructional Technology Initiative ... use Pearson regularly,” according to an internal March report from project director Bernadette Lucas. “Any given class typically experiences one problem or more daily. Teachers report that the students enjoy the interactive content — when it’s available. When it’s not, teachers and students try to roll with the interruptions to teaching and learning as best they can.”
- 4927a15fe7b0c35 12y agoThis is almost 100% about Pearson. The article even has this gem buried toward the end: Although the threatened legal action applies to Apple and Pearson, the district also sent letters Tuesday to two other companies: Lenovo, a device maker, and Arey Jones, a computer distributor. These companies also have included the Pearson product on some devices purchased by L.A. Unified. So, they had problems with non-Apple devices as well? There's also this statement: Pearson could offer only a partial curriculum during the first year of the license, which was permitted under the agreement. Teachers and principals never widely embraced the product. Okay, so the product they bought wasn't embraced. And there aren't any real reasons given other than a vague: “Any given class typically experiences one problem or more daily." What does that even mean?
- pjc50 12y ago“Any given class typically experiences one problem or more daily." It means there is a complex system that isn't reliable enough for its target usage and the end users have no way of pressuring for its improvement.
- 4927a15fe7b0c35 12y agoMy issue with the statement is two fold: 1) "Any given" really isn't the same as "every". It's vague and ambiguous, and generally means it happens often, but is not a useful measure of incidence. 2) A deployment of this number of devices + custom software will have problems, that has to be accepted. One problem, without knowing what it is, really isn't enough to say the thing is a failure. In fact, it's not even close. Is the problem that someone has to restart their iPad? That the content freezes? The content is inaccessible? The content is incomplete? The Wi-Fi goes down? The teacher's materials aren't working? We really have no idea, and that kind of comment in this kind of story is adversarial and unnecessary.
- fit2rule 12y agoIts not entirely almost 100% not about Apple. There's a small percentage of the complaint which refers to the hassle that the school infrastructures need to go through in order to update the curriculum - Apple have a finger in that pie, do not forget.
- jimhefferon 12y agoPublic discussion of education is always hampered by the fact that people not professionals in it have no sense of how complicated it is. Some students are genuises, some are cognitively low. Some students have personality disorders. Some students will soak up everything they see. Others don't care. Some students need to be a medical treatments at various times during the week. Some pray five times a day. Some are so stoned they cannot hold a pencil. Some really only care about what they need to do in this class in order to to play basketball. When a vendor comes in and says, "We know how to solve your problems," there is reason to be doubtful. I'm not saying that such efforts have no promise, but there typically needs to be a long growth period during which the tools have to be adapted, sometimes radically. In this complicated a sphere, bottom-up may well work better than top-down.
- ams6110 12y agoAre you an education professional? I'm not, but I wonder why we don't go back to the model of segregating students by ability/need. It seems like the trend today is to "mainstream" everyone into a common classroom, so you have high achievers, low ability, as well as genuinely abnormal (mentally retarded, severe behavorial problems, etc.) all together. I see no way that can be effective for any of them because you will not be able to provide the style of instruction that each of these constituencies need.
- tomswartz07 12y agoThey currently do, to a point. Lower functioning students are provided with much more 'hands on' teaching situations. I don't know how effective separating student more would be- one could argue that at a certain point it might harm the students because of the lack of socialization. A selection bias of social awkwardness, if you will.
- keithpeter 12y agoI am a teacher. Ability/need isn't a scalar quantity and real students don't distribute themselves in a way that can be described by a couple of parameters. I don't know what the answers are either but I think we need to be very explicit about any assumptions underpinning proposed models. I also agree with the 'bottom up' part of the gf comment. Now, what discrete 'styles of instruction' are there do you think?
- WalterBright 12y agoI've always been skeptical that computers would make learning effortless. It's like expecting that driving a car would make one better at running marathons. Learning requires effort, one way or another, just like exercise.
- skywhopper 12y agoI don't know the history of this deal, but I'm entirely unsurprised that this didn't work out. Digital tools are just not up to snuff. Experiments like this are worth doing, but not with an entire school district. And jumping in when there's no actual curriculum yet is completely irresponsible. Blaming Pearson and Apple is disingenuous of the district. Of course salespeople are going to lie and overpromise. Anyone who's spent any time in any business knows this. The administrators and board members who agreed to this deal are the ones who are responsible. That $768 for each iPad and software could have bought a lot of books and classroom supplies for these kids that would have enriched their lives a lot more. The overhead of supporting all these new devices likely drained a lot of operational money from other areas as well. And there's absolutely zero evidence that tablets or computers are better ways to teach kids than traditional methods. Turning over all the responsibility for educating our children to a corporation with a magic solution sounds like a brilliant plan because we want to believe there's an easy way to solve the problem, but there's not one, and this is so much snake oil, and the people in charge should be wise to this stuff by now.
- panzagl 12y agoOur school district does this regularly with non-digitized curricula- drops a couple $100K, threatens teachers with penalties if they don't teach 'to fidelity', gives it about a year, scores don't magically skyrocket, teachers start abandoning the curriculum (they're still responsible for the scores), then it ends up in the resource room and the process starts again. It's ridiculous how often school districts keep buying magic beans, then blame the teachers when they don't work out.
- smoyer 12y ago"Pearson defended its product." This is a company whose business model is being disrupted and whose life will be getting a lot worse if they don't recognize that students (particularly college students) will no longer be cash cows they can milk via textbook/curriculum sales.
- a3n 12y ago> She said although there have been challenges in carrying out “a large-scale implementation of new technologies ... we stand by the quality of our performance.” New? What's new about it? It's a computer with stuff on it.
- tomswartz07 12y agoI'm currently working at a school district in Lancaster, PA. We have gone with Linux laptops for all of our students. Even more, we've given them root access. We chose this because of exactly the points that many people are bringing up in these comments. What does the iPad offer to the pedagogical process? Not really that much outside of the sanitary iOS enviroment. Are they teaching kids about programming or computer skills? Probably not. However, with a laptop (and root access), students are able to, and encouraged to play around and experiment. Yes, we have some students that don't care about it at all, but there are others that have created some genuinely interesting projects. We've actually modified and used one of their projects to help support the linux laptop deployment. More info: http://www.pennmanor.net/techblog/?cat=69 http://www.pennmanor.net/techblog/?cat=69 My boss did an amazing TEDx talk regarding the subject: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8Co37GO2Fc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8Co37GO2Fc
- keithpeter 12y agoExcellent project. I especially liked slide 5 of your presentation... http://www.pennmanor.net/techblog/1to1devices/#/5 http://www.pennmanor.net/techblog/1to1devices/#/5 I'm wondering what materials the students are working with. I'm hoping it isn't some kind of holistic purchased package as per the OA.
- tomswartz07 12y agoThanks! The project launched last year with the High School, and this coming school year we will be expanding to the Middle Schools. It was genuinely exciting to see the students helping their peers. It's almost all stock Ubuntu, Google Apps for Education, and a few other tools thrown in. We aim for Open Source where we can.
- keithpeter 12y agoBy 'materials' I meant what the (entirely mythical) Mrs Scroggins uses with class 3P at 10:30 am on Tuesdays when they are learning to solve one degree linear equations. I'd imagine that Mrs Scroggins continues to use her trusty textbooks for routine skills development, perhaps with a few Khan academy resources, some mathpapa demos and, perhaps, a group exercise where students work together in Google Apps to document their steps in solving some bobbydazzlers.
- upofadown 12y ago>The district selected Pearson based only on samples of curriculum — nothing more was available. So they bought hardware to run software that didn't exist.
- keithpeter 12y agoYes, I noticed that as well. Just to play Devil's Advocate for a bit: assume 12 hours of material each week (Maths/English lessons plus some homework tasks), and a 36 week school year. I'm assuming something like ages 11 to 16, so something like 2160 hours total. That is a fair amount to author before you have a contract is it not? (As a teacher myself, I would have suggested leading into the scheme with 10% of that with good quality interactive material broken into small enough topics so the teachers could integrate it with what they use already.)
- greedo 12y agoPearson is horrible, but the educational software field itself is just as horrible. In 2000 I worked for a small startup that created online courseware. Our roots were as a spinoff from a Federal grant to a big name university. Our task was to commercialize the courses the university had developed, and to develop additional courses. Granted that technology in 2000 was not as advanced as today, but the pedagogy behind online/computer based courses was still in its infancy. It would take us 6 months to develop a basic Biology course, using programmers, SMEs, editors, and graphic artists. We turned out what was a pretty good course all things considered. Where the real problem lay was the selling/marketing process. School districts are by nature conservative, and new ideas/technology that threaten established teaching methods are viewed with a gimlet eye. Textbook publishers had a lock on the market and didn't want to give up any ground to an intruder. Teachers were afraid of being replaced by computers, leading to widespread skepticism of distance learning. And the technological competence of teachers and administrators at the time was bad; they had too much other things to worry about than to understand the difference between Java and Javascript. So to me, it doesn't seem like a lot has changed in 15 years. The established vendors want to protect their market, the buyers, though pushed to embrace technology don't know how to use it well, and the students are left holding a bag of shit.
- shams93 12y agoThe thing is no one is going to rob a kid for a $150 chromebook, some parts of LA are not so friendly and a kid walking home with $1000 in hardware is not just in danger of losing the ipad but of being injured or killed in the robbery. Ultimately chromeos does a much better job, and gives kids a platform to learn javascript which is the language of the future anyways. Nobody is going to risk prison for a chromebook but robbery for apple gear is not uncommon.
- neovive 12y agoI've been running a coding/tech club in a K-5 school and find the iPads work very well for younger students (K-2). Most are uncomfortable with trackpads and lack typing skills. The iPad is very intuitive and productive for them. I'm currently working through a short curriculum for K-2 using the Scratch Jr. app. Grades 3-5 use 11" Macbooks running the full Scratch application. The iPad's are a great way to prepare younger students for "real" computing. I would not recommend tablets as a primary computing device beyond 2nd grade as "creation" capabilities are limited; the iPad turns into a media consumption device at that age.
- bko 12y agoIn a 1996 Wired interview, Steve Jobs was asked whether technology could help education in the US. I think his answer was spot on. > Could technology help by improving education? I used to think that technology could help education. I've probably spearheaded giving away more computer equipment to schools than anybody else on the planet. But I've had to come to the inevitable conclusion that the problem is not one that technology can hope to solve. What's wrong with education cannot be fixed with technology. No amount of technology will make a dent. It's a political problem. The problems are sociopolitical. The problems are unions. You plot the growth of the NEA [National Education Association] and the dropping of SAT scores, and they're inversely proportional. The problems are unions in the schools. The problem is bureaucracy. I'm one of these people who believes the best thing we could ever do is go to the full voucher system. I have a 17-year-old daughter who went to a private school for a few years before high school. This private school is the best school I've seen in my life. It was judged one of the 100 best schools in America. It was phenomenal. The tuition was $5,500 a year, which is a lot of money for most parents. But the teachers were paid less than public school teachers - so it's not about money at the teacher level. I asked the state treasurer that year what California pays on average to send kids to school, and I believe it was $4,400. While there are not many parents who could come up with $5,500 a year, there are many who could come up with $1,000 a year. If we gave vouchers to parents for $4,400 a year, schools would be starting right and left. People would get out of college and say, "Let's start a school." You could have a track at Stanford within the MBA program on how to be the businessperson of a school. And that MBA would get together with somebody else, and they'd start schools. And you'd have these young, idealistic people starting schools, working for pennies. They'd do it because they'd be able to set the curriculum. When you have kids you think, What exactly do I want them to learn? Most of the stuff they study in school is completely useless. But some incredibly valuable things you don't learn until you're older - yet you could learn them when you're younger. And you start to think, What would I do if I set a curriculum for a school? God, how exciting that could be! But you can't do it today. You'd be crazy to work in a school today. You don't get to do what you want. You don't get to pick your books, your curriculum. You get to teach one narrow specialization. Who would ever want to do that? These are the solutions to our problems in education. Unfortunately, technology isn't it. You're not going to solve the problems by putting all knowledge onto CD-ROMs. We can put a Web site in every school - none of this is bad. It's bad only if it lulls us into thinking we're doing something to solve the problem with education. Lincoln did not have a Web site at the log cabin where his parents home-schooled him, and he turned out pretty interesting. Historical precedent shows that we can turn out amazing human beings without technology. Precedent also shows that we can turn out very uninteresting human beings with technology. It's not as simple as you think when you're in your 20s - that technology's going to change the world. In some ways it will, in some ways it won't. http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/4.02/jobs_pr.html http://archive.wired.com/wired/archive/4.02/jobs_pr.html
- CodeWriter23 12y agoLAUSD parent here. At our school, we have been successfully using iPads for instruction in certain grades. MacBooks and Airs in higher grades. The software used is pretty much the stock iPad selection, reinforced with some pedagogical offerings through web SaaS products. In Kindergarten, my daughter made a Ken Burns-style presentation using iMovie, researched building a parachute with a gondola to compete in the egg drop competition (her and her partner's egg broke), and has been drilled in numerous ways on spelling, counting, addition and subtraction. I am unsure how tech is applied in other grades, but I have seen the movie making and egg drop competition themes at the other grade levels, so I assume there is some iterative rigor year over year. By 4th grade, I expect my daughter to be participating in curriculum sourced from the Hour of Code program. In my view, Director Deasy's persecution is politically-motivated. The choice to go Apple was the result of successes in various Magnet and Lab Schools, conducted prior to the service agreement with Apple. Multiple vendors were evaluated during the Magnet / Lab development process. There was no opportunity in the process to put it out for three bids during the actual procurement process, because the other vendors were eliminated prior to procurement. Our technology program is funded by our PTO, which is a becoming a common trend in many public schools. It's much easier for our PTO to raise $80K/yr for tech (we raise more than that, to fund other programs) than it is for LAUSD to indemnify the purchase or lease of tech on a district-wide basis. We will likely continue to choose Apple products, with the primary motivation for that decision coming from the instructors, and secondarily, the build quality being able to stand up to student use at school and home.