4 ms·
One could profitably read this against "Lies We Tell Kids:" http://paulgraham.com/lies.html http://paulgraham.com/lies.html
by jseliger 12y ago
One could profitably read this against "Lies We Tell Kids:" http://paulgraham.com/lies.html http://paulgraham.com/lies.html
- yellowapple 12y agoWhile I agree with most of that wonderfully-written article... "But I was mystified about Carver. He seemed to have done stuff with peanuts... It's obvious now that he was on the list because he was black" He was on the list because he was an accomplished botanist who sought to relieve the effects of a cotton-planting monoculture (namely, on the deprivation of soil nutrients resulting from said monoculture) by persuading farmers to plant peanuts (or other legumes) instead of or alongside cotton, and did so by developing a very large number of novel uses for peanuts, thus increasing demand for them and encouraging farmers to follow his advice. I get what the author's trying to say - that a lot of folks only remember George Washington Carver because he was a black scientist - but it comes across as entirely ignorant of his actual accomplishments in botany and agricultural science.
- duncan_bayne 12y agoNo, what the author is trying to say that the only reason that Carver is listed alongside Einstein and Marie Curie is that he was black, and that it was considered politically necessary to include him for that reason. His accomplishments, while real and greater than mine and probably yours (no offence), aren't in the same league as those two.
- yellowapple 12y agoNo offense taken :) However, I'm still getting the impression that botany/biology/etc. are being viewed as somehow "lesser" than the sorts of physics Einstein and Curie did. Would you object to, say, Gregor Mendel being on that list? They're roughly comparable, after all (highly-respected botanists with Christian faiths and rather-groundbreaking (pun intended) discoveries in botany).
- duncan_bayne 12y agoAh, now that's a different discussion :) Yes, I was wondering about that. Mendel I think would belong on that list; I think membership in it depends upon fundamentally changing a field, rather than 'just' significantly improving it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]