4 ms·
What I hope actually kills all these products is a decentralized p2p open source system which lets humans find and rate other humans for whatever goods or servi
by zaroth 12y ago
What I hope actually kills all these products is a decentralized p2p open source system which lets humans find and rate other humans for whatever goods or services they may be selling.
The payment system is getting there (e.g. Bitcoin). The consensus algorithms are being worked out, the distributed trust systems are coming into place (e.g. Stellar). The scalable p2p discovery and mesh is pretty much already working (e.g. BitTorrent).
Why do we need to pay a 10% tax to companies to do this? I mean, as a civilization. To think the algorithms could never exist that would let me find a professional ______ near me which is, a) an actual person, b) someone who actually does this work for a living, and c) has real-life honest reviews from people who have actually paid that person to provide that service... it just doesn't seem like an intractable problem.
If you add up all the expert help, trusted reviews, on-demand this, cloud assistant that, we're talking what, at least 100 billion dollars of rent seeking?
Whether or not such a system has an optional secure anonymity layer (a la OpenBazaar) is just a matter of how you want to boot-strap the initial user base. Needless to say, "50% of the world's drug trade also happens to be conducted on the same code-base" may or may not be a great answer to the "how did you hack this system" question.
I think the "1099 Economy" is actually a great thing, I just think we could do without the gatekeepers.
- declan 12y ago<zaroth>: I'm not sure why you were downvoted, so have an upvote. Not saying I entirely agree with you -- calling it a "tax" is incendiary and no more accurate than saying "why do we need to pay a 10% tax to grocery stores or Amazon?" -- but your broader point is an interesting one. I'm pessimistic about this application of p2p discovery in the short term, but in the longer term (>7 years) you may well be right. The short/medium-term problem, and this goes back to 1990s discussions among cypherpunks about anonymous reputation systems, is that those "honest reviews" are attractive targets for gaming.
- zaroth 12y agoI don't need the karma, I'd much rather have the discussion! :-) Rent-seeking is probably a better description than tax, in that while it certainly costs a lot to build and maintain these systems, and they do provide some measure of value, the goal here is to build scale, build monopoly, and then extract profit. The alternative is building the technology in a open / decentralized fashion which doesn't grant any level of centralized control. Open source software provides such incredible economy of scale that I do think such a system could one day reasonably compete with the best a multi-billion-dollar corporation could offer.
- qq66 12y agoIf you want to see the non-rent-seeking version of a local marketplace, look at Craigslist. Their service is completely free to most participants. Craigslist has a lot of things going for it, but the "rent seekers" are able to create other advantages that Craigslist can't. They can staff people to bring businesses onboard, get everyone's metadata formatted in the right way, take business photos, handle payment disputes, etc., that they wouldn't have the resources to do without charging a fee on the transaction. For some, Craigslist is better, for others, the Thumbtack experience is better.
- zaroth 12y agoCraigslist is an interesting example. It shows how absolutely little you need to provide real value to a lot of people, but it certainly seems like they aren't even trying to make it better. I think if it was open source you would actually see a lot more interesting and useful features continuously being added. I mean, how long did it take for them to add a map to their rental listings? The software will eventually exist to properly format the meta-data automatically for the vast majority of cases. Also things like providing pluggable viewports / templates so it doesn't have to be one-size fits all. There's nothing to prevent add-on services being used in a decentralized market. For example, payment escrow is absolutely essential for many purchases, and payment escrow services themselves would be discovered and ranked through the same code base. But if you don't need it, you shouldn't have to pay for it. Discovery, search, storage, connectivity, etc. is all done using the local compute and storage resources and leveraging network neutrality. This is an absolutely huge problem space, I've been thinking about it for years, and am hoping to start working on it at least part time later this year. For example, my dad had to move a car last month. He didn't know at the time, but the guy he hired was actually a broker who took 30% of the cost as a finder fee. "Car Transport" is just a simple category in a vast field of services, but you can imagine the interface to collect leads is trivial, and the interface to select vendors, agree on a contract, and commit to the service would be mostly common platform code. Obviously the biggest problem is getting people to use it. The advantage of an open source and distributed p2p approach is the burn rate is basically zero. I can afford to work on it pretty much for the rest of my life at this point, and it would be reward enough to see people using it and benefiting it. Well, we'll see how it goes. :-)
- guelo 12y agoAgree these guys are parasites. For example, Thumbtack charges landscapers $15 per lead. It could easily take 5-10 leads to get a paying job. And these are not high earning professions.
- codecamper 12y ago10% would be OK. It covers their card processing, advertisement fees, paying some software developers reasonable rates to improve the service. But 10% is not real. These sites charge 15-30% on top of card processing fees. That's too much.