4 ms·
There's a difference between requiring to identify oneself and requiring to get an explicit clearance to travel. Last time I checked, air travel in the US requ
by nine_k 12y ago
There's a difference between requiring to identify oneself and requiring to get an explicit clearance to travel.
Last time I checked, air travel in the US requires a valid ID, but you're automatically allowed to travel, unless you're on some no-fly list or are a wanted criminal. (Last time I took Amtrak it did not require any authentication; I bought a ticket from a vending machine.)
The US system is built with certain distrust to the government, and with a number of checks and balances to prevent it from becoming tyrannical. Hence the idea of the government having no business to know my whereabouts unless there's a good reason to suspect me of some wrongdoing.
I personally don't see an excessively great trouble in anyone having my location data. Still, there are two good reasons for the government to collect as little such data as possible. First, the data may fall to wrong hands: fancy your house robbed when you're traveling? Second, it costs a lot of money to collect the data; if the data are collected "just in case", that money is wasted.
- saint_fiasco 12y agoIn my country it's exactly the same way. You need an ID, but not an authorization. The location data is also treated the same way, for the second reason you stated. The way people feel about needing valid ID is very different, though.