8 ms·
The Right Dose of Exercise for a Longer Life
- borgia 12y agoI'm glad we're getting a better understanding of how much these variables contribute toward longevity and well-being. Now we just have to come up with a plan to deal with the challenges of people living far longer. I don't know if I'm alone in noticing this, but there appears to be a larger divide in society along these lines opening up. More people seem to be exercising than ever - almost every guy I know has a gym membership, is taking part in a sport, or goes hiking, or whatever - where previously the same people may have been thin/healthy but sedentary. On the other side of things, it appears that more people seem to be simply getting more fat and more sedentary. Where once there was thin/average and sedentary | mildly overweight and sedentary, it seems to be dividing to thin/average and pretty active | very fat and very sedentary. That is all from personal observations, but it will be interesting to see the physical composition of society in 5-10 years time. What was once overweight has simply become normal, what was "fat" has now become huge and what was once a healthy weight has become the new thin.
- nileshtrivedi 12y ago> More people seem to be exercising than ever - almost every guy I know has a gym membership, is taking part in a sport, or goes hiking, or whatever - where previously the same people may have been thin/healthy but sedentary. That's because more of our interactions are moving online than offline so you see people at their best and not how they typically are. ;-)
- ChrisNorstrom 12y agoI think a lack of exersize throughout the day is why guys today are going bald earlier than in previous generations. I think high intensity exercises for 3 min every 1-2 hours throughout the day is reversing my hair loss. I'll be making a blog post on it soon with evidence of my progress. Since August of 2014 I had been losing my hair. More and more of it was showing up in the sink drain. Earlier this year I got worried because it increased. I wasn't sure if it was a temporary thing due to stress or illness so I started saving up the little clumps of hair between paper towels and date stamping them. It just kept getting worse and worse. I got a blood test to check hormone levels and find out if everything's ok. I'm waiting on the results. Last month I got tired of it all, and decided to experiment as a last ditch effort to prevent baldness in my late 20s. I started short but high intensity exersizes every 1 hour, for about 2-3 minutes. After only 1 week new hair has started sprouting up on my scalp. And the amount I've seen in the sink drain has gone down drastically. This is very odd because there's a huge delay in when hair grows and falls (often months) not 1 week. So I'm convinced it's the exersize that's increased circulation, jump started cell growth, and maintained healthy hormone levels. I need to test this out in the long term and try to get other guys to participate. I doubt it's a coincidence because 1 week I skipped my exercises and my hair growth decreased a bit and hair loss increased a tiny bit. tl;dr The right dose of exersize for a healthy head of hair. Possibly.
- BSousa 12y agoI started losing mine at 17 and I worked out/moved a lot at the time (played 2 sports + fun activities) so I doubt there is a connection there.
- corin_ 12y agoYour single point of data (anecdote) isn't really any more useful than his. I know at least one very old person who has smoked all their life, for example.
- ghthor 12y agoMale pattern baldness is directly linked to testosterone. I believe is also linked to stress. If you're TOO active and causing high levels of cortisol in your system then you'll probably go bald early.
- tempestn 12y agoNow we need someone to combine these two to give us a picture the whole parameter space. Wouldn't a 3d graph by awesome here? Premature death rate on the Z axis, minutes of weekly exercise and percentage that is beyond a given intensity threshold on the X and Y? You could then compare that to the same thing, except using average intensity as the metric instead of amount of time spent over a threshold. 450 minutes per week was optimal when it was mostly light exercise, and intense exercise is more beneficial, with diminishing returns after 30 minutes per week. But if you do a higher percentage of intense exercise, does the optimal time per week decrease? (Or maybe even increase as you get beyond a certain fitness threshold! Although I somewhat doubt that.)
- niels_olson 12y agoReading the abstracts, the measurement the US study uses for "dosing" is metabolic-equivalent hours per week. The Australian study uses "vigorous". If you want to grade your activities of choice to METs, there are various sources to do estimate them: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metabolic_equivalent http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metabolic_equivalent
- nidieunimaitre 12y agoI always wonder to what degree this kind of study might invert causality: that is, people who are subclinically "ill" may be less likely to exercise in the first place because it is harder or less pleasant for them. Someone with, for example, undiagnosed but significant cardiovascular disease (unfortunately very common: in many cases the first sign anyone recognizes as concerning is a heart attack) is likely to have some degree of decreased exercise tolerance and discomfort at longer durations and intensities -- and thus will be less likely to meet the recommendations.
- corin_ 12y agoOr indeed other causes which could create an accidental correlation. The more you eat the fatter you're likely to be, the fatter you are the harder exercise is, the less of it you're likely to do. The more you smoke, the more out of breath you'll get when exercising, the less of it you're likely to do. These are two examples I personally feel contribute to my not getting as much exercise as I did 10 years ago. If I die early is it that I haven't exercised enough, or that I had an unhealthy diet and smoked a lot of cigarettes? (I'm not saying lack of exercise doesn't contribute, just that picking it out on its own doesn't necessarily show the full story.) Additionally, given how well-known the basic concept of "exercise is healthy" is, I would imagine there would likely be some correlation between people who exercise specifically for that purpose (rather than because they enjoy it) and who also take other steps to stay healthy (whether that's having a good diet, or taking vitamins, or.. whatever).
- lkesteloot 12y agoA well-run study should control for weight and smoking. But the undiagnosed cardiovascular disease can't be controlled for. Exercise is much harder for me than for others, for example, and I don't know why.
- nickff 12y agoYou can only control for weight and smoking if you have good data, which is to say that at least a significant portion of the weight and smoking behaviours are not causally linked to the exercise behaviour. If the data is not sufficiently diverse, no amount of statistical power will overcome the garbage-in garbage-out nature of regression.
- 31reasons 12y agoStudies like these always make me think how little we know about human body. I wonder when are we going to stop doing these kind of studies and learn from human body as purely engineering system. By simulating it at a molecular level and understanding it that way. Where are the chips that mimic cells and help create complete simulation of a trillion+ cell system? We need Elon Musk of human body :)
- melling 12y agoHow about simply being able to better monitor/measure changes in the body?
- glibgil 12y agoHow about that.
- 31reasons 12y agoChanges of what? There are millions of parameters that affect each other in a nonlinear fashion due to genetics, environment, diet etc. Getting such data from the living system would be prohibitively invasive, blood tests have their limitations and doesn't provide real-time data.
- melling 12y agoI don't know what can be or should be measured. The idea is to develop better techniques for monitoring the body. A future tricorder X-Prize, for instance: http://tricorder.xprize.org http://tricorder.xprize.org You're telling me what we can do today. I'm asking what we can develop to solve the problem.
- niels_olson 12y ago> simulating it at a molecular level It's a work in progress http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2014/ph240/milic1/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2014/ph240/milic1/ Eukaryotic cells are much more complicated though. It has been estimated we have done 1% of the biological experiments necessary to figure out how a human actually works. Anybody want to fund my prostate cancer biomarker discovery project?
- benihana 12y agoFor me it always comes back to: what are people's long, long term goals. Overall? Is it a longer life? Do you want to live an extra five years? I personally don't think that's a good goal. I'd much rather be in good shape, mobile, healthy and relatively pain free for my 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s and as far into my 70s as I can manage than to increase my lifespan from 85-90. It's way less about eking out a few more years of keeping death at bay and way more about feeling good while I'm a mobile, mentally healthy adult.
- glibgil 12y agoYes, I want an extra five years. I'm working on a difficult project that I might not finish before I die. Five more years would really help me.
- RankingMember 12y ago"Duke Nukem Forever: Part Deux" developer spotted.
- nostromo 12y agoYoung people say this a lot, but I don't hear people in their 80s say it. When my grandpa was dying in his mid-80s, it really hit home for me how scary it is. Even if you've had a fulfilling, long life, dying still sucks. For young people, another year of life for an 80 year old doesn't seem like much, but to an 80 year old it means the world.
- dspillett 12y ago> Young people say this a lot, but I don't hear people in their 80s say it. When you are young those five years don't look that attractive: you are older, slower, half your friends and family are gone, you might not have any money to support the life you want depending how the economy goes, and so forth - so having a bit more fun now seems like a good compromise. Once you get older then you realise that any time is worth having as there are still more things you want to do and more time you want to spend with people than you might have time for left. Of course having too much "fun" now means that your old decrepit years come sooner because your body will fall apart faster, so that really isn't the good compromise is might seem to some - you start paying in good years as well as the later ones you might be dreading at this point in your life. To be far far more flippant about it, my reasoning up to a few years ago was: "My main worry is being able to afford to live a content life beyond a certain point so my current pension plan is to not live long enough to need a good pension. Hence my drinking habit: I'm investing heavily in cirrhosis futures!" Having started to see some of my older friends in bad conditions, various people in my life having less serious but still significant health scares, I changed my mind about that quite a bit. Had I not decided to shape up back then, an old friend my own age (mid 30s) shuffle off to the crematorium rather prematurely recently might have made me do it. I might not care about those last few years in my 80s now, but I certainly care about hanging around for a good few years yet. I've got places to see and people to do!
- suprgeek 12y agoA very important detail - these are survey studies: "Of course, these studies relied on people’s shaky recall of exercise habits and were not randomized experiments, so can’t prove that any exercise dose caused changes in mortality risk, only that exercise and death risks were associated." NOT Randomized controlled trials. So take these with a pinch of salt and then go outside & run for 30 mins every day.
- bhaumik 12y ago>The sweet spot for exercise benefits, however, came among those who tripled the recommended level of exercise, working out moderately, mostly by walking, for 450 minutes per week, or a little more than an hour per day. Those people were 39 percent less likely to die prematurely than people who never exercised.
- griffinmahon 12y agoThis is like that one TED talk on longevity that found green zones where people lived much longer. One factor found in these people's lives was an ambulatory day, just generally walking a lot -- but, surprisingly, none of these groups went out of their way to exercise.
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoI wonder if we integrated regular walking into our city planning that we could reduce cardiovascular disease and obesity.
- pvnick 12y agoThat seems difficult for a sedentary adult living in suburban America who drives their car to work and sits at a desk all day, but for cultures that do more walking - ie in cities that are more laid out for walking and public transportation - an hour of walking per day is almost an afterthought. In Dubrovnik, Croatia, for instance, a small city largely built on the side of a mountain (https://moremojitosplease.wordpress.com/2012/06/25/dubrovnik-a-city-of-stairs-stone-walls-and-gelato/ https://moremojitosplease.wordpress.com/2012/06/25/dubrovnik...), I've never done so much cardiovascular exercise inadvertently just by living there for a week. I also noticed that very few people, if any, were overweight. In fact most cities I've been to in Europe seem to be quite good for walking. The ramifications of this study should certainly be factored in to city planning.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- flambard 12y agoWhen this subject comes up, I always think of this article: http://startingstrength.com/articles/barbell_medicine_sullivan.pdf http://startingstrength.com/articles/barbell_medicine_sulliv...