2 ms·
Android is very simple: Google needs to be banned from mandating OEMs install the whole Google Apps package. Leave it on OEMs to decide what browser, search, et
by ocdtrekkie 12y ago
Android is very simple: Google needs to be banned from mandating OEMs install the whole Google Apps package. Leave it on OEMs to decide what browser, search, etc. apps to package on their devices. The market, and consumers, will decide what works.
The Open Handset Alliance is a blatant example of an illegal trust. A large group of supposed competitors agreeing not to compete.
- Oletros 12y agoDo you really believe the things you write? How the heck is OHA an illegal trust?
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoThe OHA is basically an agreement between almost every major manufacturer in the industry to not compete on software, which is the majority of the industry's featureset. Additionally, while OEMs actively advertise against iPhone, none of them have ever made ads against each other. The OHA is, at it's core, an agreement of a whole industry to not compete with Google or each other.
- Oletros 12y agoNo it is impossible that you believe that nonsense
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoI recognize your name. I've surely encountered your brand of fanboyism on HN before.
- Oletros 12y agoPlease, don't project your personality on others
- prapam2 12y agoYour trolling has ruined this thread of a lively debate.
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoActually, what's funny is I've gotten almost an identical number of upvotes as downvotes on this issue. Really, you're just a fanboy, who believes everything that doesn't suit your worldview is a troll. :) It's also interesting, because it speaks to HN's karma system as less of a measure of comment quality, and more of a measure of whether or not your opinion is popular. (Or in my case, just controversial.)
- dang 12y agoPersonal attacks are out of line on HN. You've been breaking the site guidelines repeatedly. Please read and follow them. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoRight. Why don't we see Android forks? Because if you dare ever make one, you are kicked out of the OHA. And if you're kicked out of the OHA, you can't make phones with normal Android and its Play Store. This is why it was so hard for Amazon to find a manufacturer for the Kindle Fire. Nobody wanted to be kicked out of the OHA. Luckily, they did find someone who wasn't already making Android phones.
- Oletros 12y agoFoxconn is member of the OHA
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoWhich would be relevant if Foxconn made the Kindle Fire. :) https://www.bing.com/search?q=Kindle+Fire+manufacturer&pc=MOZI&form=MOZSBR https://www.bing.com/search?q=Kindle+Fire+manufacturer&pc=MO...
- Oletros 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_Phone http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fire_Phone Perhaps you have to give better term to Bing!
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoClearly, you also did not read the comment you were responding to, because it was not about the Fire Phone. :) That being said, it is interesting that Foxconn built the Fire Phone.
- TheDong 12y agonot Foxconn, it was a subsidary of Foxconn who built the phone for a subsidary of Amazon, thereby working around the OHA restrictions :) They didn't really try to hide it, but they did the motions of some shell companies at least so they were maybe technically in the clear if you squinted enough.
- soxpopuli 12y agoAndroid gets raked over the coals for years for bad customer experience. Google attempts to reign in fragmentation and divergent and inconsistent UI experience, and move more of firmware to Play store so it can issue security updates to customers without carriers and OEMs blocking. Google raked over the coals for anti-competition. Meanwhile, Apple ships iTunes and App Store, which can only be used with their own cloud stores. They ship iMessage which only works with their Cloud. Apple Maps. A fitness app. A wallet. A payment system. etc All in a proprietary, single vendor system, closed source. If every Android phone's out of box experience was a random collection of OEM apps that had no common standard, the consumer experience would be terrible. Switch from a Samsung to an LG device and you might be hit by the fact that the device has none of the apps you were using on your previous phone, you have to delete all of the current apps, and reinstall all of your previous ones, enter all the settings again, all of the login credentials, etc. The switching cost would be huge and it would cause OEM lock in. The setup process is a factor in consumer choice. If you are faced with an onerous gauntlet of selection dialogs for 10+ apps when you start (it's not just app store, browser, maps, but email, music, video, camera, photos, etc), consumers are going to be very annoyed. I don't want to spend 30 minutes to an hour unboxing my phone and "installing", that's what used to happen on PCs. And what happens when things go wrong. If the user installs a third party app store, and gets malware, do you think they're going to be blamed, or Google's Android brand will be blamed? Most consumers aren't aware enough to narrow down who to blame. So in the end, you'd be asking Google to assume all the brand risk, all of the complaints over fragmentation and failure to patch older phones, and making consumer experience worse. Apple has none of these problems. Say what you will about their locked down platform, the one thing you don't have to worry about is inconsistent getting starting experience or malware from the App Store. The 'choice' being presented here is the kind of choice hackers and engineers love, but it's not the kind of choice one's parents and relatives may love. It's just hobbling attempts to improve the Android experience.
- ocdtrekkie 12y ago"User experience" should never be chosen at the expense of "user freedom".
- 12y ago