3 ms·
Reasons I downvote comments fall into two categories: 1. Poor etiquette 2. Poor writing Examples of poor etiquette: - Obvious self promotion that adds nothi
by chatmasta 12y ago
Reasons I downvote comments fall into two categories:
1. Poor etiquette
2. Poor writing
Examples of poor etiquette:
- Obvious self promotion that adds nothing to discussion
- Any mention of "downvote" in the comment body
- "Flamebait" and clearly mean-spirited remarks
Examples of poor writing:
- Completely off-topic, especially if at top of thread
- Factually incorrect
- Extraordinary claim without extraoridinary evidence
- Ambiguous language or poor wording that leads to confusion
- Aggressive conclusions based on faulty logic
I try to avoid downvoting for emotional reasons. Just because I disagree with a comment does not mean it's wrong. I have noticed a trend, especially around NSA/government/surveillance/conspiracy type comments, where people will downvote logical arguments without refuting them. This is not good for discussion. If you disagree with a comment, try to understand its author before reflexively downvoting. An equally logical reply contributes far more to discussion than a downvote.