6 ms·
The archipelago was first settled in the 19th century, only about 1500 people were displaced, yes the British government mistreated these people by not properly
by dogma1138 12y ago
The archipelago was first settled in the 19th century, only about 1500 people were displaced, yes the British government mistreated these people by not properly compensating them because the US and NATO needed a military base in the region.
However there are urban restructuring projects every day in western countries that displace more people without proper compensation than this incident.
And while i understand that some people might feel they've been stripped of their homeland, but considering that the Islands were populated for the 1st time in modern history less than 200 years ago and remained populated for a period of only about a 100 years it's not exactly the strongest backing for a claim to a nation.
- creshal 12y ago> However there are urban restructuring projects every day in western countries that displace more people without proper compensation Such as? Most western legal systems require compensation in such cases… at least in theory.
- talmand 12y agoI think the key is in who gets to define what is "proper" compensation.
- teknologist 12y agoThere's no number high enough- at the end of the day people will just cry out "amagad but our homes!" and claim that that's priceless and forever want money and sympathy from everyone. A line must be drawn somewhere.
- talmand 12y agoAs long as the line is more on the side of the majority feeling it fair as opposed to a certain minority feeling it advantageous, then I'm fine with that.
- tajen 12y agoIf the price were enough, they would sell it. While I understand that this logic is not helpful when we try to develop the nation's infrastructure, we must not forget that we're imposing the desires of a more important mass of people at the depends of a tiny number of victims.
- vollmond 12y agoPlus there's the fact that in at least some US cases, the displacement is to allow space for a large business which will provide more tax revenue than the displaced could.
- gkya 12y agoI do not believe that anything can compensate for loss of one's home. I do not know what's going on in the Occident but here in Istanbul on every flipping square metre they build a glass tower where they stuff people, and everyday neighbourhoods are killed and the city is resembling more and more those stock videos of Chinese urban areas. This cannot be compensated anyhow, regardless of where-ever it happens. /rant
- sokoloff 12y agoWould $1 billion in cash per household compensate? I believe for most people, the answer is "Yes, of course!" Is $1 enough? Of course not. To me, that means the "right price" is somewhere in that bounded range and makes eminent domain conflicts amenable to financial analysis.
- Symbiote 12y agoA possible example is the people living in ~500 houses in Camden (London). The houses are to be demolished to make way for a new railway, and they're not happy with the level of compensation offered.
- dogma1138 12y agoIf you go for London then you can look at all the council houses restructuring projects that pretty much kick all the non-(extremely)wealthy residents out of London by offering them well below real market value for their properties and then developing the council estates into luxury apartment projects.
- 7952 12y agoThis even happens with private properties that are bought under compulsory purchase for "regeneration". Owners are offered the value of the property as it stands, not the value of the land (which is much higher considering the development oppurtunities).
- runarberg 12y agoNo! you can't compare these two scenarios. When urban population is resettled, first, it's also really unfair and shouldn't happen. Second, they're not nearly as dependent on the land as the Chaigos islanders. Third the resettlement is most often to a similar environment. Also, the argument about the late first population is silly. You wouldn't do this to any person. These are people, who's lifes have been ruined, and you can't do that to anybody. No matter if they are indigenous, 2nd generation immigrants, descendants of slave trade, or what ever. You don't do this to any people.
- wpietri 12y agoI'm very uncomfortable with this line of argument: > However there are urban restructuring projects every day in western countries that displace more people without proper compensation than this incident. I suspect it's factually untrue, but I'm more concerned with the moral implication that if we can find a wrong Y that is worse than wrong X, we shouldn't care about X. There is a legitimate version of the argument, one where we triage resource usage. But our ability to recognize and acknowledge wrongs is not a limited resource. Indeed, this style of argument expends far more energy in denying the recognition of wrongs that it would take to say, "Why yes, that is wrong."
- pdpi 12y ago> but I'm more concerned with the moral implication that if we can find a wrong Y that is worse than wrong X, we shouldn't care about X. Definitely not "shouldn't care". But you should ask yourself "if there's a ton of materially similar things I'm ok with, why should I feel outraged about this one in particular?" Sometimes the answer is that you shouldn't feel outraged at all, other times the answer will be that you should be outraged at all similar things. It's only rarely that the outrage should be focused on the one particular incident.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoUtilitarian arguments lead you strange places. You can end up eating children or burning hobos for fuel. Be very careful.
- MichaelGG 12y agoAnd is there any reason to think that the British Government would be giving these people the proceeds of the British Indian Oceans TLD? If they had their land and own government called Chagos, it seems unlikely they'd have .io.
- ankitml 12y agoJustifying one injustice with another?
- xtrumanx 12y agoThat was pretty weak arguments against the case of the Chagossians people. I had to try really hard not to downvote because I disagree with your position. It doesn't matter if western countries mistreat their people sometimes, that doesn't justify mistreating the Chagossians or anyone else for that matter. Even if you think 200 years isn't a strong claim to a nation, that doesn't change the fact those people lived there and were forceably removed from the islands. I'm also curious, what is your cut-off point for a "strong" claim to a nation? 250 years? 500 years? 1 AD?
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoYou're a nation if you have a military. These folks clearly failed that test.
- rmc 12y agoHow old is the USA again? When was (say) Utah settled by Americans? Can we have that?
- oldmanjay 12y agolike all things in realpolitik, you can certainly try!
- chagosuk 12y agoFor us the argument is fairly simple. Resettlement of the Islands by Chagossians is possible, even maintaining the military base, and there is still will amongst the Chagossian people to do so. Certainly internal forced replacement still happens and often has terrible consequences for people but internationally the Chagos situation is pretty unique, and what is especially unique is that something can be done about it. (Link to a now slightly outdated page on our website on Return 2015 campaign) http://www.chagossupport.org.uk/return-in-2015 http://www.chagossupport.org.uk/return-in-2015