3 ms·
Ask on many sites about examples of good design (including here), and you get pointed to dribble. I do agree with you however. I (usually try to) "design" my s
by collyw 12y ago
Ask on many sites about examples of good design (including here), and you get pointed to dribble.
I do agree with you however. I (usually try to) "design" my software before I start writing it (unlike the "agile / schemaless/ latest-fad" developers). It works well for me. Usually saves a lot of work in the medium to long term.
The problem is that design is an ambiguous word that can cover every aspect of building an application. We need to be able to differentiate between "pretty looking design" and a "well architected, thought through database / software design", and all of the "design" elements in between.
- joeyspn 12y agoWhoever points you to dribbble as a source of good design is not a designer, or is a designer with a narrow scope. A designer will point you to things like Red Dot [0], or many of the schools of Design Thinking that have shaped our modern world. I also design software. I sketch the UI and architect the software myself before passing the ideas and engaging software engineers. Maybe I'm lucky cos I had my hours of both Engineering and Design at college. And IMHO this is how designers in the software industry should be: driving the product from conception to build, like in the Industrial Design world. In other words: Industrial Designer = Arts + Engineering (Physics, Math, Materials, CAD/CAE) Software Designer = Arts + Engineering (Math, Programming, Design Tooling/IDE's) This approach to design is holistic. That's the big difference I see, Industrial Designers have strong engineering background and know "how it works" [1] internally, they pick the materials and do the math, and even have estimations of the production costs beforehand. Apple is driven by this kind of Designers. Designers in the software industry usually are not trained to understand how the software works internally, let alone making costs estimations. [0] http://en.red-dot.org/ http://en.red-dot.org/ [1] http://is.gd/3RPHhE http://is.gd/3RPHhE