4 ms·
"Blacks in Oakland frequently question why I would live in SF with people who don’t look like me" This is the most racist thing I read whole day.
by gambiting 12y ago
"Blacks in Oakland frequently question why I would live in SF with people who don’t look like me"
This is the most racist thing I read whole day.
- wantab 12y agoI came to say the same thing. This is another, "Poor black me" article where he's offended by everything he construes to be against him. As if Atlanta is better.
- brtt 12y agoYou're a bit off-base there.
- wantab 12y agoNo. Not at all. Substitute all the words "black" with "white" and see all the "You're a racist!" comments come out if I had written it.
- hluska 12y agoBrtt was too charitable. You are completely off base here, but hey, way to prove the writer's point!
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThere are a lot of ways to explain that power imbalances are critical context to racist statements. Yes, when black people say racist things in America, it's racist, but when white people do it, it's racism. But the very best explanation is long-form stand-up comedy. If you don't understand, you really should watch this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dw_mRaIHb-M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dw_mRaIHb-M
- konceptz 12y agoI really wouldn't classify this as racist. It sounds to me more like an honest share about his community or extended community's view on where he is living.
- konceptz 12y agoI really wouldn't classify this as racist. It sounds to me more like an honest share about his community or extended community's view on where he is living.
- rjtavares 12y agoDo you really think that is more racist than “You know this is a tech event, right?”? If your answer is yes, I would advise a bit of self-reflection.
- mikekchar 12y agoI am a white guy living in the rural Japan. I can tell you lots of stories of other expat white people accusing me of being a "Japan-o-phile" (apparently a bad thing) because I adopted a Japanese way of life. People have often warned me that "they [the Japanese people] will never accept you" and "you know you will never be Japanese". I get far more racism from these expats who feel betrayed that I have happily integrated into Japanese society than I ever have from Japanese people. Racism exists everywhere. Living in Japan has been the first place where I've lived as a visible minority and it has been an eye opener. Being obviously different is hard in many ways. There are people who stare at you, or people who wonder if/how you are different from them. There are people who are afraid of you for no reason other than you are different. Very occasionally there are people who are abusive and rude, but most of the time it is mostly a mixture of ignorance and curiosity (and maybe a little bit of fear of the unknown thrown in). It can be quite a problem for some people. Many people take offence at practically anything and can't let anything slide. They feel it is morally wrong not to take a stand about being treated differently. They feel you are morally wrong if you happily agree to be treated differently. For me, probably like a lot of people who read HN, I have always been different. I have never fit in anywhere. Even though I was visibly the same as everyone, my way of thinking, my religious beliefs, my values have always been different from the norm. I suffered greatly in countries where everyone assumed that I was the same as them. As a visible minority, I am free to be different. It makes me happy even if sometimes it causes problems. "Expats in Japan frequently question why I would live in rural Japan with people who don't look [and by extension, think] like me", would be a true statement for me. In my opinion this is likely true of any visible minority population anywhere. It definitely hurts me and I suspect it hurts the author as well, which is probably why he wrote about it in that way.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoThanks for one of the best expositions on fundamental xenophobia I've read in a while.