4 ms·
Once again, instead of responsibly approaching the housing problem by passing measures to incentivize building more supply, the SF government has taken the easy
by twblalock 12y ago
Once again, instead of responsibly approaching the housing problem by passing measures to incentivize building more supply, the SF government has taken the easy way out by placing more restrictions on what can be done with existing units. This is a convenient regulation for politicians because it appeases certain people and attacks an easy scapegoat, but it will have a minimal effect on the quality and quantity of housing available, and on the price of rent.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoWhere do you propose "more supply" be built? Pretty much every inch of SF is already occupied by something[0]. I suppose we could start landfilling part of the bay a la Boston. [0] https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7738299,-122.4049461,7687m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0x80859a6d00690021:0x4a501367f076adff https://www.google.com/maps/place/San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7738...
- Hobotron1 12y agoThere's a third, woefully underutilized dimension I can think of.
- swang 12y agoYep. A lot of NIMBYism preventing that.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoWhich would typically require demolition of existing structures. Most property owners don't have the capital to destroy their current structures just to replace them with taller buildings. It would also require displacing current residents, who won't have anywhere else to live while the new building is constructed.
- Hobotron1 12y ago> Most property owners don't have the capital to destroy their current structures just to replace them with taller buildings. There are those that do who would gladly fork over a good chunk of change for their lots. > It would also require displacing current residents, who won't have anywhere else to live while the new building is constructed. Yeah, lets inconvenience 99% of people just so those few won't be.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoWho exactly is being inconvenienced? Those who do not currently live in the city?
- Hobotron1 12y agoCurrent tenants- paying insane prices for rent And yes, those that would like to live in the city but can't because of the ridiculous rent or simply lack of rent-able places.
- rdl 12y agoAnd the people who would like their pensions to be fully funded due to investment gains from new tech companies in SF, currently hindered by rent. And people who want to use exciting new products built by SF companies which are limited or don't happen due to lack of office space. It's a drag on not only the city but the state, nation, and world.
- ndnichols 12y agoAre you being sarcastic? Or do you genuinely think the lack of office space in SF is a drag on the world?
- tdaltonc 12y agoNot office space so much as housing. "But for the tight limits on construction in California’s Bay Area, they reckon, employment there would be about five times larger than it is. In work that has yet to be published they tot up similar distortions across the whole economy from 1964 on and find that American GDP in 2009 was as much as 13.5% lower than it otherwise could have been. At current levels of output that is a cost of more than $2 trillion a year, or nearly $10,000 per person." http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21647622-land-centre-pre-industrial-economy-has-returned-constraint-growth?zid=311&ah=308cac674cccf554ce65cf926868bbc2 http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21647622-land-centre-...
- encoderer 12y agoManhattan population density is 4x San Francisco. I don't want to see the city turn into Manhattan but we have a lot of negotiating room.
- _delirium 12y agoEven Paris, a city that has banned high-rises, has a population density about 2.5x that of San Francisco. I realize SF doesn't want Miami-style condo towers everywhere, but there's a lot of room to densify just by putting in more mid-rise buildings in the 5-6 story range, rather than having so much of the city be low-rise.
- slykat 12y agoIf you ask any architect or urban planner, you'd realize that San Francisco has plenty of room for further development. This isn't Manhattan island.
- yunesj 12y agoI would propose more supply be built on the land owned by developers who want to build more supply. For reference, the street view below is the heart of the Mission. Unfortunately, most people here would rather preserve the slums than build enough housing to support a diverse bunch of people. https://www.google.com/maps/@37.765862,-122.419784,3a,75y,267.78h,78.75t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1swKhRkx_occjOw3PD-Fw9aQ!2e0 https://www.google.com/maps/@37.765862,-122.419784,3a,75y,26...
- jsprogrammer 12y agoAnd what is preventing those developers from building more supply? I've seen plenty of construction going on in the city.
- mahyarm 12y agoPermits, height laws, comment periods where some nimby will block the development. Otherwise they would of done it already because there is a lot of relative cash to be made to the cost of building. On a relative per capita basis, SF is building a lot less than lets say houston or similar. And the reason why it's a lot slower is because of all of the above.
- pbreit 12y agoUh, even if anyone aspired to be Houston, it's not surrounded on 3 sides by water. The developers are not entirely innocent since they always, without exception, ask for more than they are allowed, hence the endless reviews.
- oxryly1 12y agoIt's a chicken and egg situation. Developers propose larger than they want because inevitably the negotiations with city and neighbors reduce their plans.
- kqr2 12y agoThis is a good editorial on trying to develop housing in the Mission: How San Francisco creates its own housing crisis http://www.sfgate.com/opinion/openforum/article/How-San-Francisco-creates-its-own-housing-crisis-5139869.php http://www.sfgate.com/opinion/openforum/article/How-San-Fran... It took 6 long years with lots of fighting to try and develop a relatively modest 12 unit condo complex that met all zoning requirements.
- pbreit 12y agoSeems like SOMA could be much taller (and infinitely prettier) without creating congestion problems in the rest of the City.
- dpifke 12y agoThe intent of the current batch of legislation is to fix the last attempt, which REMOVED "restrictions on what can be done with existing units." Prior to that, any short-term rental in San Francisco was illegal. By fixing the law so it's at least somewhat enforceable from a tax-collection standpoint, at least we're potentially going to see the hotel tax revenue, which helps fund subsidized low-income housing. And until the voters want more housing (which they don't, since they have a financial incentive in keeping supply low so their property values increase), don't expect the supes to jump on the supply & demand bandwagon any time soon. People who want to move to San Francisco but can't afford it don't get to vote in San Francisco elections, so the electorate is--not surprisingly--anti-growth.
- pbreit 12y agoFinally, someone acknowledging the obvious: property owners are thrilled with the current situation.
- DavidAdams 12y agoIt's not that hard. A huge financial incentive exists to convert a lot of the city's low density housing stock to higher density housing. SF is full of poorly built, ugly, non "historic" residential buildings that developers would gladly convert to taller, safer, prettier buildings that housed more people if they were allowed to. The city government just needs to have the will to loosen regulations and limit neighbors' effective veto on neighborhood improvements. The negative impacts of these developments could be remedied by impact fees, to go to expanding transit and other services that would be needed to accommodate more people in the neighborhoods. Again, the cost of housing is so high that developers would gladly pay astronomical impact fees if they were allowed to build. Historic buildings can be excluded from these rules, and developers can be required to adhere to certain architectural guidelines. Hell, they could mandate that all new development be in the "painted lady" victorian style, though I personally think that would be stupid.