3 ms·
I'm a big fan of arrestor lines around the sides. Basically as the stage lands, stand up four outrigger arms with a cable going through them from the corners of
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
I'm a big fan of arrestor lines around the sides. Basically as the stage lands, stand up four outrigger arms with a cable going through them from the corners of the barge. If it falls over then catch it and lower it gently. But easy to armchair, hard to do! That they have arrived exactly where the barge is (or would have been) 3 times now is pretty awesome in itself.
- andygates 12y agoVery easy to armchair -- but it's a fifteen story beer can, so you need a huge arrestor system, and it's pretty fragile except up its axis. The ultimate goal is to land on a flat pad, so adding stuff now moves away from that goal.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI love the beer can analogy. Agreed it is a really interesting problem. Which I don't doubt SpaceX will solve. I was not impressed with the ULA "lets just catch the engines with a helicopter" idea. Can't wait to see the recovered barge video.
- mikeash 12y agoThe question is always whether you remove more risk than you add. That's a big part of why it's easy to armchair but hard to do. In this case, for example, I'd bet that the odds of the rocket getting tangled in the lines and ruining a landing are better than the odds of the rocket being saved by the lines. From my armchair observations, it looks like they just need to tweak some constants in their control algorithm to avoid control-induced oscillation. This is the first time that the rocket has reached the ship while still under control (the first landing attempt ran out of hydraulic fluid and went out of control, and of course the second not-quite-attempt didn't have the ship there so it probably wasn't as obvious what was going on) and I imagine there's a fair amount of "oh, duh, how did I overlook that?" going around SpaceX headquarters now that they've finally seen it in action all the way to the end.