9 ms·
A Field Guide to the American Sandwich
- thethrows 12y agoWhy is the image loading so poor on this website?
- yareally 12y agoAfter inspecting the img tags and skimming what is required just to load them, I'd say they overengineered things just a bit.
- wtbob 12y agoThere were images? Must be loaded with some weird JavaScript—all I saw were chunks of white space.
- yareally 12y agoYeah, it's one of those lazy loading js implementations that tries to be too clever. It's not only lazy loading them, but it's trying to load different sizes based on the client. Not sure if anything they do would be better than just using optimized jpegs and settling on one size.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zorpner 12y agoSome opposing viewpoints from the Guardian: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/03/is-a-hot-dog-a-sandwich-nature-america http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jul/03/is-a-ho...
- baking 12y agoYou take a sub roll, split it in half, slather it in mayo, layer on meat and cheese, then throw it in a pizza oven until the bread is toasty and the cheese is melted, then add the veggies. That is a grinder. Everything else is just a sandwich.
- monk_e_boy 12y agoOh wow, when my friend explained grindr to me he got it completely wrong.
- CDRdude 12y agoSurely he explained the part about meat in between buns?
- gensym 12y agoGreat guide, but Chicago's best sandwich, the jibarito (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jibarito http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jibarito) was overlooked.
- cubano 12y agoI often miss the Chicago food scene as I lived there for about 2 years. That town really takes it to the next level in so many different ways. FULL DISCLOSURE: It's also where I discovered my heroin habit.
- nemo44x 12y agoIt's not a sandwich as it isn't made with some form of bread. At least according to the criteria the article uses - which I agree with.
- stox 12y agoTown Hall Deli! I miss you so much.
- toastking 12y agoI love how they use such fancy language to describe sandwiches.
- slvv 12y agoInteresting to see how many of these sandwiches I (a Canadian) have absolutely no experience with, and which ones are super familiar. (Anecdotally: most of the sliced bread ones are familiar, a lot of the hard & soft roll ones are new.) Cool!
- davidw 12y agoPanini is just Italian for sandwiches. Panino being the singular. You can put what you want on them but popular things here would be one of prosciutto, speck, salami, cheeses like mozzarella or (locally) Asiago, and maybe tomatoes.
- cbd1984 12y ago> Panini is just Italian for sandwiches. That's Italian. In English, it denotes a specific kind of sandwich.
- saraid216 12y agoIt's American English. For Americans, the word we just stole means whatever the fuck we want.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shiven 12y agoSame with biscotti, or so I have been told by nonplussed Italians who were offered some.
- cbd1984 12y agoThat's how every language works. Every language borrows and repurposes words.
- davidw 12y agoSome of them are certainly odd for native speakers of the borrowed word though: "panini sandwiches" for instance. Sometimes languages "borrow" nonexistant words, like "footing" for jogging in Italian.
- pluma 12y agoOr "pepperoni" being a salami. Cue confused Americans complaining about their pizza being too damn spicy and not having any meat on it.
- alelefant 12y agoI disagree with the declaration of open faced sandwiches not being a sandwich. You're telling me smørrebrød isn't a sandwich? I realize it's not American, but it's a sandwich, baby.
- cdcarter 12y agoHow could that be a sandwich?! I don't want to cite the dictionary but a sandwich is distinctly a food where fillings are sandwiched by bread. A smørrebrød or tartine can be tasty, but don't claim they're a sammie.
- talmand 12y agoCurious, was the word "sandwich" used in that context before the invention of the sandwich by the Earl of Sandwich? If not, I don't think you can use a secondary definition of a word as an example for the primary definition when the secondary definition exists solely because of the primary definition.
- kgwgk 12y agoThis reminds me of a great line from DeVito in Heist: “Everybody needs money! That's why they call it money!” http://miniver.blogspot.ch/2004/02/everybody-needs-roger-ebert.html http://miniver.blogspot.ch/2004/02/everybody-needs-roger-ebe...
- cdcarter 12y agoThere was a logical flaw there perhaps, but I stand by my point. Per a Guardian article linked side-thread, the sandwich was invented by our good Earl for a easily portable and hand-eatable food. One would not call an open-faced nightmare that.
- juliangregorian 12y agoIt's absolutely not a sandwich. "Open-faced sandwich" is a travesty of a name for a lone slice of bread with something on top. We should call it what it is. A disappointment.
- blt 12y agothere's a lot of fucked up things about my country, but our sandwiches aren't one of them. never trust anyone who doesn't like a sandwich.
- Stratoscope 12y agoA tip for any photographers out there: When you're shooting food, don't do the wide aperture no-depth-of-field thing like this article. Get the entire plate in focus. Otherwise the food just looks kind of weird and dizzying.
- bayonetz 12y agoAnyone else on the West Coast, who's lived on the East Coast, feel a void in the sandwich shop culture there? I've been living in Santa Monica / LA for a while now and there is basically nothing. People go nuts for this place called Bay Cities but it would just be a 'meh place on the east coast. I'm talking humble sub shops here. Of course there are some good artisan food trucks and jewish delis, but nothing much better sub-shop-wise than chains like Jersey Mike's or Subway. I guess this article made me hungry. And sad. Good night.
- EpicEng 12y agoAgreed. Also, as I'm from Chicago, I feel that there is a severe lack of decent pizza out here.
- juliangregorian 12y agoSo you should feel right at home then! (I kid, I kid, but I'm from New York so you know how I feel)
- EpicEng 12y agoGrrr... this comment branch could get deep if you want to start talking Chicago v NY style pizza :D
- simplemath 12y agoDi Napoli pls.
- fit2rule 12y agoThe place called New York Pizza near LA Community College is pretty decent. But I will never be impressed with American pizza again .. not after a few weeks in Rome. Best pizza in the world, period.
- tallanvor 12y ago
- ohazi 12y agoI like how "Avocado" is a category. My kind of sandwich.
- ascorbic 12y agoThe sandwich (by that name) may have been born in England, but damn you guys over the pond perfected it and made it your own. I am so hungry now.
- timthorn 12y agoThe first time I went into Subway in America and asked for a cheese & tomato sandwich, I discovered that there was a big difference between what people in the US think of as a sandwich and a British sarnie. And just don't try for a cheese and pickle sandwich...
- nsxwolf 12y agoThe first time I went into Subway in Australia they asked me "what salads" I wanted. I thought they were asking me if I wanted a salad. They were asking me what I wanted on it! I told my friends and they wanted to know what they say in America if not "what salads", and I said "they just say what do you want on it", and they thought that was pretty funny.
- talmand 12y agoI find that amusing because I've always said that Subway serves salad with a side of small, tasteless, worthless sandwich.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI've always thought they weren't a restaurant at all. Think about it. What benefit does a restaurant give? There are only 3. They cook the food. They serve the food. They clean up the dishes. Subway does none of those. They count Zero on the restaurant scale. They don't even have recipes. They advertise that they do - the new chicken carbonara! Try asking for it. "What do you want on that?" I answer "I don't know, what does it come with?" They say "It doesn't come with anything." Once I dragged the signpost from the doorway over to the counter and pointed at the ad, which included a list of ingredients. "I want that". The poor girl cried. The pinnacle of incompetence was my son asking for a BLT. "What do you want on it?" My god.
- pca2 12y agoI'm generally not a very patriotic American, but boy did I feel a certain amount of pride looking at all of these sandwiches that have been crafted in America.
- pluma 12y agoInteresting what American call "hard" rolls.
- Haul4ss 12y agoThis is a great article that celebrates the best of the U.S. as a "melting pot". So many of these sandwiches are a mishmash of the cultures from all over the world that influenced them. Also, this article made me pine for a good Jewish deli were I live. I haven't had a proper Reuben in years.
- oliv__ 12y agoI just read the article on my actual newspaper but damn seeing it on the web really is a completely different experience: those big, crisp (and colored!) pictures are so much nicer online it made me hungry! This is where their website really shines, imo.
- scott_s 12y agoThe first thing I thought of was this bit from 30 Rock (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7eq7O4SbJk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7eq7O4SbJk): "All of humankind has one thing in common: the sandwich. I believe that all anyone really wants in this life is to sit in peace and eat a sandwich."
- wbond 12y agoI wonder how prevalent distinctly regional sandwiches are in different parts of the US. I've grown up on the North Shore of Boston and around here we have "Roast Beef" shops. From what I understand, the roast beef you get is distinctly different than anywhere else I've visited. The meat is served warm and very thinly sliced on a burger bun or onion roll. Many people order it topped with barbecue sauce and possibly some cheese, horseradish or mayonnaise. The "beef" sandwiches usually come in two or three different sizes, such as junior, large or super. A common combination of barbecue sauce, cheese and mayo can be ordered by the phrase "three-way." There tends to be distinct loyalty to your favorite roast beef place. Some roast beef shops also serve pizza, "subs" or possibly fried seafood, but the best tend to focus on roast beef. There is one chain of roast beef places called Kelly's, but most of the roast beef places seem to be independent. Here is a slideshow of what to expect: http://www.seriouseats.com/2012/10/where-to-eat-the-best-roast-beef-sandwiches-boston-slideshow.html http://www.seriouseats.com/2012/10/where-to-eat-the-best-roa... What are some other distinctly regional sandwiches?
- talmand 12y agoI grew up in the Southeast, lived in the Southwest, and currently live in the Southmiddle. I would say there are regional tastes in sandwiches but many things seem to be universal. For instance, the sandwich you describe I've had in variations everywhere I've lived. It's just a roast beef sandwich. The only real differences I suspect are the use in locally obtained ingredients that have a huge potential to making the sandwich different from region to region. That may be why what is essentially a universal sandwich could be better in one place than another. I shall have to remember your recommendation if I ever find myself in the Boston area. As for your question, growing up in the Southeast the best I can offer off the top of my head is the pulled pork sandwich. There are far more variations than you describe for your beef sandwich. I've seen the sandwich offered in the other areas I've lived, obviously, but not as prevalent as in the Southeast. My wife claims nothing matches pulled pork sandwiches from this one place from her childhood in small town Alabama. I can't say which sandwich for the Southwest as I lived in Vegas and that place is not based in reality. As for Southmiddle, gourmet hamburgers seems to be the current sandwich fad.
- 12y ago
- dilap 12y agoOh man, seeing that avocado sandwich brought back visceral memories of my childhood growing up in the hippy enclaves of Mt Shasta CA and Ashland OR. Should you find yourself in San Francisco, as I do now, I strongly urge you to visit Darwin Cafe and try some of their sandwiches. They are always interesting, almost always good, and sometimes transcendent. (They only do like 4 sandwiches at a time, and mix them up every couple of weeks.) Oh, and I agree with another commenter: to me, open-faced sandwiches are very very much sandwiches. How can a salmon tartine not be a sandwich? Or spanish tostas? Madness!
- ozten 12y agoUsing, primarily, the bread doesn't feel like the right way to create a sandwich taxonomy. I think it would be a cluster of characteristics and the most prominent example of that category (say, the hamburger) would often be the category name.
- surge 12y agoNit-picking southerner: Pimento cheese has pimentos, not red bell peppers, which are not the same thing. It's the little red thing you see in olives.