4 ms·

Feedback for @damienj: * Your Terms & Conditions link is a PDF that downloads vs displays inline. That's super weird, and I thought I got a report without sign

by web007 12y ago

Feedback for @damienj: * Your Terms & Conditions link is a PDF that downloads vs displays inline. That's super weird, and I thought I got a report without signing up. Nope, it's your ToS. * The paginated loading of HTML/CSS validation does strange things with the loading bar. I was trying to drag it to the bottom, and it kept moving itself upward as it loaded new pieces. Doing the deferred loading is cool, but it would be better to kick it off async and have it run to completion, versus waiting for scroll-per-page. * In the downloaded report, there's no indication of what the grey circles are (average top-1000 result). * Detected Technologies is odd, it only lists comScore for the site I tested - should that include Google Analytics, Facebook Graph, etc.? * The Table of Contents isn't clickable to get to the related sections. * The color-coding of sections doesn't mesh mentally with the counts presented. I have something in green (Success) with 7 tips, and something else in red (Issues) with 7 tips as well. Is that good or bad? * I didn't check the "short" report option, but I'd like to see just things-to-fix in its own report, with details of how to fix them. As-is I have a 35-page report with no clear indication of what the biggest problems are, just the biggest per-category. I realize the webpage already does that, but unless I'm the sole developer I would want to send a hit list out to my team as a PDF. * Your own page is only 99 out of 100 =) All of that aside, this looks really useful. It's like a prettier version of http://www.webpagetest.org/ http://www.webpagetest.org/ - a lot of the same info, but a much better / more modern presentation. A good pricing hook might be a free (scheduled) report once a month, with the top-level warnings included but a paid option for the full detail. Good luck, and congrats on "SHIP IT"!

damienj 12y ago
Thanks a lot for this great piece of feedback. - T&C : that was a fast fix for something, it will be solve as soon as we find a few minutes - lazyloading on W3C listings: agreed and noted - PDF/average top-1000 result : indeed, we have to add that! - Detected Technologies: Yes for Google Analytics, that's odd. No for social widgets. We are mainly focused on CMS and frameworks. - Table of Contents: you're right - color-coding: it will be changed soon. New policy will be: if you have one issue at least in a given category, the category will be red (for now is based on the average grade of the category). - "short" report: you're not alone, we add you to the list, but still to few people - 99/100 damned! "A good pricing hook might be a free (scheduled) report once a month" > you have that daily for free (from you're dashboard, you can create a "monitoring"). Paid options allow to use the tool on other pages than homepages and to use advanced settings (custom bandwidth, authentication, etc) Thanks again! (and sorry for typos)

by web007 12y ago

damienj 12y ago

Thanks a lot for this great piece of feedback. - T&C : that was a fast fix for something, it will be solve as soon as we find a few minutes - lazyloading on W3C listings: agreed and noted - PDF/average top-1000 result : indeed, we have to add that! - Detected Technologies: Yes for Google Analytics, that's odd. No for social widgets. We are mainly focused on CMS and frameworks. - Table of Contents: you're right - color-coding: it will be changed soon. New policy will be: if you have one issue at least in a given category, the category will be red (for now is based on the average grade of the category). - "short" report: you're not alone, we add you to the list, but still to few people - 99/100 damned! "A good pricing hook might be a free (scheduled) report once a month" > you have that daily for free (from you're dashboard, you can create a "monitoring"). Paid options allow to use the tool on other pages than homepages and to use advanced settings (custom bandwidth, authentication, etc) Thanks again! (and sorry for typos)