4 ms·
Will we also see the attempt to land the rocket in this stream?
by jerf 12y ago
Will we also see the attempt to land the rocket in this stream?
- Phlarp 12y agoI hope so, but it wasn't included in the live stream last time.
- grecy 12y agoAt about +1:30 I heard "Recovery platform has acquisition signal" and then: "Stage separation confirmed. Good luck stage 1" and "We have stage 1 boostback startup" then a little while later "stage 1 boostback shutdown" (sounded good) "stage one entry burn has started" then "stage one entry shutdown" "stage one is transonic" "stage one landing burn has started" "LOS of stage one" (From reddit: waiting for stage one confirm..... Waiting for tweet from Musk) officially waiting for word from the landing ship... webcast over. (From reddit: "We falcon punched the barge" ) (From reddit: "Rumors that the Falcon 9 booster landed on the drone ship, but not softly. At this point, who knows.") (From reddit: Not a successful landing today.) Musk Tweet: "Ascent successful. Dragon enroute to Space Station. Rocket landed on droneship, but too hard for survival." https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588076749562318849 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/588076749562318849
- Cshelton 12y agoIf it's successful I hope they'll show a quick replay for stage 1. Probably reasons why they don't want to show it live...
- mikeash 12y agoFrom what I understand, the reason they don't show it live is because they don't have enough bandwidth to transmit live video from the barge. They get a frame every second or two, and lots of telemetry, but not video.
- jerf 12y agoThank you, that makes sense. All things considered I'd still call what happened today a good sign.
- mikeash 12y agoThey're getting ever closer. And they have a great setup to experiment with. They have paying customers funding the whole thing, and they can take their time to get it right. If this was some pure R&D project, today's events would probably be a major setback. But SpaceX still made a healthy profit on this launch even with the bang at the end. That's the genius of their approach, and it's why I think they'll succeed where others have failed.
- InclinedPlane 12y agoSo far SpaceX has used approximately a third of a billion dollars in launch hardware in reusability testing, almost entirely subsidized through commercial launches. It's a very savvy way to do R&D. Note that it takes a lot of foresight to design a rocket which can serve as both a good expendable booster and also be sensibly made reusable, and most of the optimizations for expendability would push the design away from being good for reuse.
- mikeash 12y agoIt takes some smarts and will to realize that fully optimizing for reusability isn't the right move, too. It's a constant refrain in these comment threads to ask, why don't they use parachutes? Why don't they use wings? Why not do all sorts of things that would make it easier to reuse, instead of trying a crazy vertical landing suicide burn onto a boat? The paradox is that making reusability easier would make it harder, because you'd have to get it right from the start, and spend a lot more money developing it, and ensure you can reuse each vehicle many times to make up for the increased cost. So instead of inventing something new, they started with something known to work, and then adapted it. Because it's cheap, you can keep tweaking it in live tests and not worry too much when you break the stuff. People often compare this stuff to the Space Shuttle, since that's the one example of a reusable rocket that actually flew, and it was never cheaper than expendable launchers. Imagine what would have happened if the Shuttle had crashed on its first two landing attempts. The program would have been dead before it got anywhere. Now imagine what would have happened if the Shuttle had been so cheap that they could build and launch one for $60 million, instead of $2 billion per orbiter and $500 million per launch (and imagine that somehow they could be lost without killing anybody). It would have been an enormous success even if a bunch had crashed.
- david-given 12y agoOne of the most impressive things about SpaceX (and don't take this wrong, it's not intended as a snark to your comment) is that nobody cares about the payloads any more --- they just work. We just assume that when they launch something it'll get there. Their first ISS mission was in early 2012! That's less than three years ago! That's amazing! There is no higher compliment for a rocketry company than to be considered boring. That said... I'm waiting for the first stage landing footage. squee