3 ms·
The plaintiff is going to loose this lawsuit. Trade dress is essentially packaging. The Coca Cola bottle is considered trade dress. Essentially Lanham act prote
by briandear 12y ago
The plaintiff is going to loose this lawsuit. Trade dress is essentially packaging. The Coca Cola bottle is considered trade dress. Essentially Lanham act protects trade dress only when said trade dress functions as a trademark would.
Even if the alleged trade dress does function as a trademark, the plaintiff would still have to establish that there is a likelihood of confusion between the plaintiff and Apple. That would be a huge stretch by any standard because Apple doesn't sell art, they sell computers. The likelihood of proving that a consumer would confuse Apple with some artist is extremely small.
In terms of the artistic style, Romero isn't particularly interesting or even original. Artist Joseph Peirmatteo, for instance uses a similar style:
Piermatteo example: http://lesintemporels.fr/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/piermatteo_comme_sur_des_roulettes.jpg http://lesintemporels.fr/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/piermatt...
Romero: http://uploads3.wikiart.org/images/romero-britto/first-love.jpg http://uploads3.wikiart.org/images/romero-britto/first-love....
Picasso: http://www.umma.umich.edu/images/view/collection-galleries/picasso-two-girls-reading.jpg http://www.umma.umich.edu/images/view/collection-galleries/p...
Marceau Constantin: http://www.avignon-et-provence.com/musee-provence/musee-marceau-constantin/img/visage.jpg http://www.avignon-et-provence.com/musee-provence/musee-marc...
We also have obvious stylistic "borrowing" from Roy Lichtenstein..
and James Rizzi: http://www.galerie-am-dom.de/prdimages/James-Rizzi-_Day-or-night-my-city-is-bright.jpg http://www.galerie-am-dom.de/prdimages/James-Rizzi-_Day-or-n...
in terms of that "black outline" mentioned in the article, Keith Haring uses a similar technique and color palette.
The point is that artistic style isn't trade dress. If that were the case then Cubism would have ended with Picasso and Braque. Pop art would have ended with Warhol. Interestingly, Artists have appropriated brand names (i.e. Campbell's Soup, Brillo) for their own artwork (from which they made a significant financial gain,) so Apple, appropriating an artistic style is returning the favor.
I find it interesting that the suit has to claim that Romero Britto is a "world-famous visual artist." That's subjective. An Apple customer in Dallas, Texas or San Diego is very likely not going to be confusing Apple's ads with Romero. Even if there were some kind of connection, it would be an "homage" and not a dilution of Romero's "brand." For example, using an audio clip in a commercial that sounds like a Bob Dylan guitar riff (but isn't,) isn't infringing on Dylan's trade dress. Providing that there Romero is financially harmed in this case is going to be next to impossible. In fact, his stock likely goes up after this -- which explains why he's suing Apple. It's all about the payday, not the damage to his art.