2 ms·
Random idea, if batteries are cheap enough could we charge them up and ship them on trains back forth instead of building high voltage transmission lines?
by mrfusion 12y ago
Random idea, if batteries are cheap enough could we charge them up and ship them on trains back forth instead of building high voltage transmission lines?
- jeffasinger 12y agoI had the same thought reading the article, but after some thought, I doubt it. Grid transmission can be as low as 0.5% per 100 miles already. Batteries lose about 10% of the energy by storing it, that leaves you with needing to go at least 2000 miles in order to make up the battery loss difference, plus needing the energy to move the batteries physically.
- ch4s3 12y agoFloat them down a river. \s
- intrasight 12y agoTrue. They float plenty of coal on the rivers here in Pittsburgh
- jbert 12y agoPerhaps stretch out a flow battery with a pair of pipelines? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery We could repurpose those oil pipelines we no longer need. :-)
- crpatino 12y agoBatteries are cheap to charge in-place. Once you load those into a train you have to add the cost (both economic and in energy conversion rates) of moving the whole mass around in a diesel powered vehicle. We already do that with alkaline batteries, and we pay premium price per BTU because of the convenience of begin able to carry small quantities of electricity around. But if you want to move city-powering amounts of it (think millions of Megawatt-hour), I am guessing a grid is more efficient.