6 ms·
2015 MacBook Review
- FreakyT 12y agoThis review seems to indicate that the 2015 MacBook has similar issues to the original 2008-era MacBook air: lots of potential, but still worth waiting for a 2nd generation product to work out some of the issues. Personally, though, I'm just excited that Apple finally offers a laptop in multiple colors. (And without a price premium, for anyone who remembers the "black tax"[1]) [1] http://www.512pixels.net/blog/2015/2/future-classics-the-black-macbook http://www.512pixels.net/blog/2015/2/future-classics-the-bla...
- mfunke 12y agoMoore's law always works. So if you don't need to buy one now, the next gen is might be the better choice.
- Someone1234 12y agoTrue. But in this specific case the whole concept doesn't seem "fully baked" yet. The USB-C was a great idea, but just a single USB port on the entire machine that worse still will be in-use by the charger? And $80 adapters if you want a second usable port? This line of machine has potential. But it needed minimum a second USB port for mice/keyboards/hubs/USB keys/etc. The Surface Pro 3 only has a single USB port, but in that case that single port isn't also used for charging so it is "workable" (and it has a second Display Port also, which this also lacks).
- _asummers 12y agoThe 8GB RAM is kind of a deal breaker to me. If I could up that to 16, I'd most likely buy this. What was the reason for limiting it?
- jdietrich 12y agoDifferentiation. The MacBook is designed to be the thinnest and lightest possible laptop that provides adequate performance for the majority of users. Users who need more ports or more performance are expected to opt for the 13" MacBook Pro Retina, which provides a far better price-performance ratio. Not unreasonably, Apple assume that most people who need large amount of RAM will also need a fast processor; Adding the option for 16GB on the MacBook would increase the size of the logic board for the benefit of a very small niche of users. Jony Ive has always been ruthless about avoiding feature creep, going back to the original G3 iMac and the highly contentious decision to drop legacy ports and the floppy drive.
- Eric_WVGG 12y agoBattery life is certainly part of it; RAM that isn’t being used still draws power. But isn’t the whole idea behind an ultra-portable that you make sacrifices for greater portability? The Pro isn’t getting dropped from the lineup… Augh why are we still having discussions about the specs on low-end/ultraportable laptops? Why do people think that every single laptop model should be tailored for their personal needs?
- barrkel 12y agoThe single biggest thing that lengthens the useful lifetime of a PC is memory - as much as you can fit. There's compromises, and then there's hobbling.
- simonh 12y agoIt depends what your priorities are. If lightness and thinnes and battery life are top priorities, and making the RAM upgradeable or increasing the space on the board to provide that as an option compromises those, then a machine that makes that compromise is hobbled. The whole point of having more than one laptop design in your lineup is that they make different design tradeoffs.
- TheLoneWolfling 12y agoHowever, enough RAM prevents additional disk operations, which draw substantially more power, be it an SSD or spinning disk. Also, RAM typically draws very little power compared to other components (screen, etc, etc). The reason why we are still having discussions about the specs on low-end / ultraportable laptops is that they are so often almost useful, but take things one step too far.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThe entire motherboard is about the size of a single DIMM.
- barrkel 12y agoI had a similar problem with the MBA I bought (2012?), in order to get the maximum amount of RAM (4GB), I had to max out the expensive SDD too. To get 50 USD worth of RAM, I had to spend closer to 300+USD extra. And the biggest problem I have with it today is still lack of memory - it's fast enough for what I use it for, as a travel laptop (I run Windows 7 on it, mind).
- kaolinite 12y agoApparently it's a limitation of the chipset. It can only support 8GB when soldered onto the board (16GB when unsoldered). Can't find the reference for it on Intel's website but it was discussed at length on the Accidental Tech Podcast (atp.fm) by John Siracusa.
- wyager 12y agoIt's worth noting that, for some reason, Intel's specifications are almost always wrong when it comes to how much RAM you can use with a given processor. I've had a number of computers (one Apple, one non-Apple) where all the docs claimed that the max RAM was $X GB, when in reality it would work fine with $2X GB. I suspect Intel's listed max RAM specifications are based on some other engineering considerations than what is actually possible.
- woof 12y agoLack of space. I own a 3 year old MacBook Air 11" with 4GB RAM and that works surprisingly well. It even runs Photoshop fairly good. I'd say 8GB is ok unless you do extensive image or video editing -and then the MacBook (or the Air) is not the right machine any way.
- EthanHeilman 12y agoDevelopers often use much more than 8GBs of RAM, especially if they are running VMs, databases, compiling code, running tests, IDEs and emulating smart phones. More and more I'm seeing a distinction in requirements between "user machines" and "engineer machines".
- woof 12y agoMy 4GB MacBook Air 11" is slow with Parallels, postgres, apache, emacs and the usual programs (mail, chat, multiple browsers etc.) -but usuable. Even my 3-4 years old MacBook Pro with 8GB was a little slow, but processor speed was the culprit. My year old MacBook Pro (2,4 i7) with 16GB is fast, but I have more memory then I actually need... I've even used it with three simultaneous Parallels instances (FreeBSD Server, FreeBSD CI and Windows 7 client) and it runs fine. 8GB memory is not a dealbreaker for me, I'd buy the new MacBook any day :)
- eropple 12y agoI dunno--even as a developer (JVM, some Ruby) I honestly don't use that much RAM anymore now that I don't work for a company that thinks it is a grand idea to load eight gigs of crap into memory just to start the application server. I think we're moving towards much more composable systems that have much less need for fat memory specs. Even when working on my game in Windows I only have 4GB allocated to the VM (VS2015, C#).
- cmsj 12y agoIf you're doing all of those things at once, you want a MacBook Pro
- jchendy 12y agoPossibly just to make you buy a Pro?
- higherpurpose 12y agoI wonder if people realize Apple could've offered the same product for probably no more than $800 at most using its own next-gen A9 processor with similar performance. All it needed to do is focus earlier on on ARM portability for its Mac apps.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wodenokoto 12y agoAre you saying that this is the same speed as an iPad air?
- woof 12y ago>All it needed to do is focus earlier on on ARM portability for its Mac apps. Just like Microsoft did with Windows RT?
- dilap 12y agoswitching architectures ain't something you do just so you can get a temporary price reduction in one product! it's kind of a big deal†. (& apple knows exactly what's involved, since they've done it twice already. (68k => ppc => intel.)) i don't think we'll see arm mac's unless/until intel definitively becomes uncompetitive. †in an ecosystem where distributing arch-specific binaries to end-users is still a big deal
- Phlarp 12y agoI doubt this very much.
- untog 12y agoYes, because Windows RT was such a huge success.
- GreaterFool 12y agoIt looks like a perfect laptop for programming (tinkering). Most of the time I just ssh to a remote server or keep a window with persistent mosh connection. All my stuff on the server is only tmux attach -d away! I suppose I could compile small to mid sized programs on the Macbook itself. Benchmarks indicate it has enough power for that. Compiling something like boost or linux kernel might take a while but I don't do that very often. In the end, I don't know. I'm keen to give it a go. I switched to 13" rMBP from Air for the retina screen and I still remember how clunky it felt. Probably not enough to be my only laptop but wouldn't mind swapping my 13" rMBP for 12" Macbook + 15" rMBP (when quad core Broadwell or Skylake comes out).
- nfoz 12y agoIt looks like the keyboard is terrible, which rules out programming for me.
- pdiddy 12y agoWhy do you say the keyboard looks terrible? They have been touting the new keyboard a lot. See here: https://www.apple.com/macbook/design/ https://www.apple.com/macbook/design/
- dogecoinbase 12y agoFrom the article you're notionally commenting on: Ultimately I don’t find the MacBook’s keyboard to be any different to type on as far as key size and feel goes (even with my large fingers), but your mileage may vary.
- nsxwolf 12y agoI spent some time with the keyboard. It's not terrible. It's very different in feel from the Air/Pro, especially when typing fast. It takes some getting used to but I would not complain if this keyboard made its way to the MacBook Pro.
- eropple 12y agoSort-of-agreed. I like the corner stability, but I think I'd be unhappy if the key travel was this poor on the MacBook Pro.
- DannyDelott 12y agoOne port is a problem for me. Minimal design now meets minimal function.
- kmfrk 12y agoEspecially when your battery requires a power adapter to stay on three years down the line.
- zk00006 12y agoBefore Apple shows that this issue is resolved: www.staingate.org, any new model is just a waste of money for me.
- dilap 12y agoi had this happen on a macbook i used some weird cleaning agent on the screen with; this was maybe 3 or 4 macbook's ago -- since then i'm really picky about what i use to clean the screen, and i haven't had the problem. obviously it's not definitive, but i suspect cleaning products may be to blame, or blame in a large number of cases. edit: knock on wood.
- zk00006 12y agoYes this is what Apple says. The fact is that all screens have serious structured patterns imprinted from the keys - independent on the cleaning method.
- pdiddy 12y agoWhen you say picky what do you use? Shouldn't you just use water?
- dilap 12y agoYeah, mostly just water. My (now ex) officemate had something else he was using for a while without problems, so I used that sometimes, too.
- JustSomeNobody 12y agoHaving worked my way through an engineering degree as a lab manager for an optical lab, this looks like what happens to an A/R (anti-reflective) coating when harsh cleaning chemicals are used (Windex, etc...). On mine, I would just use a water-dampened, clean, soft towel if I need to clean my screen. And by clean towel, I mean clean. I don't even set it on the counter as it can pick up particulate matter. And by soft, I mean never a paper towel. Ever.
- fit2rule 12y ago
- emehrkay 12y agoThat very first picture looks like an iPad with a keyboard attached. I wonder if they'll ever put the logic board in the screen housing and make the bottom piece all battery.
- Someone1234 12y agoI liked the Windows performance page. Very useful. I'd love a Windows battery life page. Macs running OS X get very solid battery life (8-12 hrs). Running Parallels they get "aright" battery life. Running bootcamp with any version of Windows tanks them into the ground (2-3 hrs) due to Apple's poorly optimised Windows drivers and bugs (e.g. running the cooling fan at max constantly). Microsoft has done a lot to improve Windows' battery consumption (with the Surface Pro 2 & 3 getting around 8-9 hrs depending on who you believe), so Apple cannot continue to claim that Windows itself is the problem. Dell, Lenovo, and others have all been able to produce Windows-based laptops and tablets with decent battery life, why can't Apple?
- jasonpbecker 12y agoWhy would they? They are making hardware to work with their operating system. Do you blame PC makers who have bad battery life on Linux because there are bad open source drivers? Or PC makers that don't run well as a Hackintosh?
- Someone1234 12y ago> Why would they? Then why provide Bootcamp at all? > Do you blame PC makers who have bad battery life on Linux because there are bad open source drivers? In a word, yes. I do. But the reality on the ground is that a lot of those hardware manufacturers aren't advertising Linux support as a "feature." Apple does advertise Windows support as one.
- WorldWideWayne 12y agoEver since the switch to Intel chips, Apple has billed all of their Macs as being able to run Windows and that is a big selling point for them. So, I don't think it's out of line to ask them to make proper drivers for running an operating system that they do support.
- whatisapancake 12y agoIIRC a bug causes the CPU to sit at 100% constantly, that's why the fan runs at max. A sleep-wake cycle after boot temporarily fixes that problem and the battery life increases.
- nsxwolf 12y agoApple could have moved the Magsafe mechanism an inch or two down the line from the USB-C connector, making it a 2-piece cable much like the safety breakaway mechanism on wired XBox controllers.
- brianolson 12y agoNew thing here: NVMe SSD! I've read a bunch of other reviews and none mentioned that. Kudos to AnandTech for thinking about that detail. Thinking about that in conjunction with the storage benchmarks is interesting, faster in most tests but a little slower in random-write. Now I want that in the next -Pro version to be my next development machine.
- mrbonner 12y agothe keyboard is terrible. I figured it out after about 10 minutes typing on the dang thing.
- jasonargonaut 12y agoWhy so nasty? Instead of calling it a 'dang thing', which seems incredibly mean, why not just say the keyboard wasn't right for you?