5 ms·
> On Jan. 18, 2012, an Ontario judge granted a search warrant to seize 32 servers in Canada — equivalent to the amount of data stored on 100 laptops, according
by joshstrange 12y ago
> On Jan. 18, 2012, an Ontario judge granted a search warrant to seize 32 servers in Canada — equivalent to the amount of data stored on 100 laptops, according to Megaupload lawyers.
Wait what??? Neither servers nor laptops have any sort of "average HD size". This comparison seems quite stupid. It's not only apples and oranges to compare the two but provides no meaningful data at all....
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joshstrange 12y ago> both servers and alptops obviously do have an average HD size Ok what are those numbers? And how long are they valid for? I've got 35TB on one of my servers, and 20GB on 2 other ones. My Laptop is 256GB but my last one was 1TB... These numbers mean nothing at all. It's a stupid comparison. I doubt the averages would last for ever a year without changing pretty drastically. Edit: deleted parent comment: > both servers and alptops obviously do have an average HD size, so the average may not be all that meaningful -- for servefs especially. But i suspect they used the actual size of the servers, not an average, though implicitly they used something like an average for laptops.
- asdfdsafueu33 12y agoOh stop being pedantic/dense.. it's really not that cryptic. Average consumer laptop has about 250-500GB of HDD space.
- joshstrange 12y agoOk, how large is an average HD space on a server? Are we assuming servers have an average of 750GB - 1.5TB? That is not correct either. I'm not being dense, both servers and desktops have WILDLY different HD sizes.
- gress 12y agoYou seem to be ignoring the meaning of average. It's a statistic that you can create to characterize a numeric property of any well defined category. If you agree that there are laptops, and that there are servers as categories, then we can take a sample of each category, and calculate an average HDD size for each, regardless of the standard deviation. It is true by definition that there are average HDD sizes for servers and laptops. If you disagree with their estimates, do you have reasoning to show that they are wrong?
- joshstrange 12y agoI don't discount that there EXISTS an average but I don't think it would line up at all with their numbers. I fully understand the meaning of "average" and I also understand that there are a LARGE number of times that the average is completely useless due to the input data. In most of those cases it's better to use the MEDIAN not the MEAN (average). For example if you are looking at the following data set: $20,000 $30,000 $25,000 $35,000 $100,000 The mean is $42,000 but the median is $30,000 which is a better representation of the data IMHO. Same with servers, you have servers that are massive for storing data and small <10GB App servers that sit behind a LB. What I'm trying to say is the numbers don't make sense and it's a BAD comparison. It would be a little better if they gave numbers for either laptops or servers but they way they have it phrased they just as well could have said "They seized 35 apples that is equivalent to 100 oranges". Lastly while there EXISTS averages no doubt I challenge you to FIND these averages, a quick couple google searches produces no such knowledge. Not to mention that while an average exists I believe it to be incalculable unless you want to use sampling due to the fact that the VAST majority of companies do not share that type of information.
- gress 12y agoDo you think the median HDD for servers is larger than the median HDD size for laptops?
- joshstrange 12y ago
- belorn 12y agoWhile the numbers are only valid for this moment in time, its possible to get a list of laptops from a price comparison web service and do average on it. Doing a very hasty lookup (the site I use got diagrams that represent number of products with each drive size), cheap <1000$ laptops got in average 600G and 1000$ and up got an of average 800G or 1T if you include SSD's.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- buttcoinslol 12y agoPedantry is the top-voted comment yet again. Welcome to Hacker News.
- vonklaus 12y agoCalling something pedantic typically comes with a negative connotation. The above comment raises a fairly reasonable point, pedantic or otherwise.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- marak830 12y agoThats because its one of the few things we all actually agree with. Otherwise were all always arguing different points :-)
- logfromblammo 12y agoThis is lawyer math. It is intended to be persuasive rhetoric, not rational argumentation. The comparison is entirely for the purpose of converting the numbers to a scale familiar (and shocking) to the median member of the jury pool.
- joshstrange 12y agoIf that were the case the number of PEOPLE's personal data would be a far more compelling number. 100 laptops worth of data may be equivalent to the servers but they still don't represent the only thing that should matter: innocent's people data being unlawfully searches/seized.
- logfromblammo 12y agoLawyers are constrained, in that they cannot knowingly tell outright lies, and any intentional misrepresentations they may make are limited by the forbearance of the judge. I'm quite certain that lawyers for the defense would have preferred to say that the seizure and search of the servers was the equivalent of kicking down the doors of 100 homes in your neighborhood, and taking 100 of your neighbors' laptops, merely on the suspicion that they might have unlicensed copies of movies and music on them. And your neighbors are good, hardworking people who already have piles of legitimately purchased CDs and DVDs next to their laptops. They care for their cute babies, and refrain from kicking puppies and kittens at all times. The smell of fresh-baked apple pies frequently wafts across your lawn from their windowsills, along with the sounds of the neighborhood kids playing sandlot baseball. But why would a wookiee live on Endor? It makes no sense! At that time, the judge reminds the defense that Kim Dotcom is the accused, and you stop that crap right now, or you'll get sanctioned.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Lawyers are constrained, in that they cannot knowingly tell outright lies Lawyers may have greater professional consequences if they are caught knowingly telling outright lies in certain contexts, but it is absolutely not the case that they cannot knowingly tell outright lies.
- zb 12y agoThe article states quite clearly (in the fourth paragraph) that the amount of data in question is 25TB. It later mentions that the data was spread across 32 servers and that lawyers compared it to the amount of data in 100 laptops - which would fix the lawyers' estimate for the average amount of data in a laptop at around 250GB. I haven't bought a laptop recently, but that sounds like an entirely reasonable guesstimate to me. The comparison seems like an appropriate way of conveying the order of magnitude of the amount of data that needs to be searched to a non-technical audience. This thread adds nothing interesting to the conversation. Please just stop.