4 ms·
This is certainly an interesting approach, but more interesting to me is the fact that ULA's new rocket (the first they are actually building) won't launch unti
by danpalmer 12y ago
This is certainly an interesting approach, but more interesting to me is the fact that ULA's new rocket (the first they are actually building) won't launch until 2019. As SpaceX have been launching their own since 2010.
Also interesting is the reasoning behind capturing parts of the rocket (and it is only parts) in midair. ULA say this is because the expensive bits are small, and essentially imply that they can get most of the 'wins' with not much effort when compared to SpaceX's "land it on a boat" approach. This may well be true but it seems SpaceX's approach is thinking in wider terms of the re-usability required for frequent space flight, rather than cheap space flight.
I have a keen interest in space flight and SpaceX in particular, so take my opinion with a pinch of salt, but this article reads to me like SpaceX are well over a decade ahead of the ULA, much more forward thinking, and overall the more exciting player in the commercial space-race.
- ohitsdom 12y agoYou probably already know this, but just want to point out that SpaceX's approach goes way beyond "landing it on a boat". For today's launch (and launches in the near future), they'll land it on their barge. But after the landing system has been proven, they'll land it on the launchpad it took off from. Work is already underway at Kennedy Space Center to make a launch site capable to have a rocket landing. Pretty cool animation here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Ca6x4QbpoM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Ca6x4QbpoM I do wonder how much this will save SpaceX in logistics cost once it's in place. Seems a lot cheaper than coordinating a helicopter to catch a rocket engine in mid air, land it on a barge, and ship it back to shore.
- lloeki 12y agoDon't forget that SpaceX aims for that red rock out there. Reusability in this case may go much farther than saving on convoluted blocks of metal but also includes gathering data and experience for a surefire way to get there and back.
- proteusguy 12y agoYeah "won't launch until 2019" means that bird will never fly. Just like SLS.
- JshWright 12y agoULA doesn't have a whole lot of choice on this one... They need to stop using RD-180's from Russia, which means Atlas is going away. Delta is too expensive to pick up the slack, and is also slated to be phased out. I'm not optimistic about the BE-4's (I suspect ULA will end up going with an Aerojet engine), and they may ditch the engine recovery aspects, but I fully expect to see _some_ sort of new launch platform by the end of this decade. They don't have a whole lot of other choices...