4 ms·
The following is oversimplified but has a grain of truth to it: Poor people pay for access to their own money. Rich people are paid for accessing their own mon
by patio11 17y ago
The following is oversimplified but has a grain of truth to it: Poor people pay for access to their own money. Rich people are paid for accessing their own money.
Here's a practical example for you: a one month train pass from my home town to Nagoya costs about $200. A six month pass costs $1,000.
Given these facts, some people (through either lack of means or lack of savvy) will in a six month period buy six one-month passes, each time incurring a $1 ATM fee, for a total cost of $1,206. More savvy people will buy the six month pass on a credit card and pay it off before the grace period runs out, which costs about $990 ($1,000 less the $10 your bank will give you to say "Thanks for your business! Please charge more stuff!").
If you know you're going to be working in Nagoya for six months, buying the six month ticket is equivalent to buying six month CDs at an APR in excess of 40%. The actual rate offered on a Japanese CD is typically .5%. Somewhat surprisingly, there are many people at my day job who buy both one month tickets and own $5,000 or more in CDs.
- ghshephard 17y agoNot a perfect analysis, but still insightful. My issue with the analysis is that purchasing a CD is, to some degree, a mechanism to store your money - and hopefully get it back at the end of some period of time. Buying tickets one month at a time also gives you the flexibility of finding alternative transport or moving.
- jordanb 17y agoIt's worth observing that your CD example may be rational given that CDs are more liquid than train tickets. Train tickets are generally non-transferable so, absent a black market, they are not liquid at all. Buying a six month ticket is making a $1,000 investment in being in that situation for six months. Maybe they'll lose the job in question, move, or need the $1,000 in cash for some emergency. Depending on how likely those possibilities are, the buyer is going to have a lesser or greater preference towards a more liquid place to put their money.
- patio11 17y agoI would agree absent for the unstated knowledge that everyone at my office is a Japanese salaryman and, as such, the most negative thing you can say about my job security is that I may lose my job if I die.
- nandemo 17y agoTrain tickets are generally non-transferable so, absent a black market, they are not liquid at all. Actually, the tickets are refundable. There are restrictions which vary according to each train company (you might have to pay a small fee, etc), but still the tickets aren't completely illiquid.
- DenisM 17y agoor need the $1,000 in cash for some emergency But that's exactly the point! If you are so poor you don't have the extra $1000 to carry you through you will have to pay more, just for being poor.
- ojbyrne 17y agoI think the time value of money is just totally upside down, and the train pass pricing is a good example of it. Nagoya needs to change their pricing to reflect that, because they're leaving money on the table by charging so much less for a six-month pass vs. one month passes. Chances are the money they get paid up front can't be invested in a short-term asset with a return that justifies the discount. Governments move slow, and leave money behind them.
- patio11 17y agoJR (East and West) are both publicly traded corporations. I sympathize with "governments are inefficient by nature", but I think you're a wee bit off the mark here. I say "a wee bit" because Japan Railways was once owned by the state, and at certain industries and certain sizes in Japan it is difficult to tell where the government stops and the companies start, and vice versa. This phenomenon isn't unique to Japan -- c.f. "military industrial complex" or the security arrangements at airports. Anyhow, both of the JRs are solid constituents of what used to be called Japan, Inc. (A derisive name in the late-80s which fell out of favor after denationalization and, probably more importantly, after Japan's economic woes caused it to drop off the radar screen of threats to American economic preeminence.)
- gaius 17y agoIt's not that they can invest the money, but that they've certainty over the money, and can plan with it, whereas they can't assume that a buyer of a one-month pass will buy another one-month pass next month.
- drusenko 17y agoNot sure if this is what you meant or not, but while some of the discount comes from the TVM side of things, I'd venture to guess a much larger source of the discount comes from the fact that they have locked you in to a 6 month pass. If you picture the monthly pass as a monthly subscription, then think of a reasonable retention rate for this situation (something less than 100% month-over-month), the value of guaranteeing 6 purchases up front starts to become significant.
- 17y ago