2 ms·
Another question, with the same date set: Albert: I don't know, but Bernard might. Bernard: Then your birthday is in May! Albert: Ha ha! I was lying abo
by logfromblammo 12y ago
Another question, with the same date set:
Albert: I don't know, but Bernard might.
Bernard: Then your birthday is in May!
Albert: Ha ha! I was lying about what I knew.
Bernard: So was I!
Cheryl: Then you both know my birthday now.
(May 15, 16, 19, June 17, 18, July 14, 16, August 14, 15, 17)
- jahooma 12y agoAugust 17, assuming Bernard would have said something different if he knew Albert's first comment was impossible.
- itaibn 12y agoIf Bernard knew that Albert's first comment was impossible, then by the principle of explosion his first statement is correct according to his premises. Therefore his seond statement saying that his first statement is a lie would be incorrect.