4 ms·
In the context of this article's thought experiment, fission's probably out of the question. However, for other scenarios, it is indeed a viable option, consid
by yellowapple 12y ago
In the context of this article's thought experiment, fission's probably out of the question.
However, for other scenarios, it is indeed a viable option, considering that it's statistically the safest (last I checked), very clean, and packs a high energy density.
The problem, though, is that fissile material is subject to a lot of the same availability problems as fossil fuels (if not worse), plus quite a few safety concerns (particularly when it comes to radiation, though coal mining poses this sort of risk, too). The energy density is much better, so we could probably get by for a very long time (especially with things like breeder reactors, increased use of thorium instead of or alongside uranium or plutonium, etc.), but ultimately, we'll need to transition to something like fusion power at the very least.
- eru 12y agoFissile material is easily available. Current prices just make exploiting most reserves uneconomical. I am not sure what time spans you speak about. Thousands of years is possible on fission with current technology and at current levels of demand.
- alphydan 12y agoThe link is somewhat old, but this should help you learn more http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2379 http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2379 (and understand that "thousands of years on fission with current technology" is pretty far from the truth)
- yellowapple 12y agoEasily available in what context, though? To us in the modern day, yeah, it's probably pretty trivial to mine such nuclear fuels, but the article discusses a lack of that technology.
- PepeGomez 12y agoThere is less fissile material than fossil fuels. And the reactors are huge and heavy. Thousands of year maybe at current consumption levels, not if all energy consumption was replaced with nuclear.
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoThe article's thought experiment is useless, it's not even internally consistent. He imagines a world where we could be able to collect old solar panels, but all knowledge is lost. Now what on earth is going to destroy every library in every town all over the earth, but leave solar panels on the rooftops intact? A single small-town library would contain huge amounts of useful knowledge. If we include the knowledge contained in the heads of the survivors, the only realistic way of losing all (or even most) useful knowledge is killing everyone.
- dalke 12y ago"A single small-town library would contain huge amounts of useful knowledge" I can envision a future where libraries have few books. Here's one at a school in Florida - http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/08/25/us-usa-florida-library-idUSKBN0GP0W620140825 http://www.reuters.com/article/2014/08/25/us-usa-florida-lib... . Here's a broader commentary about libraries which don't have physical collections, including a public library in San Antonio - http://www.mnn.com/lifestyle/arts-culture/stories/is-a-library-still-a-library-if-it-has-no-physical-books http://www.mnn.com/lifestyle/arts-culture/stories/is-a-libra... . I doubt that small-town libraries will get rid of all books. Libraries do have collections of local history which are unlikely to be part of a digital archive. (Eg, phone books from the 1950s, local high school yearbooks, photo collections and films about the annual downtown parade, publications from the local genealogical society, etc.) But if in 100 years small-town libraries have mostly switched to digital collections, then yes, it's possible for the knowledge to disappear even if the infrastructure remains. I don't think it's likely, but it's not completely inconsistent.
- tripzilch 12y agoThey won't do that everywhere. The world's a big place.
- PepeGomez 12y agoYou won't find how to do such things in most libraries, you would get the geenral idea, but the details would be still too hard to figure out.