9 ms·
CloudFlare Is Now a Google Cloud Platform Technology Partner
- higherpurpose 12y agoDoes this mean it will be even harder to DDoS sites protected by Cloudflare now?
- sudhirj 12y agoIt's always been hard to DDoS sites protected by Cloudflare. Their business model is to promise to absorb any DDoS attack against you - and I think they've delivered so far.
- andrewpe 12y agoWhat percentage of the web traffic flows through CloudFlare now?
- gabeio 12y agoApparently around 5% http://www.businessinsider.com/cloudflare-is-ready-to-take-on-cisco-2014-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/cloudflare-is-ready-to-take-o...
- abritishguy 12y ago"double web content transfer times" That should be speeds.
- josephmx 12y agoMaybe they're gonna be twice as slow now?
- henningschuster 12y agoDidn't Google announce their own DDOS protection service some month ago?
- yla92 12y agoYou mean the Project Shield[1] ? [1]: https://projectshield.withgoogle.com/en/ https://projectshield.withgoogle.com/en/
- nezo 12y agoIs it going to be beta or alpha, like most Google Cloud services?
- oaktowner 12y agoGoogle Product Manager here. Not sure why you think most Google Cloud Services are in beta. The Google Cloud products page [1] lists 17 main products. Two are in alpha (Container Engine, Deployment Manager), one is in beta (Pub/Sub). The rest are fully supported. There are some beta features here and there...but saying "most" are in beta is certainly not correct. [1] https://cloud.google.com/products/ https://cloud.google.com/products/
- ddorian43 12y agoExample: Data Flow is in Alpha & Logging is in Beta.
- nulltype 12y agoGo on App Engine has been in beta for years
- dragonwriter 12y agoSure, a GA product like App Engine often has features that are in Alpha/Beta/Experimental states. That different than the major product being in a pre-release state.
- cmelbye 12y agoWhy? The point is, Google has a habit of releasing tons of shiny new Cloud Platform services (whether they're considered "separate products", part of an existing product, or whatever), but keeps them in alpha/beta for a long time. Go support has been there for years, and it's still "experimental". Some of the new products released last year at I/O 2014 are still in alpha, and we're already approaching I/O 2015. Pedantry aside, this deserves discussion.
- TeeWEE 12y agoWait, isnt google appengine already using SPDY?
- bingobob 12y agoHTTP/2 is replacing SPDY http://blog.chromium.org/2015/02/hello-http2-goodbye-spdy-http-is_9.html http://blog.chromium.org/2015/02/hello-http2-goodbye-spdy-ht...
- humanarity 12y agoCloudFlare hosts reddit, is that correct?
- nezo 12y agoYou're right!
- humanarity 12y ago:)
- zuck9 12y agoYes. The NS records list reddit nameservers (usually you need to use CF nameservers for using their service, using your own nameservers require more config) but the A records list CF IPs (free users just get two IPs, reddit has quite a lot) reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.143 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.141 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.137 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.139 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.143 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.142 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.139 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.141 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.138 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.140 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.138 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.137 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.142 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.208.140 reddit.com. 22 IN A 198.41.209.136
- humanarity 12y agoSo is that like load-balancing out from reddit.com to all those IPs, is that the purpose of so many?
- breakingcups 12y agoHuh, interesting. I didn't even know they'd allow you to do that. I assumed CF requires full DNS control to allow quickly switching over IP's in case of DOS and such.
- zuck9 12y ago
- nulltype 12y agoHow is this different from before they were a GCP partner?
- Artemis2 12y agoIt sounds like they are now peering directly. Google could also be operating Cloudflare's [Railgun](https://www.cloudflare.com/railgun https://www.cloudflare.com/railgun) software at the edge of their network to reduce content transfer times.
- andygambles 12y agoSo is this basically GCP and Cloudflare peering with each other?
- throwaway000002 12y agoThis is sorta an internet architecture question for those in the know. Assuming there's no issue with client reachability/latency, what's stopping CloudFlare from having a single IP? Suppose the IP was behind a fat enough pipe, why not load balance behind it instead of DNS load-balancing in front of it (and additionally behind each as I presume now happens)? Also, if that IP was anycast then you could ignore the issue of client latency as well, assuming you have the necessary private network behind endpoints to manage state. If you don't like/can't solve the problem at the level of IP anycast, when not leverage a third-party anycast DNS and just have a few fixed IP for specific geographic locales, again with fat enough pipes and load balancing behind them. I guess what I'm saying is that there's no reason for an organization, a monolithic entity, to have more that a handful IP addresses at most.
- jgrahamc 12y ago1. Non-SNI based SSL means you need an IP per host. 2. People attack IP addresses. Handy to be able to change the IP address of a web site. 3. Countries block sites based on IP addresses. Handy to be able to move sites around to prevent collateral damage.
- throwaway000002 12y agoIn my defense, I was assuming SNI (aka the modern internet), and that the IP was reachable by those you care for it to be reachable by. Ignoring these issues, is there an "engineering" reason why a single IP won't work, in terms of, for example, hardware can't demultiplex the aggregate ingress volume of CloudFlare and handle DOS mitigation? I guess I'm asking this because of how woeful looking the "load-balancing" solutions are from the major cloud providers. I feel they way they're externally documented, and how their APIs are specified, hitting them with more than a 40Gbps fat-server's load of traffic will cause issues, regardless of how many hosts you have serving that load. I'd appreciate some insight from those who handle such crazy amounts of traffic.
- jgrahamc 12y agoIf you think of a connection is defined by the tuple (source_ip, source_port, destination_ip, destination_port) then you might run into problems if destination_ip was a single value, just because whatever hashing you are using/table lookups for connection management, DoS protection etc. etc. might have problems with the sheer size. We are doing a huge amount of traffic and I can imagine having to engineer around some things related to that. But the real issues are the ones that outline above.
- relaunched 12y agoI wonder if this is one of those strategic deals that would lead to an acquisition. With the push surrounding cloud and Google actively competing hard in this space, it would make a lot of sense.
- dmix 12y agoOh wow, Google is already on every site with Analytics, imagine if they were also the SSL host/WAF/CDN/DNS host for every major property? It would fit in well with their silent yet never ending reach across the internet.
- bigiain 12y agoAnd now we start to wonder even more - is Google just an unexpectedly profitable NSA front?
- ryanlol 12y agoProblem is that (besides for the brand) Cloudflare really has nothing to offer for Google. Google has spent the last 20 years solving the same problems CF is aiming to solve, they've even got a competing service Google PageSpeed that does exactly what CF does, except better (in my personal experience.).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rgbrenner 12y agothey've even got a competing service Google PageSpeed that does exactly what CF does You mean this service? https://developers.google.com/speed/pagespeed/service https://developers.google.com/speed/pagespeed/service PageSpeed Service is in a limited field trial, and is not currently accepting new signups
- ryanlol 12y agoOh, I didn't know they closed signups. I've been using it for some personal projects for a good while (Since 2011 or so?) now.
- jhgg 12y agoWhat does this add? Before the partnership, could gce users not use cloudflare? Does the peering agreement result in lower transit costs on my gce bill?
- brandonwamboldt 12y agoDid you read the post, specifically the benefits section? Or the Google page they linked: https://www.cloudflare.com/google https://www.cloudflare.com/google It sounds like they now have a peering agreement so Google can directly communicate with CloudFlare's network, resulting in 2x faster performance. It looks like that's the primary benefit (other than the regular benefits of CloudFlare).
- Jgrubb 12y ago3rd item under "Comments" -- https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jhgg 12y agoThey never actually say that the peering agreement results in 2x faster performance, just that they use SPDY for 2x speed (which is something they've been doing for a while now). >2x Web Performance Speed - CloudFlare uses advanced caching and the SPDY protocol to double web content transfer speeds, making web content transfer times significantly faster.
- touhonoob 12y agoDirect Peering Costs: NA: $0.04/GB EU: $0.05/GB APAC: $0.06/GB
- nivla 12y agoRecently I have been getting cautious about Cloudflare. I do use them and like them a lot, also enjoy reading their technical blogposts. However from a privacy stand point it makes me feel uneasy. Cloudflare is just everywhere now: HN, Stackoverflow, Reddit and countless other sites. You can block a cookie, connection to a third party script, but how do you block an internal proxy? All your cookies, credentials, heck even HTTP request and response goes through them. Also why is there cloudflare specific cookie (__cfduid) on sites may not prefer tracking users? (eg: HN) Maybe I am just being paranoid...
- jgrahamc 12y agoWhat CloudFlare logs: https://blog.cloudflare.com/what-cloudflare-logs/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/what-cloudflare-logs/
- jsprogrammer 12y agoHowever, there is no way to verify that is all they log. CloudFlare gets to see the cleartext of all traffic they serve as they MITM HTTPS connections.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 15155 12y agoFrom an engineering feasibility/cost standpoint: there is no scenario in which they could log (as in packet capture) and dedupe all traffic without a nation-state-like (alphabet orgs, interested companies a la Google) budget. CloudFlare's (non-enterprise) prices simply aren't even in the required order of magnitude. Now: whether or not metadata, request bodies, etc. are logged, and to what scale, is another story/discussion of possibility. At some small, targeted scale, it's safe to say that total duplication (certainly request bodies, etc.) is possible, if they were so interested.
- nivla 12y agoThank you for the link. It was a simple and yet detailed. Wish more companies took time to explain parts of their privacy policy. However my concern is more to do with thinking as an outsider. I have toyed with idea of a company that requires establishment of trust among users. Although it may seem as simple as do no evil on the surface, it is an extremely hard undertaking. The thing with Cloudflare is that its niche is its own problem, "Man in the Middle", even if I were to place trust in the privacy policy, there are other things I need to be worried about. What if there is a break in and a hacker places a sniffer to sniff the communication between Cloudflare and the client sites? Sure the client followed the best practices such as, one way hash, strong crypto (eg bcrypt), 1000+ iterations, database encryption, https communication, etc but all of it is pointless or redundant now because the browser ends up sending the password in plaintext. Now imagine if instead of an hacker its a govt agency and that too with a gag order. See my concern?
- runn1ng 12y agoI misread the title and thought that Google has acquired CloudFlare. And that made me a little uneasy.
- cmelbye 12y agoDo we have to do anything special to make this work? We've already been using CloudFlare with our App Engine application, using a CNAME in CloudFlare DNS.
- growthape 12y agoCloudways also became Google Cloud Platform Technology partner. And the invester in more than 10 cloud companies Ben Kepes wrote about it on Forbes. http://www.forbes.com/sites/benkepes/2015/02/04/cloudways-adds-google-compute-engine-to-its-application-hosting-platform/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/benkepes/2015/02/04/cloudways-ad... And that's what they have built using Google Cloud Platform: http://www.cloudways.com/en/managed-google-compute-engine.php http://www.cloudways.com/en/managed-google-compute-engine.ph...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tux 12y agoGood time to stop using CloudFlare now :-) Thanks for the heads up OP.