3 ms·
As a young person living in the UK, it seems to me as if 'social mobility' is the zeitgeist, for lack of a better term. Everyone's talking about it. There are
by stegosaurus 12y ago
As a young person living in the UK, it seems to me as if 'social mobility' is the zeitgeist, for lack of a better term. Everyone's talking about it.
There are two main issues I have with the idea. The first is that it presupposes a system in which some people are poor, and as long as it's possible for some of those poor people to climb out, we're doibg okay. I don't think that the issues surrounding that are worthy of further comment.
The other problem is that under capitalism it's fundamentally impossible outside of limited cases of entrepreneurism.
In order for a working class person to have the same lifestyle as a higher status person, they must not only match, but exceed the expectation placed upon an otherwise equal higher status person, because they have a head start.
Take homeownership in the UK. A 20something that has had a leg up into the housing market via parental donation or loan has an entrenched advantage forever. I could earn 60K GBP whilst my middle class (via birth) friends earn 40K and forever be 'behind' them in wealth terms.
I don't really have much more to say on the topic because I'm not sure how it could be fixed or what that even means, but it's been a central theme in my life since attending University.
- scalesolved 12y agoThis is so very true, I earn more than a lot of my friends and save more but I'm one of the only ones that doesn't own a house as I never came into a lump sum. I guess you just need to work with what you've got!
- stegosaurus 12y agoIndeed, I've found a way to come to terms with it, but what does bug me is any sort of political discourse that seemingly ignores it entirely. The idea seems to be that poor kids go off to University, get well paid jobs, and that's the end of the story. Except it's not, because my 'well paid' is far higher that of someone who isn't paying rent. Income inequality is a non issue to me. Wealth inequality is the problem.