3 ms·
Not necessarily. I thought about this from the beginning with News.YC, because I didn't want that to happen here. The solution I came up with is to pick a gro
by pg 19y ago
Not necessarily. I thought about this from the beginning with News.YC, because I didn't want that to happen here. The solution I came up with is to pick a group of smart people as editors and weight everyone else's votes based on how much they overlap with the editors'. Then as long as the editors don't vote for dumb stories, they won't take over the front page.
I don't have this turned on, but I do have something in the code that shows me where stories would rank if I did. The good news is that, as of right now, the front page wouldn't look significantly different if vote weighting were turned on.
- brk 19y agoBut this site is also much more targeted than a digg or reddit or mixx type of site. I think if you stick to any given topic (hacking, politics, biotech, environmental, etc.) you have a lesser chance of the site becoming a giant cesspool of repeated lame topics.
- izak30 19y agoSo then: someone should make "voteupronpaulstories.com" and "allyourronpaularebelongtous.com" and "this-is-where-you-vote-on-videos-and-NSFW-content.com" to make reddit and digg better.
- waleedka 19y agoInteresting. I reached the same conclusion. I start by inviting trusted friends and friends of friends to sign up to the community before it's open to the public, and use their voting data as a base to measure against. And, of course, continued tweaking is also required. It's not 100% democratic because a selected few set the tone of the community, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Seems to work great in news.yc.
- robg 19y agoAs I've thought more about it, it sticks in my head: Have you tried weighting votes by the voter's karma? Use some floor for overall karma, or a logistic function, and you let the community be the editors. It could drift over time, but it would take a while to move significantly if at all. I'm willing to bet that the community principles would continue to drive submissions and votes. That inertia creates a stable orbit. The editors seem like great training wheels and a good sanity check over time. But I'm really curious if they become irrelevant as the community takes on life. Seems like you could test this hypothesis by using karma-votes to predict edited-votes. Drift could then be measured as that prediction varies from the edited standard.
- aswanson 19y agoA karma weighted neural network. A variant of pagerank. The only thing to worry about is if the karma based penalty function is a good gauge of quality or just activity.
- robg 19y agoIt needn't be as complicated as a neural net. Just calculate the difference between the editor-based points to each story and the karma-weighted points. I bet that's a closer match than the current no-weight version. If you played with the function, you could even try to approximate the editors from the users. And the beauty here of karma is that it inherently isn't just activity. Fundamentally it is a gauge of quality because people make informed decisions on what to value when they vote. For instance, you could submit every story, every day, from digg's front page and this community won't reward you (much). Better to make more informed decisions about what to submit, if you value your time. The goal isn't submission - it's submission to a community standard.
- queensnake 19y agoNo, the tabloid posters' karma would go up (presumably) and so their postings would get stronger. (I reason that if tabloid stuff got voted down, people would post less of it, so it must be finding an audience.) My personal tactic is to be nasty to posters of crap. It has more impact than some mere 'point', and gives them guidance as to what's wrong.
- robg 19y agoOnly to the extent that the community appreciates (and up-votes) what you think of as tabloid postings. Karma is a function of every submission (and comment). If the submissions aren't appreciated, neither will be the user. If a community mind has already set in, it should, in theory, be hard to shake free of that standard.
- rms 19y agoBeing nasty to posters of articles that don't meet your definition of Hacker News sounds like a terrible idea to me. Spam/personally linkjacked articles are different.
- iamelgringo 19y agoI wasn't thinking about this regarding YC news's quality. It's remained amazingly stable since I've been using it. I was thinking about this regarding Reddit, and how the signal to noise ration seems to be degrading even more recently. The main reddit is fairly unusable for me now, although I like the science and programming sub-reddits. I was asking for ideas for future reference regarding sites with social components. It seems to be a common problem online: how to avoid the troll issue and signal to noise degradation issue. I was thinking that votes could be weighted based on length of stay, or karma or both. Users who've been around longer and who had higher karma are obviously more invested in the site than hoards of users that just started. @PG: I really hadn't thought of weighting everyone's votes similar to the editors. A nice, elegant solution I think.
- bayareaguy 19y agoIt seems we have nickb to thank for reposting just the good stuff from reddit here.