2 ms·
We try to charge people with crimes they actually commit. DUI is a crime because of the actual harm caused by drunk driving. CFAA make exceeding authorized acce
by zaroth 12y ago
We try to charge people with crimes they actually commit. DUI is a crime because of the actual harm caused by drunk driving. CFAA make exceeding authorized access a crime too, and I suppose there are even corollaries to DUI where "exceeding access" could cause inadvertent harm as well, but certainly not in the case of a teacher's desktop background.
The CFAA used to have a $5,000 minimum damages inflicted before the offense was actually a felony, but that was eliminated in 2008 (according to Wikipedia). It would certainly be a miscarriage of justice if this is actually proceeded as a felony charge; just like a first-time offense blowing a .04 needn't be a big deal either.
The problem here isn't actually the charge, it's the law. When you have to ignore the law in order to avoid imposing ruinous charges for inconsequential pranks, it's a clear sign the law should be changed.
States are just starting to figure this out for adolescent drug charges it's a wonder we're going in the opposite direction with computers.
- FireBeyond 12y agoI get that (in another life I'm a paramedic who responds to both numerous DUI stops, and MVAs caused by same). DUI is, however a crime, regardless of the harm caused by that instance of drunk driving. Again, without judgment (I have little sympathy for this kid - he had repeated warnings and in-house punishments and continued to do these things, but I think a lot of computer crime is severely punished due to a failure to understand on a technical level what was going on) - is there any inclination that the prosecution believes that they're imposing "ruinous charges for inconsequential pranks" (or are they, as I said, satisfied with their approach)?