4 ms·
I am not downvoting you or flaming you, as you are trying to engage in a debate, not being "needlessly negative". However, that's a rubbish argument ... (Sligh
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
I am not downvoting you or flaming you, as you are trying to engage in a debate, not being "needlessly negative".
However, that's a rubbish argument ... (Slight flaming then)
raising children is a good argument for stable marriage, irrespective of sexuality, and history is full of non typical arrangements (raised by grandparents, adoptive parents, neighbours etc)
Homosexuality has been more or less socially acceptable at different times as well (from nearly compulsory in Sparta or Ancient Greece to well he is the king, so we may as well)
No, the case against gay marriage has always been the case against dissent and the case for obedience to a central authority. It seems there are "social norms" at the case by case level and those at the official lip service level. A society that has less dissonance between those in my opinion has less tolerance for dissonance between other stances (like superstition vs science).
- cubano 12y agoI am not downvoting you or flaming you, as you are trying to engage in a debate, not being "needlessly negative". I appreciate that...without honest discussion this whole site is suspect, IMHO. I am all for homosexuality if that is your thing! But I'm sticking to my guns...for most of human history it was impossible for a man to have a child with a man, or a women with a women. That is a simple fact. The idea marriage wasn't a social construct with the primary purpose of creating a situation that would optimize the creating AND caring of offspring seems just as factual to me. Now of course, one can parse the whole of history and find exceptions and all that...that's fine, great in fact! And yes, there is no doubt in the Judeo-Christian framework, obedience meant control, but I believe in this case you are totally throwing out the real biological basis with the bullshit one.