7 ms·
Teenager Charged with Felony for Changing Teacher's Desktop Photo
- lnlyplnt 12y agoI hope this doesn't mean what it sounds like: "The school district spokesperson said that "our information technology department is working to get all our passwords centralized."
- lectrick 12y agoIn all likelihood, it means exactly what it sounds like. :/
- asuffield 12y ago> The school district spokesperson said that "our information technology department is working to get all our passwords centralized." I think I can see the problem here.
- nickysielicki 12y agoI'm sure everyone on HN that is young enough to have had computers while in highschool has gone through this bullshit of fighting tech-illiterate adults what constitutes using a computer. Most of them are not aware that there are productive ways to use computers outside of Microsoft Office and IE. I shit you not, I used to get logged off by the dumbass librarian for opening Idle and playing with python. White on black text means I must have been up to no good. It's so clear to me that this kid actually is a hacker. Just in the Stallman sense of the word. I suspect he's just like any of us were at his age-- completely and utterly in love with computers. He was suspended before from using computers, and he found a way around it. You know what that says to me? He's got the knack.[1] Highschool is a waste of this guys time. We should have him in a CS program somewhere. Instead, he's got a few more years of hell. What bothers me is the heavy handedness of this. He had been suspended for 3 days before. He's suspended now for 10 days. He's going to have to go to court. This has effects on this young mans life that we may not have a huge appreciation for. The result might culminate as a slip in his grades. It might be as much as having to transfer schools and becoming a social outcast. It might be the stress it places on his relationship with his parents, which shamefully have to show up to court. But the point is this is a smart kid that is being punished for existing in a fucked up education system, and his future success in that system is at stake. And most unfortunately, his success in that system will dictate what college he gets into, what job he gets, and what his life will be. That bothers me so much. I wish I could reach out, tell his parents to not punish him, and encourage him to get his GED and not let this ruin his life. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60P1xG32Feo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=60P1xG32Feo
- libraryatnight 12y agoI agree. It seems reasonable to punish within the school system - a detention, something along those lines, but legal action feels ridiculous. Pranks and things of this nature are commonplace at that age, and computers are a modern vehicle for those pranks.
- Symbiote 12y agoI found the administrator password for my school's NT network, in 1997 or so. It was "changeme". I think the only thing I used it for was to re-enable right clicking in Windows for my user account. (It was blocked, I don't know why.) Many months later, another boy changed the password. I think he got detention, and probably a ban from using the computers outside lessons.
- smt88 12y agoI agree that the way they treated this kid is insane, but you seem to have invented a persona for him that wasn't supported by the article at all. There's no indication that he particularly likes computers, let alone that he's "completely and utterly in love with them". He basically just noticed that the IT department had stupid password policies and messed around on other people's accounts. He himself could be mostly tech-illiterate. There's also no evidence that high school is a waste of this kid's time. If he's doing stupid, immature shit like this, he does need a structured environment where he has good role models. This particular high school may not be the right one for him, but he does need one. And he wasn't suspended before for using the computers. He was suspended for getting into other people's accounts.
- nickysielicki 12y ago> "The student had previously been suspended three days from school for similarly accessing computers without permission." To me, that says he used a computer when he was otherwise banned from it. And that's where I'm getting this persona from. Yeah, I'm reading into it, and you're right to call me out on this. I still think he's probably close to what I'm describing, and I'm sure he's wanting to study compsci at some level.
- libraryatnight 12y ago"The school district spokesperson said that 'our information technology department is working to get all our passwords centralized.'" Seems like a better response would be to go over password best practices. I imagine their IT is responsible for the passwords being last names in the first place. They're probably centralizing all the passwords in a safe protected with Password12345.
- ghshephard 12y agoAn even better process would be to role out circa 1995 two-factor tokens.
- jqm 12y agoSome terminations are in order over that policy. But hey.. who am I kidding? It's an IT department in a public school. Incompetence isn't something punishable.
- danneu 12y ago> "Even though some might say this is just a teenage prank, > who knows what this teenager might have done," [Sheriff] Nocco said. The local authorities? > However, local authorities say that the student didn't > open the FCAT files, nor did he change grades even > though he was capable of doing so after accessing > the teacher's computer.
- zaroth 12y ago"Who knows what this teenager might have done" must be the most brain-dead quote I've read today. Who knows what someone might do? Yes, exactly, who knows! I mean, not that this astounding logical null of a statement really surprises me coming from law enforcement, but what the actual fuck? Edit: It appears the quote has been removed from the article, but still on other sites reporting the same story.
- jacquesm 12y agoAnd plenty of comments here parrot exactly that same nonsense. What he might have done is totally un-important, what he did is what matters.
- GotAnyMegadeth 12y agoOne time someone logged onto one of the grumpiest teacher's accounts at college and sent an email out to everyone saying "I love you x". We were in class and he had just finished a presentation and was still projecting his desktop behind him. Notifications were popping up saying "I love you too!" every second. So funny. Poor guy.
- mahouse 12y agoWell. One of my teachers used to configure a shared network folder for us to upload our assignments when the class was finishing. That was back when Windows allowed you to change the background of a folder, so every day I changed the background to a black image so he would not be able to read the file names. He then learned how the wizard I was using to do it looked like [1], so he started to look at me when the class was about to end to yell at me for doing it. Therefore I had to use a workaround: I prepared a copy of the `desktop.ini' file that would set that black background and hid it around the disk drive, then I would just copy it to the "Incoming" folder :-) And it would just look like I was copying my assignment. [1] https://i.imgur.com/2AQscKC.png https://i.imgur.com/2AQscKC.png
- cxseven 12y agoMeanwhile, following the Sony hacks, the executive branch is pushing a "Tough on CyberCrime" bill tripling penalties for all sorts of nonsense that has become felonious "unauthorized computer use", e.g. sharing HBO passwords, posting "Let's Play" videos, or underage use of Facebook in violation of TOS. In addition, "violating norms of conduct" would become a crime. This should help bring prisons back up to capacity as the drug war scales back. The EFF, as usual, is trying to organize against this BS: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/obamas-computer-security-solution-mish-mash-old-outdated-policy-solutions https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/01/obamas-computer-securi... As an aside, it's sad how quickly Aaron Swartz is fading from memory, including on Reddit, which he helped build. He also worked hard to build open syndication with RSS, which has been crushed by Google and Facebook building up incompatible walled gardens.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Avernar 12y agoHow times have changed. I used to figure out the admin password all the time. It was actually a game between me and the computer teacher. I didn't even have to see the keyboard but just his arms moving back and forth. Eventually he gave up and put me to work doing maintenance and new software installs. :) So back then I got experience being a Novel Netware admin while today I'd be suspended and facing charges.
- hurin 12y agoWindows has lots of easy windows (?!) for getting administrator privileges without any password - Or at least had (haven't used it for a few iterations except on rare occasions). Also from my experience all of the sand-boxing software I ever saw at libraries or schools was always very poorly designed and trivially subvertible. Felony charges are absolutely nuts though.
- ehmmm 12y agoYeah... I also think you are drawing your information from the Windows 95 era.
- pizzeys 12y agoDo you think privilege escalation is unusual on Windows now, then? :)
- ehmmm 12y agoLoaded question.
- hurin 12y agoBack in middle-school; the public library nearby installed 4-5 new machines down on a lower level for word-processing (they were better than my home pc even), so pretty soon we had Unreal Tournament installed on every machine, and that would be our goto spot after school. Once in a while someone would get banned from the library for a couple weeks (I think other kids that saw us started playing as well, so it was hard for them to identify a culprit), they would call in IT, overhaul their computers and we'd be back to laning a month later once things cooled off.
- fuckedapanda 12y agowe have become so irrational
- noonespecial 12y agoHas "felony" lost its meaning yet and just become another synonym for "poor", "underclass", or "different" or do we have another 2 or 3 weeks to go still?
- zaroth 12y agoIt should be a felony to charge a teenager with a felony for such nonsense. Criminal mischief on behalf of the DA.
- tim333 12y agoYeah, or Sherrif rather - >Pasco County Sherrif Chris Nocco decided to use Green as an example, saying to the Tampa Bay Times, “If information comes back to us and we get evidence (that other kids have done it), they’re going to face the same consequences.” http://thelibertarianrepublic.com/unbelievable-boy-changes-teachers-desktop-picture-felony-charges-filed/ http://thelibertarianrepublic.com/unbelievable-boy-changes-t...
- zura 12y agoHuh, many years ago some Ad company asked me to write a "virus" that when the user opens some particular website, the desktop wallpaper should change after the user restarts the computer... Of course I refused, but I did implement it just for fun - some win32 app launching on system startup. The app itself was transported through ajax, and executed through Shell.Application object, all done in js. This worked in IE, including IE6. Needless to say, that code never left my PC.
- hrayr 12y ago"The teen was able to access the teacher's computer because he noticed that faculty members were each given unique, obvious passwords: Their own last name." The level of legal response should be directly proportional to the level of stupidity of the IT department. This should have been a slap on the wrist not a felony.
- A_COMPUTER 12y agoWhen I kept breaking into computers on the school network in the early 1990's, they got me to stop causing trouble by making me an intern for the sysadmin. I had years of legitimate tech experience before I graduated high school, which helped me get a leg up over other people when I looked for summer work in other computer-related jobs during university. So instead of being labeled a juvenile delinquent or made a felon, I was accelerated toward being a productive member of society.
- littletimmy 12y agoI suppose changing the screensaver would've gotten him life without parole. Was he black?
- bayesianhorse 12y agoDid he really break into a secured computer system? For a teenager without a sophisticated grasp on ethical and legal implications of computer usage, and a modest amount of curiosity, this "hacking" incident wasn't much more than stepping over an invisible line.
- milesf 12y agoIt ought to be a felony for the School District to use such weak passwords. Sadly, having worked in a school district myself as a tech, this is par for the course. Many educators seem to love teaching, but hate learning. Not all of course, but enough to poison the culture.
- pinkunicorn 12y agoI really used to admire a girl at college a lot.. We had UNIX labs where you didn't have a GUI but just a Putty to a RHEL5 server in which each of us had an account. Once I was asked to help figure out the girl with something, and after doing it I just inserted this line into her .bashrc "echo "You are awesome!"". Everytime she logged in(we had two one hour sessions a week), she used to get that message. There was also another guy I disliked and I just inserted "exit" into his .bashrc. Even the sysadmin couldn't figure out why his terminal was quitting as soon as it was opened and they finally had to delete his user account and then re-create it.
- chrismcb 12y agoThis issue isn't about the prank, nor the picture, it is about the fact that the kid could have accessed the standardized test. I think the school is negligent. They did a poor job of securing a valuable piece of property. They allowed too many people to have access to that valuable property. And finally they involved the police in a situation that the police didn't need to be involved in, potentially ruining the life if a child they are legally in charge of.
- threatofrain 12y agoTo be fair, the child could have ruined the life of the teacher by revealing them as a secret homosexual who engaged in sexual activity on school grounds. It's part of a teacher's job description in America to be 1000 miles from anything remotely sexual. And heavens forbid there is an association to homosexuality. At that point, saying "it wasn't me!" is foolish for the teacher. It's better to lay a trail of legal evidence pointing to someone else's clear culpability. From an outside perspective, I would always reserve the possibility that the teacher is a liar and made up a story about hacking to cover for their sexuality. But when part of the story becomes court record, then I am far more willing to trust the teacher.
- threatofrain 12y agoI'm pretty sure that where the teen stepped over the line is in endangering a teacher with a potential reputation as a sexual danger to children. I'm surprised there isn't more discussion of that. Note that it does not matter what we, a liberal audience, might think about homosexuality. What matters is what kids and parents think, and I have found both groups to be champions of boundary-policing and conformity-enforcement. If the young person didn't pose such a risk to the teacher's financial security, then there wouldn't have been such an issue. Now the teacher has to lay a trail of official evidence which shows that he is not secretly homosexual, and did not engage in sexual activities within a teenage context. Both the school and the teacher need to be sure that at a later time, an issue does not arise where the teacher's secret homosexual activities on school grounds is in question.