4 ms·
It's not possible to pay soldiers a reasonable amount of money. If you pay them too much, you basically get an army of mercenaries, while the personal sacrifice
by mseebach 17y ago
It's not possible to pay soldiers a reasonable amount of money. If you pay them too much, you basically get an army of mercenaries, while the personal sacrifice any soldier send into harms way endures is impossible to truly translate to money.
We entrepreneurs often talk of our way of life as something we choose quite explicitly over financial security. I'm pretty sure the success of an army depends a lot on it's soldiers thinking roughly the same way about their chosen path.
Finally, my impression is that the United States is build on a certain mentality that's difficult for us Europeans to fully grasp. The country was founded by people fleeing from prosecution and suppression, and it's first war was fought against that same suppression trying to catch up. That mentality lies pretty deep in Americans, as I understand. It has nothing to do with cheating people into collecting our garbage and manning 24-hour convenience stores.
It's a shame that thankfulness to esp. US and UK troops isn't better founded in western European minds, and that it's only brought up when trying to justify a new war. Fact is that 400.000 Americans died in WWII, without whom my German would probably be a lot better. There's a D-day burial ground in Normandy. Any European should make a point of visiting it sometime (I haven't yet) -- especially before making high-brow intellectual rants against war.
- oiubhn 17y agoAs long as you remember that it's a mentality of sacrifice that led to 183,000 Americans dying in Europe, but it's facist totalitarianism that led to 10.7M Russians doing the same. 4 out of the 5million German military casualties were on the Eastern Front, The Russian army had a not insignificant role in Germany's defeat.
- mseebach 17y agoThat's a fair point, probably clouded by the fact that the Soviet Union was, at first, an ally to Nazi Germany, and eventually celebrated its victory by forcibly annexing eastern Europe and the dozen of million people living there as a buffer against western Europe.
- Tichy 17y agoSorry, it is a touchy subject and I am certainly thankful to the troops who freed us, too. I don't have a good answer - not all wars can be avoided, but I certainly wouldn't want to encourage anybody to become a soldier. If I really believed in the cause, I might become a soldier, too, though. I think many soldiers are from poor backgrounds, though. Not sure how many chose to become a soldier for the excitement, or because it offers them a good chance at a better life. Again sorry, I don't have good answers. Overall, though, I think words are cheap and improving pay is maybe better. Soldiers provide a service to society, society should pay.
- jacquesm 17y agoRecruiters in the US routinely target the poor.
- Maktab 17y agoAccording to one Heritage Foundation study[1], US military enlistees tend to come disproportionately from middle class backgrounds. They found that only 11% of enlisted recruits came from the poorest quintile of neighbourhoods in the US. While the Heritage Foundation is not an entirely neutral institution, its methodology in this study seems fairly sound. And its findings don't support the popular belief that American soldiers are disproportionately poor and ill-educated and only joined because they had no alternatives. Anecdotally, I've found this to be true for all of the American soldiers I have met and spoken to about their backgrounds and their reasons for enlisting. [1] - http://www.heritage.org/Research/NationalSecurity/cda08-05.cfm http://www.heritage.org/Research/NationalSecurity/cda08-05.c...