9 ms·
And frankly by the late 80s the 680000 architecture itself had hit a dead end performance wise. Maybe Motorola could have pulled off what Intel did with Pentium
by cmrdporcupine 12y ago
And frankly by the late 80s the 680000 architecture itself had hit a dead end performance wise. Maybe Motorola could have pulled off what Intel did with Pentium, paper over the aging CISC with RISC internals, but instead we got PowerPC.
I'm not sure if you ever used a PowerPC Mac when they were a mix of emulated 68k and PowerPC, but they were notoriously unstable. The mix of a lack of memory protection and emulated CPU instructions would have been the same for the Amiga and Atari ST whose OSs also lacked memory protection and safety features of more modern operating systems.
I have an Atari Falcon 030, Atari's last and best machine. It is a really really nice machine. But it was hobbled by poor software support -- it's only now that hackers are discovering what they can do with the combination of the 68030 and the Motorola 56k DSP in it (Example: Quake 3 has been ported/rewritten recently for it, using the 56k for 3d acceleration.)
I used to wonder what the world would have been like if the 68000 systems won out. But now we're seeing a world where the ARM belatedly wins out, which is kind of neat, tho ARM is arguably now as "evil" as Intel :-)
What is an interesting mental exercise is imagining what would have happened if the 6502 or 6809 architectures had expanded and done well. Those architectures had insanely fast interrupt processing and very fast (single CPU cycle) memory access. Some really neat machines could have been made if they'd continued to advance them, gotten past the 64k memory address limit and into high clock rates. Western Design stopped at the 65c816, a 16-bit variant of the 6502. Something faster and funner than the Amiga could have been built with a 32-bit 6502 descendant and chipsets similar to what was in the Amiga. That would have been really neat.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 12y agoMaybe Motorola could have pulled off what Intel did with Pentium, paper over the aging CISC with RISC internals, but instead we got PowerPC. I think one of the factors could be that 68k is a bit harder to decode than x86 - while the instruction set is more orthogonal, the encoding has less structure; compare http://goldencrystal.free.fr/M68kOpcodes.pdf http://goldencrystal.free.fr/M68kOpcodes.pdf (68k) with http://i.stack.imgur.com/07zKL.png http://i.stack.imgur.com/07zKL.png (x86). very fast (single CPU cycle) memory access That was possible only because at the time, memory was faster than the core and could keep up. Modern CPUs run the core at several times memory speeds, and there is latency involved due to physical constraints.
- digi_owl 12y agoYep. The one thing Intel frets over these days is cache misses. Hyperthreading is all about keeping that pipeline busy even if the original thread encounter a cache miss.
- ghostberry 12y agoOne difference between Motorola and Intel, is Motorola was less concerned with breaking backwards compatibility. If the 68k family had continued to evolve past the 1994s 68060, I'm sure they could have just dropped backwards compatibility to some of the more complex addressing modes, or just devoted less silicon to them, and making what remains faster. Kinda like happened with the ColdFire version of the 68k family.
- rbanffy 12y agoThe not-implemented instruction trapping in the 68K could be easily evolved to cover less frequently used instructions to make room for more optimized implementations of the frequently used ones. What really killed the 68000 was the move to RISC, in particular Apple's move to PowerPC. That took away any hope of future evolution (they even managed to release the 68060 after that, but that was it) and collapsed the high-end 68K business.
- rogerbinns 12y agoNote that Motorola also did the m88k which was their RISC approach. It generated a bit of interest, but was never successful. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_88000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motorola_88000 The Motorola Series 900 machines were interesting - I had one under my desk at work for quite a while. They had stackable units, including one that contained a SCSI 3.5" floppy drive that was way faster than regular ones. We also had a DG unit with the m88k.
- stox 12y agoA lot of what was the 88K was put into the PowerPC.
- mwcampbell 12y agoWhen you say ARM is now as "evil" as Intel, are you referring to processor architecture, business practices, or both?
- jejones3141 12y ago>What is an interesting mental exercise is imagining what would have happened if the 6502 or 6809 architectures had expanded and done well. It was, but for some reason Hitachi didn't publicize it, and word only escaped years too late: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitachi_6309 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitachi_6309
- cmrdporcupine 12y agoYep I have some here, and there's even a board for putting it and the 6809 into Atari 8-bit computers (!). It's a fine processor, but limited to 64k address space still. But fast, and fun to play with.
- fit2rule 12y ago>(Example: Quake 3 has been ported/rewritten recently for it, using the 56k for 3d acceleration.) Wow, what is that like? I'd love to see a demo video .. know of one?
- throwawaymylife 12y agoSeems to be this (Quake 2, not 3, and still in development): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDXSMgW-r5M&index=1&list=PLNs6Jw4V4vlvafSs0H3Ww_M5nMm10m0UM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hDXSMgW-r5M&index=1&list=PLN...
- cmrdporcupine 12y agoYes, sorry, Quake 2. Long thread here: http://www.atari-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=68&t=26775 http://www.atari-forum.com/viewtopic.php?f=68&t=26775
- rasz_pl 12y agoYour last paragraph describes first ARM chip :) ARM was all that(fast interrupts, fast ram) and more (30k hand laid transistors). It took a while, but ARM is taking over from the bottom up, making Intel ignore highend and concentrate all of its efforts on power efficiency (raw performance all but stopped in last 5 years).
- kjs3 12y agoMaybe Motorola could have pulled off what Intel did with Pentium, paper over the aging CISC with RISC internals They did; that's what the mc68060 was. Too little, too late and (as you say) corporate attention directed at PPC.