4 ms·
"Use a password manager" still seems to be the right answer for frictionless logins. "Easy" is requirement #1 to get people to use a thing. In fact, using it
by Terretta 12y ago
"Use a password manager" still seems to be the right answer for frictionless logins. "Easy" is requirement #1 to get people to use a thing. In fact, using it should be easier than not using it.
If you use 1Password, it nails the password details that trip up the "shady" password managers you allude to. See this study about stealing passwords or credit cards from users of auto fill password managers:
https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~suman/publications/suman_pwdmgr.pdf https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~suman/publications/suman_pwdmgr.p...
Interestingly, the Safari built in keychain is better to protect cc.
- homakov 12y agoyou're free to use any password manager. my scheme is for developers to build better authentication
- stephenr 12y agobut it just isn't better though. it's worse in the way that developers should be worried about most: security.
- homakov 12y agoHow exactly is it worse if it's not different from classic scheme?
- stephenr 12y agoyou're removing something which people basically understand the concept of - passwords: keep them fucking secret/safe - and trying to replace it with something that is built on top of a system never meant to work that way. If your system routinely sends out OTP emails, all it takes is someone to intercept those emails on their way from your SMTP server out to the wider internet, and every fucking user is breached. The only reason password reset links are at all acceptable is because they are used relatively rarely and it's not predictable when they will be used.
- homakov 12y agoSo your point is it is less secure because the same weak feature is being used more frequently? > all it takes is someone to intercept those emails on their way from your SMTP server out to the wider internet it doesn't matter when some user will create a reset request. Because you can do it for him, right? There are tons of services out there generating a password for you and sending it over in plain text, which is exactly what I proposed. Do we see it heavily abused? The opposite is true - those services are more safe because they got rid of reused passwords. Also there's a bunch of techniques i didn't describe to prevent some attacks. When user is trying to login save a secret token1 in a cookie and send token2 to their email. When the user clicks this link verify old cookies. This makes passive global wiretapping less useful (if it was your concern). Still vulnerable to more targeted attacks (enter username, wait for email, reuse cookie), but so "reset password" is.
- stephenr 12y ago> it doesn't matter when some user will create a reset request. Because you can do it for him, right? only if I know the user's email address for this given service. with your system the attacker will get a regular flow of emails like this, and can even just track the emails as they're used, so as to then use them later to create a new authenticated session without arousing the suspicions of the user. even if an attacker was lucky enough to capture a password reset email, they either have to use it immediately (or it will become invalid) or do a later, second password reset. Either way, the user still knows at the very least that something isn't right. > There are tons of services out there generating a password for you and sending it over in plain text and this is fucking atrocious from a security stand point. > Do we see it heavily abused? The opposite is true - those services are more safe because they got rid of reused passwords. Care to name some? I'm not aware of any major service, website or application that relies on a OTP via email for primary authentication. > Still vulnerable to more targeted attacks (enter username, wait for email, reuse cookie), but so "reset password" is. You still don't seem to accept that knowing your account was compromised is a security feature. With your system there is potentially ZERO indication to the end user that their account has been compromised. That is FUCKING TERRIFYING to me, and that it isn't to you, is even MORE FUCKING TERRIFYING. Please stop making claims as if you have any fucking idea about security.