3 ms·
While it's true that "hindsight bias" is a thing, and should be guarded against, this kind of throw-away comment dismissing issues like this bothers me. We can
by ColinWright 12y ago
While it's true that "hindsight bias" is a thing, and should be guarded against, this kind of throw-away comment dismissing issues like this bothers me. We can similarly dismiss everything said by everyone prominent by referring to "Argument from Authority," as if that's a bad thing. But in truth, people with a great deal of experience sometimes rise to a position of authority purely because they tend to be right, and so Bayesian Analysis suggests that we really should give more weight to what they say.
Similarly here. Don't simply say "Oh, hindsight bias, this is completely irrelevant." If you don't provide some sort of evidence that this particular instance is "simply hindsight bias" then I will tend to dismiss what you say.
You may be right, but you have provided no evidence. Just a baseless accusation.
I was reluctant to say what follows, as I didn't want to be accused of an ad hominem attack, but I have decided to say it as I feel that it is information to be shared. In looking through your previous comments I see that you have a track record for providing a relentlessly negative response to things. There is value in that, as such critical and sceptical responses balance the relentless, boundless positive viewpoints of others, but it means that now I have a more informed context in which to interpret your contributions.